Chief Justice Arun Bhansali, Justice Kshitij Shailendra, Allahabad High Court

While upholding an order setting aside a second show cause notice enhancing punishment of a Postal Assistant to that of ‘compulsory retirement’, the Allahabad High Court has held that the Central Administrative Tribunal can entertain a challenge to the notice issued without jurisdiction.

The High Court was considering a Petition challenging an order whereby the Central Administrative Tribunal, Allahabad Bench, Allahabad (Tribunal) had allowed the Original Application filed by the respondent setting aside the notice impugned therein.

The Bench comprising Chief Justice Arun Bhansali and Justice Kshitij Shailendra held, “The words "A Tribunal shall not ordinarily admit an application…..." appearing in sub-Section (1) of Section 20 of the Act of 1985 make it clear that such alleged bar against admission of an application can be invoked under ordinary circumstances where remedies against the action have not been availed of by the concerned applicant. However, in exceptional circumstances, like the one involved in the present case, the Tribunal can very well entertain a challenge to the notice issued without jurisdiction. Further, in our opinion, merely because the respondent filed response to the second SCN, the same would not mean that he had availed a ‘remedy against the notice’ or that only passing of an order based thereupon would give rise to a cause of action to him and not prior thereto. We, therefore, hold that the OA was maintainable”, it added.

Advocate Ashish Kumar represented the Petitioner while Advocate Vinod Kumar represented the Respondent.

Factual Background

The respondent was appointed as a Postal Assistant in 1996. He was placed under suspension vide an order dated June 10, 2002, whereafter a First Information Report was lodged against him and seven other persons, levelling allegations of embezzlement of funds. As regards the criminal case based upon the FIR, the respondent was acquitted therein by an order passed by the Trial Court. A departmental charge sheet was issued to the respondent on the same allegations on which the FIR was lodged against him. A departmental inquiry was conducted against the respondent, in which the charges were not found to be proved against him and, consequently, he was exonerated by the inquiry officer vide an inquiry report.

The Director of Postal Services, however, disagreed with the conclusion drawn by the inquiry officer and a fresh inquiry was conducted by another inquiry officer who submitted his report wherein also charges were not found proved against the respondent. There was another charge sheet issued to the respondent, which also formed the subject matter of another inquiry, wherein charges against the respondent were found to be proved, and the disciplinary authority passed a punishment order whereby the annual increment of the respondent for a period of two and a half years was stopped. The respondent accepted to undergo the said punishment and did not challenge the same.

About two and a half months after imposition of the above punishment, a show cause notice (first SCN) was issued to the respondent, purportedly under Rule 27 of Central Civil Services (Classification Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965 asking him to submit a reply on the point of enhancement of the above-imposed penalty to that of stoppage of increment for the next three years with cumulative effect and further recovery of Rs 50,000. The application giving rise to the writ petition was filed by the respondent challenging the second SCN with a further prayer to direct the petitioners not to interfere in his peaceful functioning on the post in question and further direct them to pay regular salary to him with all consequential benefits. The Tribunal stayed the second SCN, whereafter affidavits were exchanged inter se between the parties and, by final order, the application was allowed, setting aside the second SCN.

Reasoning

The Bench refused to accept the submissions made on behalf of the petitioners that the second SCN was independent of the first SCN, inasmuch as the second SCN contained specific reference not only to the first SCN but also to a representation submitted by the respondent against the first SCN. The Bench further noticed that the Tribunal stayed the second SCN, by which time also, the first SCN was in existence, and it was only thereafter that the petitioners might have been advised to withdraw the first SCN to take a plea before the Tribunal as if only the second SCN remained operative.

The Bench thus held that the issuance of the second SCN was without any statutory sanction in light of the proceedings pursuant to the first SCN being pending and dropping of proceedings post issuance of the second SCN which, by way of an interim order, was interfered with by the Tribunal and the first SCN was withdrawn after the interim order was passed by the Tribunal.

The Bench noted that the action of the petitioners in somehow proceeding to punish the respondent by way of an enhanced penalty was contrary to the scheme of Rules, 1965. “The exercise is found to have been undertaken to harass the respondent who was successively exonerated in previous inquiry proceedings and, at one point of time, had accepted and undergone minor punishment awarded to him on 20.07.2012”, it stated.

Thus, finding no ground to interfere with the order passed by the Tribunal, the Bench dismissed the writ petition.

Cause Title: Union of India and 2 others v. Pramod Singh Yadav and another (Neutral Citation: 2026:AHC:233845-DB)

Click here to read/download Order


Tags: