The Bombay High Court, Aurangabad Bench has held that Commissioners under the Employee’s Compensation Act, 1923 must call for at least one independent witness to establish an employer-employee relationship between close relatives, in addition to the claimant and the employer-relative. The Court said they must not rely solely on the statements of the claimant and the employer relative.

The Court set aside an award of Rs 6,55,840 to the widow and minor child of a tractor driver who died in an accident. It remitted the claim for fresh disposal on the limited question whether he was employed by his father, the tractor owner.

A Bench of Justice Ajit B. Kadethankar observed, “I hold that, the Trial Courts/Commissioners must call for at least one independent evidence/independent witness to establish employer-employee relationship in the cases of close relatives, in addition to the depositions of the claimant(s) and the employer relative. In other words, the Courts/Commissioners must not rely solely on the statements of the claimant(s) and the employer relative”.

Advocate Mohit R. Deshmukh appeared for the appellant while Advocate Aniruddha A. Nimbalkar appeared for respondents 1 & 2 and Advocate Ramraje Deshmukh appeared for the respondent no. 3.

“Proposition of law is one thing, and facts to apply the proposition is another thing. I am of the considered view that merely relying upon the testimony of the claimants and the admission of the vehicle owner to uphold ‘employer-employee’ relationship between very close blood relatives would be laying down a wrong precedent. I am of the view that there must be at least minimum one ‘independent witness, other than the claimant and the alleged employer to assert on oath that there was employer-employee relationship between the deceased and the employer/owner”, the Bench further said.

In the matter, the husband of the appellant died on the midnight of June 15, 2014, when the tractor he was driving fell into a water canal. The tractor belonged to his father, Kundlik Anna Dalvi, and was insured with HDFC ERGO General Insurance Co. Ltd.

His widow and child claimed Rs 10 lakh under Section 4 of the Act, as they alleged that his father employed him as driver and that he was going to plough his father-in-law’s farm on the father’s instructions.

The father accepted the claim but sought insurance cover. Only the widow and the father deposed. The insurer led no evidence and argued that the claim was collusive. The Commissioner awarded Rs 6,55,840 with interest, jointly and severally against the owner and the insurer. The insurer appealed, and substantial questions of law were framed on October 7, 2026.

The Court accepted that employing close relatives in agricultural work is a long-standing rural practice in Maharashtra, but held that this alone could not establish the relationship. It discarded the salary certificate as an afterthought, written by another person and dated nine months after the accident. It held that the driving licence did not define the relationship. It also rejected the insurer’s plea of policy breach, as there was no evidence that the tractor was used commercially.

The Court found that the ration card, read with the revenue record, showed that the deceased lived in a separate nuclear family. This supported the claimants on a preponderance of probabilities, a point the Commissioner had not examined. Even so, it held that the employer-father’s evidence always carries dark clouds on its genuineness, and that nothing prevented the claimants from examining a villager or a relative. It said the Commissioner, conducting an inquiry, could have called for such evidence, including through Section 165 of the Evidence Act.

“As I expressed at the outset, I have no reason to disagree with the finding that ‘in the rural part of the State, there is common practice to employ close relative(s) on agricultural job’. Unlike employer-employee relationship between ‘husband and wife’, such relationship between ‘father-son’, ‘brother-brother’, ‘sister-brother’ are quite acceptable. This is because of limited source of earning, scarcity of manpower, limited resources and limited agricultural equipment, early division of the families etc. I segregated such relationship between ‘husband and wife’, for the reason that it is a far fetchable inference to frame a case into section 4 of the Employee's Compensation Act 1923”, it noted.

“This is a case of agriculturists. Considering the society and condition in which the parties live, the relationship, the source of livelihood etc. expecting the claimants to produce documentary evidence to prove the employer-employee relationship between the close relatives; and discarding the claim for want of such documentary evidence would be frustrating the object of the legislation itself”, it noted further.

The appeal was partly allowed and the award dated July 22, 2015 was quashed. The matter was remitted to the Labour Court so that the claimants may adduce independent evidence, with liberty to the insurer to rebut. The parties must appear on December 1, 2026, when the claimants must file their additional evidence, and the trial must be concluded within three months. The claimants may withdraw the amount deposited by the insurer, with interest, on an undertaking to refund it if the claim is dismissed.

Cause Title: HDFC ERGO General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pallavi Arjun Dalvi And Ors. (Neutral Citation: 2026:BHC-AUG:55238)

Click here to read/download the Judgment


Tags: