Justice Dipankar Datta, Justice Sheel Nagu, Supreme Court

The Supreme Court has observed that the right to a reasoned order is illusory if the judgment or order itself is not made available to the litigant who might seek to challenge it before a higher court.

The Court noted that a judgment of the Madras High Court dated September 21, 2026 was uploaded only after the Supreme Court directed the High Court’s Registrar General to furnish it, more than six weeks after it was passed.

It reminded High Court judges to consider a mechanism for timely uploading of judgments and orders, despite the heavy burden of judicial work they bear.

On the merits, the Court found no reason to interfere with the High Court’s judgment and dismissed the special leave petition. It left the petitioner free to pursue civil litigation or any other remedy in accordance with law.

The Bench of Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Sheel Nagu observed, “Before parting, this Court would remind Hon’ble Judges to consider a mechanism for timely uploading of judgments/orders notwithstanding the heavy burden of judicial work that each Hon’ble Judge of a high court has to bear. After all, the right to a reasoned order is illusory if the judgment/order itself is not made available to the litigant who might seek to challenge it before a higher court.”

Senior Advocate Siddhartha Dave appeared for the Petitioner.

The petitioner filed a special leave petition against the judgment of the Madras High Court dated September 21, 2026, passed in a criminal original petition, along with an application seeking permission to file it without a certified or website copy of the impugned judgment.

The Supreme Court had directed the High Court to furnish the judgment. In compliance, the Registrar General of the Madras High Court furnished the uploaded copy of the judgment.

The Court noted that the impugned judgment was uploaded only the day before the hearing, at around 4.40 pm. It remarked, “It requires no special intelligence to infer that but for the intervention of this Court, the impugned judgment would not have been uploaded yesterday at all.”

Having perused the judgment, the Court found no reason to interfere with it and dismissed the special leave petition. It clarified that any proceeding instituted by the petitioner may be considered on its own merits, without being influenced by any observation made in the impugned judgment or by the dismissal of the petition.

On the delay in uploading, the Court observed that the delay, “though unintentional, could cause serious prejudice” to the litigant.

It added, “That apart, omission/neglect to upload any judgment or order within a reasonable period and not uploading it for more than six weeks, as in this case, raises unnecessary doubts and could lead to unforeseen complications as well as undesirable criticism which should best be avoided by ensuring timely availability thereof.”

The Court said it trusted that this would not recur and that judgments and orders would be made available to litigants promptly.

Cause Title: Express Infrastructure Private Limited v. Aurea Aviation Private Limited & Ors. [SLP (Crl.) Diary No. 68795/2026]

Appearances:

Petitioner: Senior Advocate Siddhartha Dave, AOR Pranay Shridhar Chitale, Advocates Priyanka Shetty, Ayush Chaddha, Mayank Jain, Samyak Jain, Aditya Dutta and Arundhuti Mukherjee.

Click here to read/download the Order

Tags: