The Telangana High Court has held that a rowdy sheet cannot be opened or continued mechanically, routinely or merely on the basis of past criminal antecedents.

It was added that every decision to open or continue one must be founded on relevant material, independent application of mind and recorded reasons, with due regard to the individual’s right to personal liberty and privacy.

The Court observed that the object of surveillance is preventive and not punitive. Continuing a rowdy sheet without sufficient and contemporaneous justification would result in unwarranted interference with personal liberty and may expose the person to social stigma.

The Court allowed a writ petition filed by a Hyderabad resident and directed the police to forthwith close the rowdy sheet maintained against him at Chatrinaka Police Station. It also issued detailed directions to police authorities across the State on opening, periodically reviewing, renewing and closing rowdy sheets.

The Bench of Justice N. Tukaramji observed, “The power of the police to open and maintain a rowdy sheet is preventive in nature and is intended to protect public peace and maintain law and order. However, such power is not unfettered and must be exercised strictly in accordance with the relevant Police Standing Orders and the constitutional guarantees enshrined under Articles 14, 19 and 21 of the Constitution of India. Mere past involvement in criminal cases, by itself, cannot constitute an indefinite justification for opening or continuing a rowdy sheet or subjecting an individual to surveillance.”

Advocate Bommagani Prabhakar appeared for the Petitioner, while Assistant Government Pleader Sridhar Bhuvanagiri appeared for the Respondents.

Brief Facts

The petitioner stated that a rowdy sheet was opened against him in 2008, on the basis of an FIR, and had been continued for 18 years. He was acquitted in three cases. In one case, only a fine was imposed in connection with a neighbourhood quarrel, and the proceedings in another were stopped under Section 258 CrPC in 2022. No criminal case had been registered against him thereafter.

His representations seeking deletion of his name from the rowdy sheet were neither considered nor answered with a reasoned order. He then approached the High Court.

Contentions of the Parties

The petitioner contended that the police had neither disclosed the reasons for opening or continuing the rowdy sheet nor shown that periodic reviews were held as required by the Police Standing Orders. He argued that the continued surveillance, repeated summoning to the police station and social stigma had affected his reputation, dignity, privacy and family life, and that surveillance cannot be continued indefinitely as a measure of punishment or harassment.

The State contended that the petitioner had been involved in seven criminal cases relating to offences affecting public peace, including a conviction under Sections 324, 452 and 504 of the IPC. It stated that the rowdy sheet was being maintained up to December 31, 2026, after following the prescribed procedure, that the petitioner was continuing to indulge in activities causing nuisance, and that members of the public were afraid to lodge complaints against him.

Observations/Findings of the Court

Referring to Standing Order of the Telangana State (Andhra Pradesh) Police Manual, the Court held that habituality of conduct, together with material showing that a person’s activities are likely to disturb public peace, is relevant for opening and maintaining a rowdy sheet.

It observed, “Consequently, mere registration or pendency of criminal cases, without anything more, cannot automatically justify classifying an individual as a rowdy or continuing a rowdy sheet against him.”

Examining Standing Order Nos. 602, 735 and 742(2), the Court held that continuation of a rowdy sheet “cannot be mechanical or automatic. It must be preceded by periodic review, supported by relevant material and founded upon the considered satisfaction of the competent authority.”

The Court noted a discrepancy between the parties on the case number and the nature of the alleged conviction, which required verification. It held, however, that “even an isolated conviction cannot, by itself, establish the present necessity for continued surveillance.” It added that proceedings stopped under Section 258 CrPC cannot be treated as an acquittal on merits.

On the State’s claim that people were afraid to complain against the petitioner, the Court noted that no specific incident, complaint, occurrence report, preventive proceedings or other documentary material had been placed on record.

Holding that the continued maintenance of the rowdy sheet was arbitrary, disproportionate and unsustainable, the Court declared it violative of Articles 14 and 21. It directed the police to close the rowdy sheet, delete the petitioner’s name from the surveillance records and update all consequential entries. It clarified that this would not preclude fresh action in accordance with law on the basis of subsequent credible material.

Directions To Police Across Telangana

The Court issued detailed directions for strict compliance by police authorities. Among others:

1. Mere registration of FIRs, involvement in an isolated case or past criminal antecedents shall not, by themselves, justify opening a rowdy sheet. The SHO must identify the specific category under Standing Order No. 601 and submit a reasoned proposal, and the competent authority must record specific reasons rather than mechanically approve it.

2. Renewal shall not be treated as a routine administrative formality. The SHO must prepare a fresh review report, including the date of the last criminal case, the person’s conduct in the intervening period, and whether he has figured as an accused in any case during the preceding five years.

3. Where there has been no criminal involvement in the preceding five years, continuation shall be permitted only on a considered opinion, supported by current material. The Court directed, “Any allegation of fear or intimidation shall be independently verified and supported by credible material. A general or repeated assertion shall not suffice.”

4. On proportionality, the Court directed, “The longer the period of absence of criminal involvement or adverse conduct, the greater shall be the need for specific and convincing material supporting renewal.”

5. Representations seeking deletion of names must be disposed of by a reasoned order communicated to the person.

6. Maintaining a rowdy sheet shall not, by itself, authorise repeated summoning or compulsory attendance at a police station, restriction of movement, interference with occupation, or public humiliation or harassment.

7. The Court directed the DGP to issue circular instructions to all Commissioners and Superintendents of Police within four weeks of receiving the order. The jurisdictional authorities must then review all existing rowdy sheets within three months.

The Court clarified that the directions are intended to regulate, and not to restrict or curtail, the lawful exercise of preventive police powers.

Cause Title: G. Harinath Goud v. State of Telangana & Ors. [W.P. No. 35654 of 2026]

Appearances:

Petitioner: Advocate Bommagani Prabhakar.

Respondents: Assistant Government Pleader for Home, Sridhar Bhuvanagiri.

Click here to read/download the Order