The Bombay High Court has held that refusing a renowned sportsperson permission to acquire additional arms for practice, despite his eligibility under a Central Government notification, is “a curb on Petitioner’s fundamental right” of participating in the sport of his choice. The Court described the rejection as highly arbitrary, and high handed.

Allowing clay pigeon trap shooter, Hemant Ankush Balwadkar’s petition, the Court held that the pendency of a criminal case, in which no role or violence was attributed to him, could not justify the refusal. It said Section 17 of the Arms Act, 1959 could not be attracted merely because of such pendency. It quashed the orders of the Commissioner of Police and the State and directed that six additional arms be endorsed on his licence within seven days.


A Single Bench of Justice Milind N. Jadhav observed, “It is seen that rejection of permission in such circumstances is therefore highly arbitrary, high handed and a curb on Petitioner’s fundamental right of denying him participation in the sport of his choice in which he has been recognized as a renowned sportsperson. Insofar as the objection and reason for rejecting Petitioner’s application is concerned qua the pending criminal case, it is seen that no role is attributed to Petitioner in the FIR neither there is any incidence of violence mentioned in the FIR…”.

“…Further, invocation of Section 17 of the Arms Act cannot be attracted against Petitioner due to pendency of the aforesaid criminal case. Petitioner has already lost substantial, rather humongous amount of time in prosecuting the present Petition and proceedings. Persons like Petitioner are required to practice their skill set virtually on a daily basis in order to compete and participate at the highest level. Despite being eligible, Petitioner is forced to continue his practice with his old weapons/arms due to the regressive mindset of the prosecution in rejecting his application on completely untenable and innocuous grounds which cannot be allowed and countenanced by this Court”, the Court said.

Advocate Kalyani Mangave appeared for the petitioner while Mamta S. Srivastava, AGP appeared for the State.

The petitioner, a Pune-based shooter certified by the National Rifle Association of India in two disciplines, held four arms under his licence for his sport. He stated that they had become old and obsolete and sought six additional weapons in the exempted category, three non-prohibited bore revolvers or pistols and three rifles. He relied on a Gazette Notification dated February 12, 2020, under which he was eligible to possess up to 12 arms.

The Commissioner of Police, Pune rejected the application by an order dated January 24, 2025, on the ground that the additional arms were sought for personal use or safety. The State later rejected his statutory appeal. He contended that the appeal was decided after almost a year, though Schedule V of the Arms Rules, 2016 prescribes 60 days. He moved the High Court and argued that the Commissioner’s order was non-speaking, and that the FIR under Sections 34, 406, 504 and 506 of the IPC attributed no role to him.

The Commissioner’s reply stated that the denial was not arbitrary, that the notification created no automatic right, and that the offences were grievous.

The Court found the Commissioner’s order to be an unreasoned non-speaking order passed without application of mind. It said remanding the matter would only cause further delay. It noted that the application was within the parameters of the notification and that it was not the respondents’ case that the petitioner had misused his existing arms. No material showed any threat to public safety or security.

The Court observed that persons like the petitioner are required to practise virtually on a daily basis to compete at the highest level. It held that the pendency of the criminal case, in which no role or violence was attributed to him, could not attract Section 17 of the Arms Act.

The petition was allowed in terms of prayer clauses (b) and (c), and the orders of Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 were quashed. The application for six additional arms was allowed. The Additional Commissioner of Police, Pune was directed to endorse them within seven days from receipt of the application for endorsement, the period prescribed in Schedule V, and not to delay once the licence is submitted with a copy of the order downloaded from the High Court’s website.

Cause Title: Hemant Ankush Balwadkar v. State of Maharashtra And Anr., Writ Petition No. 2180 of 2026

Click here to read/download the Judgment



Tags: