Earlier Guidelines Rendered Toothless, Time To Evolve Foolproof Procedure: Madras High Court On Public Libraries Book Procurement Scam
The Court asked the Government for a white paper on two decades of book procurement and an account of library cess, observing that AI and digital processes were subverted for the first time.
The Madras High Court, Madurai Bench, has observed that the earlier guidelines on procurement of books for public libraries “have been rendered toothless” and that “it is time to evolve a foolproof procedure”. It was hearing a contempt petition over alleged non-implementation of its 2024 judgment on transparent book procurement. The Court said it would close the contempt petition once a binding procedure is put in place by a formal Government Order.
The Court asked the Government to submit by the next hearing a white paper on how books have been procured over the last twenty years and more, and to disclose whether library cess has been duly credited and how it has been spent. It observed that, for the first time, AI and digital processes have been subverted in such a scam.
Pertinently, the Bench had earlier directed the Directorate of Vigilance and Anti-Corruption to register an FIR forthwith over alleged fraudulent procurement of books for Tamil Nadu’s public libraries. The Court also ordered the immediate freezing of bank accounts connected with a publication and its proprietor and directed the Government to initiate disciplinary action, including suspension, against the officials involved.
A Division Bench of Justice G.R. Swaminathan and Justice M.D. Sumathi observed, “…The earlier guidelines have been rendered toothless. It is time to evolve a foolproof procedure. Since the suggestions are fairly comprehensive, it should not take too long to issue a formal G.O so that we do not witness another scam in books procurement. Once such a binding procedure is put in place, we shall close this contempt petition. We would of course issue suitable directions”.
“…The scam has shaken the conscience of the people of Tamil Nadu. Their faith in the system must be restored”, the Bench said.
Advocate K.P.S. Palanivel Rajan appeared for the petitioner, while Vijay Narayan, Advocate General appeared for the respondents.
Ramasubbu had filed a Contempt Petition against K. Gopal, Secretary to Government, Higher Education Department, and R.V. Shajeevana, Director of Public Libraries. He alleged wilful disobedience of the judgment dated June 19, 2024.
On the day of hearing, the Court first posed nine queries. They included whether the same conditions governed general and special procurement for Periyar Arivulagam, how many books rejected by the expert committee were still procured, and why 600 titles of the publisher Agalvilakku were rejected while the remaining 1,700 were bought.
In the afternoon, the Advocate General sought more time and assured that all persons involved would be dealt with. He said five officials had been suspended. The State Public Prosecutor said DVAC, Chennai City, had registered an FIR under the BNS and the Prevention of Corruption Act, naming Agalvilakku’s proprietor as an accused.
The Court noted that a stakeholder, the publisher Badrinarayanan Seshadri of Kizhakku Padhippagam, assisted it and sent a note, and that two others also submitted suggestions, enclosed as Annexures A to C. It expected the Government to go through all three notes “with utmost care and attention” and to respond positively by the next date, since a formal G.O. should not take long. The Court also took judicial notice that library cess is levied and collected, and said the scam “has shaken the conscience of the people of Tamil Nadu”.
On the investigation, the Court said it should not direct the investigating officer to arrest any particular accused, but that the case falls under an “exceptional category”. It observed that the bogus publishers had been identified and that, unless they were custodially interrogated, one would never know how much money was paid to which public servant. It added that these matters fall within the realm of the police.
The Government’s affidavit must devote a paragraph to the library cess. Impleading applications will be considered on the next date, and the matter is listed on November 20, 2026 at 10:30 a.m. as the first item.
Cause Title: Ramasubbu v. K. Gopal, IAS & Anr., CONT P(MD) No. 3763 of 2026
Appearances:
Petitioner: K.P.S. Palanivel Rajan, P.M. Vishnu Varthanan.
Respondents: Vijay Narayan, Advocate General, P.V. Balasubramanian, Additional Advocate General, and B. Saravanan, Additional Advocate General, M. Kannan, Special Government Pleader; R. John Sathyan, State Public Prosecutor, assisted by D. Venkatesh, Additional Public Prosecutor.