Justice Kalyan Rai Surana, Justice Susmita Phukan Khaund, Gauhati High Court

The Gauhati High Court has held that continuous residency is a sine qua non to prove citizenship, and that voters’ lists of 1970, 1985 and 1997 produced in a scattered manner cannot establish lineage with parents and grandparents where the names and ages differ. The Court said the petitioner had not linked the lists with cogent, reliable and contemporaneous records.

Dismissing the petition, the Division Bench upheld the June 30, 2022 opinion of Foreigners Tribunal, which declared the petitioner a foreigner who entered India illegally on or after March 25, 1971. It held that she failed to discharge the onus under Section 9 of the Foreigners Act, 1946, and vacated her bail order of October 11, 2023.

A Division Bench of Justice Kalyan Rai Surana and Justice Susmita Phukan Khaund observed, “In a scattered manner, a voters list of 1970 and thereafter, after 15 years, a voters list of 1985 and after 12 years, a voters list of 1997 cannot establish lineage of the petitioner with her parents and grandparents when their names appear to be different, and their ages are also not similar. Continuous residency is a sine qua non to prove citizenship”.

“…The voter identity cards or EPIC of individuals do not at all prove their citizenship… the onus was on the petitioner to establish her lineage with her parents and her grandparents…”, it read further.

Advocate N. Uddin appeared for the petitioner, while A.K. Choudhry, CGC appeared for the Union of India.

The Superintendent of Police (Border), Goalpara referred the petitioner’s nationality to the Tribunal on December 22, 2010, expressing doubt over it. In her written statement filed on November 27, 2018, she claimed to have been born in 1978 at Uzirar Char, married in 1996, and to be the granddaughter of a man named in the 1951 NRC. She examined herself, her father, a Gram Panchayat Secretary and a Gaonburah, and exhibited the NRC entry, voters’ lists and two certificates. After the Tribunal’s opinion, she approached the High Court.

She argued that the notice came without copies of the reports and that her public documents were wrongly discarded. The respondents argued that the documents did not link her to her parents and grandparents.

The Court rejected the notice contention, noting that the grounds were stated in the notice and that she had appeared and filed a written statement.

Placing the onus on the petitioner, it noted that her grandfather appeared as Dukhiya, Duikha and Doila Munshi, with his wife shown as the wife of “Duikha” in the 1970 list, and that her father appeared as Matleb and Abdul Matleb with differing ages and wives across lists. No document covered 1970 to 1985. Her claim that her grandparents moved villages in 1960 appeared only in evidence and not in pleadings, and evidence cannot traverse beyond pleadings.

The certificates of the Gaonburah and the Gram Panchayat Secretary were found unsafe, having been issued for NRC updation without verification, and the latter could serve only as a supporting document. The Court added that her mother, who was alive, was not examined, and that her siblings and uncles were not reflected in the lists.

The Court concurred with the Tribunal, dismissed the petition, directed that the consequences of the June 30, 2022 order shall follow, vacated the bail order, made no order as to costs, and directed that the Tribunal’s record be returned with a copy of the judgment.

Cause Title: Jaygun Nessa @ Joygun Nessa @ Joygon Nessa v. The Union of India & 6 Ors., WP(C) 5985/2023

Appearances:

Petitioner: N. Uddin, with M. Islam and S.K. Chhetry, Advocates

Respondents: A.K. Choudhry, CGC; G. Sarma, FT & Border; A.I. Ali, ECI; R.B. Bora, Jr. Govt. Adv.

Click here to read/download the Judgment



Tags: