Hotel Manager Having Access To Room No Reason To Doubt Recover From Occupant: SC Sets Aside Bail In NDPS Case
The Supreme Court was considering an appeal filed by the State of Goa against the order granting bail to the accused.
Justice J. B. Pardiwala, Justice K. Vinod Chandran, Supreme Court
The Supreme Court has set aside an order granting bail to an accused found in possession of cocaine and MDMA/Ecstasy, which were recovered from an Airbnb room rented by him. The Apex Court observed that if the argument about the manager having access to the room was accepted, then any recovery made from a hotel or a rental facility cannot be pinned on the person occupying the room or the facility.
The Apex Court was considering an appeal filed by the State of Goa against the order of the High Court granting bail to the respondent accused.
The Bench comprising Justice J. B. Pardiwala and Justice K. Vinod Chandran held, "The AOR for the State argues that the High Court strangely thought it fit to grant bail on the ground that the Manager of the facility had unhindered access to the room and hence prima facie there is reason to believe that the respondent had not committed the said offence as alleged. If such a reasoning is accepted, then any recovery made from a hotel or a rental facility cannot be pinned on the person occupying the room or the facility. Since every hotel has an alternate key with the management, which is also used; even when in occupation, in the absence of the occupants for cleaning purposes, unless specifically prohibited by the occupants."
AOR Omkar Jayant Deshpande represented the Appellant, while Advocate Sana Raees Khan represented the Respondent.
Factual Background
The respondent was allegedly found in possession of 50.03 grams of cocaine and 15.04 grams of MDMA/Ecstasy recovered from a room/flat he occupied in Helen Oasis, Vagator, Goa. The room occupied by the respondent was an Airbnb facility. The search was conducted following all formalities, in the presence of Panchas and after first detaining the respondent in the basement, then leading him to the room he occupied. The respondent refused to hand over the keys of the room, and the duplicate keys were obtained from the manager of the facility.
The respondent argued before the High Court that he was apprehended two days back and was subsequently taken to the room after the contraband was planted. It was further alleged that there was sufficient time for the Manager to plant the contraband in the accused’s room.
Reasoning
On a perusal of the FIR along with the appeal and the search warrant, the Bench noted that it indicated the Raiding Officer had intimated his superior on January 22, 2025, about reliable information of narcotic activities carried on by the respondent, who was staying at the Air-B&B facility. The Raiding Officer had obtained permission from the superior officer to conduct a house search and also obtained the seal to secure the contraband.
A medical examination report of the accused on his arrest was brought to the Court’s notice, which indicated a burn injury on the forearm, which was stated to have been caused by a lighter. The Bench found that the doctor opined that it could have occurred two days back. The Bench rejected the story of the respondent regarding the planting of the narcotics in the room and a bogus raid being conducted.
Thus, finding no reason to sustain the order granting bail and setting aside the order passed by the High Court, the Bench directed the respondent to surrender within three weeks.
Cause Title: State of Goa v. Agniv Sengupta (Neutral Citation: 2026 INSC 1245)
Appearance
Appellant: AOR Omkar Jayant Deshpande, Advocates Nrupal Dingankar, Chandan Goswami
Respondent: Advocate Sana Raees Khan, AOR Pranay Shridhar Chitale, Advocate Sonakshi Chaturvedi
Click here to read/download Order