Accidental Discharge Of Serviceman’s Own Weapon Cannot Be Treated As Self-Inflicted Injury Without Evidence Of Intention: Supreme Court
The Court granted War Injury Element of pension to a retired Subedar Major shot by the accidental discharge of his own weapon during Operation Rakshak/Operation Parakram, setting aside the Armed Forces Tribunal’s rejection of his claim.
The Supreme Court has held that an officially recorded accident cannot be converted into a self-inflicted injury merely because the weapon belonged to the serviceman. The Court said that weapon ownership and intention are distinct facts, and the former cannot, without evidence of intention, prove the latter.
Allowing the appeal, the Court set aside the Armed Forces Tribunal’s rejection of War Injury Element of pension to a retired Subedar Major, who was shot by the accidental discharge of his own weapon during Operation Rakshak/Operation Parakram. It held that the Tribunal erred in denying the claim for want of final Battle Casualty approval from the Adjutant General’s Branch/MP-5.
A Bench of Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh observed, “…the absence of contrary contemporaneous material, an officially recorded accident cannot be converted into a self-inflicted injury merely because the weapon belonged to the appellant”.
“The distinction pertinent to note here is that the exclusion is of a self-inflicted injury, not of every injury in which a serviceman’s own weapon happens to be the source of the bullet. The words ‘his wpn’ in BC-59 record identify the weapon from which the bullet emerged. They do not establish that the appellant consciously fired the weapon at himself, intended to cause the wound to himself, or committed any act for the purpose of avoiding duty. Weapon ownership and intention are distinct facts, the former cannot, without evidence of intention, prove the latter”, the Bench said further.
Advocate Akhilesh K Soni appeared for the appellant and Aishwarya Bhati, A.S.G. appeared for the respondent.
The appellant retired on March 31, 2019 after 33 years of service. On August 7, 2002, while serving in Jammu and Kashmir, his loaded weapon accidentally discharged while he was on duty, the bullet passing through his left thigh and damaging the femoral vein. A Release Medical Board found the injury attributable to service and assessed disablement at 40%, and the Union granted the ordinary Disability Element. He sought the higher War Injury Element under Regulation 103 of the Pension Regulations for the Army.
The Tribunal at Lucknow accepted attributability but dismissed his claim on May 10, 2023, because the casualty lacked final approval from MP-5 and his name was absent from the digital database. It refused leave to appeal on July 19, 2023. The original Court of Inquiry records were lost in the 2014 floods.
The Union argued that only MP-5 could accord Battle Casualty status and that, without primary records, it was not established that the discharge occurred during operations against militants.
The Court held that Regulation 103 requires circumstances under Category ‘E’ of Regulation 82, and that Part II Order No. BC-59, headed “Battle Casualty Wound Op Rakshak Op Parakram”, the Attributability Certificate and the entitlement cards established an operational connection, not merely presence in a sensitive area, bringing the case within clause (h).
Further that the Army Order 1/2003/MP excludes self-inflicted injuries, not every injury from a serviceman’s own weapon, and paragraph 69 recognises accidental gunshot wounds as Battle Casualties where operational and severity requirements are met. The earliest record described the discharge as “accidental”, and no authority had classified it as deliberate.
“A service weapon may discharge without an intention to cause bodily injury to himself, for example while holding a weapon, an impact or fall, snagging of the trigger, inadvertent pressure on the trigger, or a mechanical defect can also cause the discharge of a bullet from one’s own weapon. These nature of incidents are clearly distinguishable from the idea of self-inflicted injury which has certain element of knowledge or intention so as to disqualify from getting enhanced pensionary benefit. These possibilities are not findings as to how the present weapon discharged, however they demonstrate why the source of the bullet cannot, by itself, determine whether the wound was self-inflicted. That classification must rest upon the evidence concerning the occurrence and the contemporaneous findings of the competent authorities”, the Bench said,
The loss of records could not be attributed to the appellant, and MP-5 had passed no reasoned order invalidating the surviving documents.
The Court set aside the Tribunal’s orders and directed that the War Injury Element be paid from the date of retirement, adjusting the Disability Element already paid, with a revised Pension Payment Order and arrears within three months.
Cause Title: JC-377745M Ex Sub Maj & Hony Lt Devi Singh v. Union of India & Ors. (Neutral Citation: 2026 INSC 1256)
Appearances:
Appellant: Pavan Kumar- 1217, AOR, Akhilesh K Soni, Neelam, Rohitash Kumar Sharma, Rajesh Kumar, Nayeem Hasan Raza, Advocates.
Respondent: Aishwarya Bhati, A.S.G., Shreekant Neelappa Terdal, AOR, Chitrangda Rastavara, Jitender Kumar Tripathi, Astha Singh, Advocates.