The Allahabad High Court has held that where more than one response to a multiple-choice question is correct, the Court may either exclude the question from evaluation or award equal marks.

Accordingly, the High Court directed the revision of UPTET 2026 results concerning Questions 36 and 37 for candidates not already declared successful, while protecting the existing results of successful candidates.

The Court was hearing an intra-court appeal filed by the Uttar Pradesh Education Service Selection Commission against a Single Judge’s order directing that Questions 36 and 37 be excluded from evaluation or treated consistently with binding precedent, with uniform consequential benefits and correction of the writ petitioners’ results.

A Division Bench comprising Justice Saumitra Dayal Singh and Justice Swarupama Chaturvedi observed: “subject to delay and laches, wherever more than one answer response to a multiple choice question may be found correct, the Court may interfere in exercise of extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. While granting relief it may order exclusion of a suspect question or provide for award of equal marks to all candidates.”

Senior Advocate Ashok Khare appeared for the Commission. Advocate Tanya Pandey appeared for the original writ petitioners.

Background

The dispute concerned Questions 36 and 37 of UPTET 2026. The Commission’s provisional answer key identified one correct response to each question. After considering objections, however, the Commission accepted two responses as correct for each question and awarded full marks to candidates who had selected either accepted option.

The writ petitioners had attempted both questions but had chosen options other than the two responses ultimately accepted by the Commission. They challenged the treatment of the questions after the final answer key and result were declared.

The Single Judge directed that both questions be excluded from evaluation or dealt with consistently with the binding precedents considered in the judgment. The consequential benefit was to be extended uniformly to similarly situated candidates, and the Commission was required to recompute the writ petitioners’ scores and correct their results and scorecards.

In appeal, the Commission argued that the writ petitioners had not challenged the provisional answer key and had therefore lost the opportunity to question the answers after the final result. It further contended that awarding marks to candidates who selected either of the two accepted responses was the only correction required.

The writ petitioners responded that they had no reason to suspect any defect when the provisional key identified only one correct answer. They learned that the Commission had accepted two responses only when the final answer key and result were published, by which stage the objection process had ended. They maintained that the appropriate remedy was either to exclude the questions or award marks uniformly.

Court’s Observations

Challenge Was Not Barred By Failure To Object Earlier

The Court rejected the Commission’s preliminary objection. When the provisional key was published, the writ petitioners knew only that their selected answers differed from the single response then identified as correct. They had no reason to know that the framing of the questions was fundamentally defective because two options would later be accepted.

The Bench observed: “They first gained knowledge that there were two correct answer responses at the stage of publication of the final result, and not earlier.” Since no further objection could be filed after the final key and the writ petition was instituted promptly, the Court held that the petitioners could not be non-suited for failing to object earlier.

Judicial Review Of Answer Keys Remains Limited

The Court considered UPSSSC v. Ashok Yadav, which reiterated that a question or answer carries a presumption of correctness and that the candidate bears the burden of demonstrating an error. The reproduced passage stated: “Besides, while considering a challenge to the correctness of a question or an answer, the court must bear in mind that there is a presumption about the correctness of the question/answer, and the onus is on the candidate to demonstrate that it is incorrect.”

However, the same precedent recognised interference where a question itself was incorrect or two responses were correct despite the candidate being required to select only one. Reading Ashok Yadav with Guru Nanak Dev University v. Saumil Garg (2005), the Court concluded that the available remedies included excluding the suspect question or awarding equal marks, subject to delay and laches.

Qualifying TET Was Distinct From A Competitive Selection

The Court declined to apply Guru Nanak Dev University mechanically. That case concerned admission to a medical course and included vague questions for which marks had been granted even to students who had not attempted them.

The Bench distinguished the present examination, observing: “The present is not a case of selection but only of qualification at TET. No job opportunity is secured solely on the strength of marks obtained at the examination.” The rule in Guru Nanak Dev University was nevertheless relevant to the extent that candidates who had not attempted a disputed question should not receive marks for it.

Earlier Answer-Key Decisions Were Distinguished

The Court held that Priti Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh (2022) and Uday Bhan Yadav v. State of Uttar Pradesh did not govern the case. Those decisions concerned challenges to the correctness of responses where objections had not been raised within the prescribed time; they did not involve the examining body accepting two correct responses to a question requiring one answer.

The Bench also addressed the coordinate-bench decision in Sunil Kumar Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh (2017), stating: “Last, the decision of the coordinate bench in Sunil Kumar Singh (supra) may not carry any precedential value, as that decision has been set aside, even though on another point.”

Relief Modified To Protect Results And Benefit Those Who Attempted Questions

Although the Court rejected the Commission’s substantive challenge, it modified the Single Judge’s directions because the final result had already been declared. The results of all candidates who had already qualified were protected.

For the remaining unsuccessful candidates, the Commission was permitted to award one mark for any response given to each of Questions 36 and 37. The Court expressly limited the benefit to attempted questions, clarifying: “We clarify, wherever candidate may not have attempted either question nos. 36 or 37, that candidate may not be awarded any additional mark/s.”

The Bench directed: “Such further/supplementary result may be prepared and declared preferably, within a period of one month from today with liberty to approach the Court, if any further time is required.”

Conclusion

The High Court partly allowed the Commission’s appeal and modified the relief granted by the Single Judge.

Existing successful results were left undisturbed. For candidates not previously declared successful, the Commission was permitted to award one mark for any attempted response to each of Questions 36 and 37, while candidates who did not attempt a question were denied an additional mark for it.

The supplementary result was directed to be prepared and declared preferably within one month, with liberty to seek further time from the Court.

Cause Title: U.P. Education Service Selection Commissioner, Prayagraj and Another v. Vijay Sonkar and Others (Neutral Citation: 2026:AHC:235265-DB)

Appearances

Appellants: Ashok Khare, Senior Advocate; Udayan Nandan, Advocate

Respondents: Tanya Pandey, Advocate; Ankita Singh, Chief Standing Counsel

Click here to read/download Judgment

Tags: