Justice Vikram D. Chauhan, Allahabad High Court

While dropping proceedings against a man who was taken into custody for recording court proceedings without any authorisation or valid pass, the Allahabad High Court has held that no litigant would be permitted to enter the courtroom with mobile phones. 

The High Court was considering a matter where a person was found recording the Court proceedings from his mobile phone without permission of the Court.

The Single Bench of Justice Vikram D. Chauhan held, “Considering the aforesaid aspect of the matter and the fact that counsel has admitted to the mistake treating the same as being accepted by the counsel, the Court proceedings are hereby dropped. Sri Raj Kulshrestha is directed to be released forthwith. However, the directions contained in the order dated 19.11.2026 restricting from carrying the mobile phones to this Court room shall continue and no litigant would be permitted to enter the Court room along with the mobile phones. The mobile phones may be kept in the office of the concerned Advocate or may be kept somewhere else. Accordingly the Court proceedings are hereby dropped.”

Advocate Nitish Kumar Soni represented the Petitioner, while Government Advocate represented the State and Advocate Prayageshwar Kumar Upadhyay represented the Private Respondent.

Factual Background

The mobile phone of the aforesaid person (Raj Kulshrestha) was taken into custody by the Bench Secretary of the Court. After opening of the mobile phone, three videos of the Court proceedings were found to be recorded. He could not give the purpose of his conduct.

Reasoning

The Bench took note of the fact that Raj Kulshrestha could not explain as to why he was recording proceedings of the Court without permission. “Such an act is not permissible. Mr. Raj Kulshrestha has disclosed that he has no case listed before this Court. The pass which Mr. Raj Kulshrestha is carrying is a pass issued by the Registry of this Court only limited to the Advocate chamber. However, he has entered in the court room without a proper pass. He has not disclosed as to why he is present in the Court when his case is not listed and the purpose of recording court proceedings without permission of the Court”, it noted.

The Bench found it strange that unauthorised persons were travelling up to the Court without any valid Pass. “This Court is having jurisdiction of criminal cases. Various cases pertaining to liberty of an individual, child sexual abuse matters, CBI matters, Enforcement Directorate matters, MP/MLA matters are being listed and argued. These cases have facts which are not required to be published on the social media (without the determination by Court). The Court has inherent power to regulate its own procedure and maintain order”, it added.

Considering the fact that the counsel had admitted to the mistake, the Bench ordered the Court proceedings to be dropped. “The mobile phone of Sri Raj Kulshrestha shall be handed over to Sri Raj Kulshrestha after deleting the recording of the court proceedings and resetting the phone. Sri Raj Kulshrestha is hereby restrained from publishing any such video on the social media. The video in the pen drive shall be kept in a sealed cover”, it ordered.

Cause Title: Kuldeep Batra v. State of U.P. and Another (Matters Under Article 227 No. 14284 of 2026)

Petitioner: Advocate Nitish Kumar Soni 

Respondents: Government Advocate, Advocates Prayageshwar Kumar Upadhyay, Saurabh Singh

Click here to read/download Order


Tags: