Epilepsy Not Mental Disorder, Having It Does Not Prove Matrimonial Cruelty: Gauhati High Court
The Court upheld Family Court’s refusal to call for wife’s original medical records at that stage.
The Gauhati High Court has held that epilepsy is a neurological disorder, not a mental or psychopathic disorder, and that the condition does not by itself establish cruelty in matrimonial proceedings.
The Court dismissed a husband’s supervisory petition challenging the Family Court’s refusal, at that stage, to require his wife to produce her original medical records in their pending divorce case.
The Court was hearing a petition under Article 227 of the Constitution challenging two Family Court orders passed in a divorce case instituted by the husband under Sections 13(1)(ia) and 13(1)(iii) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.
A Division Bench of Justice Michael Zothankhuma and Justice Sanjeev Kumar Sharma observed: “...epilepsy is a neurological disorder. It is not a mental or psychopathic disorder. It should also be noted that just because a person has epilepsy does not mean that the person is cruel. Cruelty and mental cruelty would have to be decided on the basis of specific instances to be proved by the person making the allegation, against the person who committed acts of cruelty.”
Advocates A.K. Rai, B. Yadav & M. Das appeared for the husband.
Background
The parties married, and the husband said that he subsequently learned that his wife had epilepsy and was receiving medical treatment. He alleged that she behaved badly towards him because of the condition and that her conduct amounted to mental cruelty.
He instituted divorce proceedings on the grounds of cruelty and mental disorder under Sections 13(1)(ia) and 13(1)(iii) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955. The divorce case was pending at the evidence stage when he sought directions requiring his wife to produce the original marriage certificate and her original medical records.
The Family Court directed the wife to produce the original marriage certificate, and she complied. As regards the medical records, the Family Court noted that the husband had already submitted medical documents relating to his wife. It held that the originals were unnecessary at that stage because evidence was yet to be recorded and the husband could summon any person under whom she had undergone treatment. The Family Court further held that rejecting the request at that stage would not prejudice him.
The husband challenged both orders before the High Court. He argued that the original medical records were necessary to support his allegations of mental cruelty and mental disorder.
Court’s Observations
The Court noted that the husband had invoked two distinct matrimonial grounds. Section 13(1)(ia) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, provides cruelty as a ground for divorce. Section 13(1)(iii) applies where a spouse has been incurably of unsound mind or has suffered from a mental disorder of the statutorily prescribed kind and degree.
Reproducing the threshold under Section 13(1)(iii), the Court referred to a person who “has been incurably of unsound mind, or has been suffering continuously or intermittently from mental disorder of such a kind and to such an extent that the petitioner cannot reasonably be expected to live with the respondent.”
Against that statutory standard, the Court distinguished epilepsy from a mental or psychopathic disorder. It also separated the existence of the neurological condition from proof of cruelty. The husband was required to establish specific acts said to constitute cruelty or mental cruelty instead of treating the medical condition itself as proof of either ground.
The Court considered the request in the context of an evidentiary process that had not yet concluded.
It further noted that the husband could summon the person under whom his wife had received treatment. The Court held that no prejudice could be said to arise unless he took the stand that the contents of the medical documents in his possession were false.
The Court next considered the limited nature of the interlocutory ruling while examining whether supervisory correction was warranted.
The High Court observed: “The learned Family Court has only held that calling for the original documents was not required at this stage.”
The request for the original records had therefore not been finally foreclosed. The Family Court had only determined that their production was unnecessary at the existing stage of the trial.
The Bench also found that the husband had not shown that the Family Court acted beyond its jurisdiction. It therefore declined to exercise its supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution.
As regards the earlier order concerning the marriage certificate, the Court noted that it had granted the husband’s request and that the wife had produced the original certificate. There was consequently no reason for him to challenge that order.
Conclusion
The High Court dismissed the revision petition and declined to interfere with either Family Court order. The divorce proceedings remained pending before the Family Court, where the parties’ evidence was yet to be recorded.
Cause Title: A v. B (Neutral Citation: 2026:GAU-AS:16743-DB)