Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra, Justice Shree Chandrashekhar, Supreme Court

While affirming the orders of the Central Administrative Tribunal directing the release of the employees’ gratuity, the Supreme Court has held that superannuated employees of advanced age should not have to suffer due to long pendency of appellate proceedings against acquittal for an uncertain number of years particularly when the delay is not attributable to them.

The Apex Court was considering an appeal filed by the Delhi Development Authority challenging the judgment of the Division Bench of the Delhi High Court affirming the orders of the Central Administrative Tribunal directing the release of the respondents’ gratuity, together with applicable interest, subject to the respondents furnishing the undertaking to refund the amount if the pending judicial proceedings ultimately concluded against them.

The Bench of Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice Shree Chandrashekhar held, “The requirement to furnish the undertaking has been imposed solely to balance the competing equities of safeguarding public funds with the right of a retired employee to receive and enjoy terminal benefits earned over decades of service. Practically speaking, if a superannuated employee (being necessarily of advanced age) were required to await the conclusion of even appellate proceedings against acquittal for an uncertain number of years, it is most probable the pensionary benefits would itself be rendered illusory. They should not have to suffer due to long pendency of such a challenge preferred by the State, particularly when the delay is not attributable to them.”

Advocate Himaghn Jain represented the Appellant while Advocate Navjot Kumar represented the Respondent.

Factual Background

The respondents joined the service of the appellant-Authority in 1984. In 2001, an FIR was registered by the Anti-Corruption Branch of the Government of National Capital Territory of Delhi against certain officials of the appellant-Authority (including the respondents), the Municipal Corporation of Delhi, and the Slum and Jhuggi-Jhopri Department. It was alleged that the said officials had conducted a joint survey of slum dwellers for determining their eligibility for relocation and alternate plots and they had, in connivance with property dealers, included the names of fictitious dwellers therein for wrongful gain. The Special Judge convicted four co-accused and acquitted the respondents and seven others, while one accused was discharged for want of sanction. The State thereafter instituted a Criminal Leave Petition before the Delhi High Court under Section 378 of the Code of Criminal Procedure seeking leave to appeal against the acquittal.

The appellant-Authority provisionally promoted both the respondents but the same was subject to the outcome of the State’s challenge to the acquittal. The respondents superannuated from service. However, owing to the pendency of the Criminal Leave Petition before the High Court, the appellant-Authority withheld the respondents’ gratuity under Rule 69(1)(c) of the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972. The respondents made representations to the Authority for the release of their gratuity, but the same was rejected. Subsequently, the respondents approached the Tribunal. The Tribunal directed the release of the gratuity with applicable interest, subject to an undertaking by each respondent to refund the amount received, together with interest, if the judicial proceedings were decided against them. Aggrieved by the dismissal of the petition, the appellant Authority approached the Apex Court.

Reasoning

The Bench referred to the judgment in Kishan Lal Taneja vs. Government of NCT Delhi and Ors. and held that the same was equally applicable to the case of the respondents, who were honourably acquitted after the same full-fledged trial. “The High Court had rightly held that mere pendency of the appellant’s Section 378 Cr.PC application (with no stay operating on the Trial Court’s judgment), especially since 2017, could not justify withholding the terminal dues of the retired employees after long years of service”, it added.

The Bench was of the view that the pensionary benefits would itself be rendered illusory if a superannuated employee (being necessarily of advanced age) were required to await the conclusion of even appellate proceedings against acquittal for an uncertain number of years.

Holding that the condition imposed by the Tribunal and the High Court adequately safeguarded the financial interests of the appellant-Authority, the Bench dismissed the appeal.

Cause Title: Delhi Development Authority v. Rajender Kumar Sharma (Neutral Citation: 2026 INSC 1213)

Appearance

Appellant: Advocate Himaghn Jain, AOR Niharika Ahluwalia

Respondent: Advocates Navjot Kumar, Karan Khanna, AOR Vaibhav Manu Srivastava

Click here to read/download Judgment


Tags: