Adjudication Of Tenancy Rights Is Beyond Scope Of Proceedings U/S. 14 SARFAESI Act; Tenants’ Remedy Lies Before DRT: Kerala High Court
The Court held that the scope of inquiry by the CJM under Section 14 is constricted and that “any person” in Section 17(1) includes persons other than borrowers.
Justice S. Manu, Kerala High Court
The Kerala High Court has held that adjudication of tenancy rights is beyond the scope of proceedings under Section 14 of the SARFAESI Act before the Chief Judicial Magistrate. The Court said that a Section 14 proceeding is not purely a judicial proceeding and that the Magistrate’s scope of inquiry is constricted. It upheld the Magistrate’s refusal to restrain the dispossession of three occupants who claimed lease rights older than the mortgage.
The Court held that a tenant or any other aggrieved person must go to the Debts Recovery Tribunal under Section 17 of the Act, because the expression “any person” in Section 17(1) is wide enough to include persons other than the borrower. It dismissed the writ petition without prejudice to the petitioners’ right to pursue statutory remedies.
A Single Bench of Justice S. Manu observed, “…the proceedings under Section 14 of the SARFAESI Act is not purely judicial proceedings. Scope of inquiry by the Chief Judicial Magistrate in a proceeding under Section 14 is constricted. Therefore, I do not find any impropriety in the view of the learned CJM that adjudication of tenancy rights is beyond the scope of the proceedings under Section 14 of the Act”.
Advocate Rajit appeared for the petitioner and Advocate Madhu Radhakrishnan appeared for the respondent.
“…the learned CJM rightly observed that the expression “any person” employed in Section 17(1) of the SARFAESI Act is wide enough to include persons other than the borrowers also if they are aggrieved by the measures taken under the SARFAESI Act. Learned CJM hence held that the petitioners have to avail the remedy available under Section 17 of the Act. I affirm the view of the learned CJM as it is perfectly correct. Proper remedy of the petitioners is to approach the Debts Recovery Tribunal…”, it noted further.
The premises in Ward 11 of Kunnamkulam Municipality were mortgaged by respondents 2 to 7 to Axis Bank to secure a loan. After the loan was not repaid, the bank started SARFAESI proceedings and filed a complaint before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Thrissur, under Section 14. An Advocate Commissioner was appointed to take physical possession of the property.
The three petitioners, who run a hotel, a dairy shop and a stationery and cool drinks shop in the premises, filed a petition seeking an order restraining their eviction. They said their tenancies began before the mortgage and could be ended only under the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965.
The bank argued that the Magistrate could not decide rival claims of tenancy and that the remedy lay before the DRT. By order dated October 7, 2026, the Magistrate rejected the application, holding that the petitioners had shown no authority in the Court under the Act to recall, stay or modify orders under Section 14 on a disputed claim of tenancy, and that the statutory remedy could not be bypassed.
The petitioners challenged this order under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, placing reliance on Shaji v. Federal Bank (2015). The bank relied on Bajarang Shyamsunder Agarwal v. Central Bank of India & Anr. (2019), and said the lease periods had long expired and some deeds did not name the petitioners.
The Court said that interference under Article 226 is justified only if there is an illegality or impropriety in the order or the procedure. It noted that the Magistrate considered both sides and gave reasons. It said it prima facie found merit in the bank’s contention that the materials did not convincingly show valid subsisting tenancies. Accordingly, affirmed the Magistrate’s view and observed that the Magistrate left it open to the petitioners to approach the DRT or any other appropriate forum.
Cause Title: Yousuf Sidique & Ors. v. Axis Bank Ltd. & Ors. (Neutral Citation: 2026:KER:86722)
Appearances:
Petitioners: Advocates Rajit and Sruthi Rajit.
Respondent: Advocate Madhu Radhakrishnan.