The Telangana High Court has held that a solitary offence, irrespective of its gravity, brutality or premeditated nature, cannot establish the habituality required to classify a person as a “goonda” under Section 2(g) of the Telangana Prevention of Dangerous Activities of Boot-Leggers, Dacoits, Drug-Offenders, Goondas, Immoral Traffic Offenders, Land-Grabbers, Spurious Seed Offenders, Insecticide Offenders, Fertiliser Offenders, Food Adulteration Offenders, Fake Document Offenders, Scheduled Commodities Offenders, Forest Offenders, Gaming Offenders, Sexual Offenders, Explosive Substances Offenders, Arms Offenders, Cyber Crime Offenders and White Collar or Financial Offenders Act, 1986.

The High Court consequently set aside six preventive-detention orders that relied upon a single criminal case alleging murder.

The Court was hearing six habeas corpus petitions challenging detention orders passed under Section 3(2) of the 1986 Act by the Commissioner of Police and subsequently confirmed by the State Government. All six detenus had been classified as “goondas” under Section 2(g) on the basis of their alleged involvement in the same criminal case.

A Division Bench of Justice Moushumi Bhattacharya and Justice Renuka Yara observed: “The defining feature of the word ‘goonda’ under section 2(g) of the 1986 Act consists in the words ‘habitually commits, or attempts to commit or abets…’. The word ‘habitually’ means doing something often or a usual pattern of behavior expressed through actions. The expression thus contemplates a degree of repetition and continuity. The inclination to commit offences punishable under the prescribed sections of the IPC hence cannot be inferred from a solitary act but must be reflected through multiple instances of commission or attempted commission of such offences. Therefore, there must be multiple instances of committing offences, whether by reference to the number or frequency of offences, for a person to be categorized as a ‘Goonda’. A solitary offence cannot by itself satisfy the requirement of the word ‘habitually’ under section 2(g) of the 1986 Act.”

Senior Counsel V. Raghunath appeared for the petitioners in three matters, while Advocate Ajith Reddy appeared for the petitioners in the remaining matters. Special Government Pleader Swaroop Oorilla represented the State.

Background

The six detenus were accused in a criminal case alleging conspiracy, hurt and murder under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, firearms offences under the Arms Act, 1959, and an offence under the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989. The prosecution alleged that they planned and carried out an armed attack in a public park.

After their arrest, the detenus applied for bail. Their initial applications were dismissed, but they were subsequently granted conditional bail and ordered to be released from judicial custody. The investigating officer moved applications seeking cancellation of bail, which remained pending.

The Commissioner of Police thereafter passed preventive-detention orders describing the detenus as notorious and dangerous criminals with a history involving attempt to murder. The orders stated that the alleged public attack had caused fear, terror and panic and had disturbed public order and tranquillity.

The detenus challenged the orders through habeas corpus petitions. They argued that reliance upon one criminal case could not satisfy the statutory definition of a “goonda”, which expressly required habitual commission, attempted commission or abetment of specified offences. They also contended that the State should pursue the available criminal-law remedy of seeking cancellation of bail instead of invoking preventive detention.

The State submitted that the alleged offence had been committed in broad daylight at a public park and had caused fear and trauma among those who witnessed it. It maintained that the incident affected public order and justified preventive detention.

Court’s Observations

Habituality Requires Repetition And Continuity

The Court examined Section 2(g) of the 1986 Act, which defines a “goonda” as a person who, by himself or as a member or leader of a gang, habitually commits, attempts to commit or abets offences punishable under specified chapters of the Indian Penal Code, 1860.

The Bench held that habituality was a threshold statutory requirement that had to be independently established before a person could be classified as a “goonda”. It observed: “Having regard to the definition of ‘Goonda’ under section 2(g) of the 1986 Act, we reiterate that for a person to be classified as a ‘Goonda’, the statutory requirements of habituality must first be satisfied.”

The material relied upon had to show a pattern of repeated offending concerning offences against the human body, property or the other categories specified in the provision.

All Six Detention Orders Relied Upon One Crime

The Court found that each detention order relied only on the same criminal case. Although the orders described the detenus as having a past criminal history involving attempt to murder, they did not identify or rely upon any other criminal case as evidence of repeated offending.

The Court observed: “The fact that only one criminal case has been relied upon to bring the detenu within the definition of a ‘Goonda’ raises a serious question on the legality of the impugned detention orders with reference to the definition under section 2 (g) of the Act.”

It further found no statement or evidence in the detention material showing that the detenus were habitual offenders or had repeatedly committed offences falling within the chapters specified by Section 2(g).

Gravity Or Premeditation Cannot Substitute For Habituality

The Court held that the severity of the alleged offence could not replace the express statutory requirement of repeated conduct. Even an allegation involving a grave and premeditated offence remained a solitary instance unless the detention material demonstrated other qualifying acts.

The Bench stated: “The gravity, brutality or premeditated nature of a crime cannot, by itself, bring an accused within the ambit of section 2(g) of the 1986 Act unless ‘habituality’ is established, preceding the requirement of acting in a manner prejudicial to the maintenance of public order as mentioned under section 2(a) of the 1986 Act.”

The Court therefore held that the case failed to satisfy the fundamental requirement for classifying the detenus as “goondas”.

Preventive-Detention Statute Required Strict Construction

The Bench emphasised that a special statute carrying consequences for personal liberty had to be construed precisely and strictly. The words requiring habitual commission, attempted commission or abetment could not be overlooked or treated as equivalent to statutory categories that did not require habituality.

It observed: “A special statute involving consequences infringing on personal liberty must receive a precise and strict construction.”

The Court held that the Legislature’s deliberate use of “habitually” required the detaining authority to apply the definition only where the material disclosed habitual or repeat offences.

Conclusion

The High Court allowed all six habeas corpus petitions and set aside the preventive-detention orders and their subsequent confirmation by the State Government. It held that reliance upon one criminal case could not satisfy the habituality required for classification as a “goonda” under Section 2(g) of the 1986 Act.

The Court directed the Superintendent of the Central Prison to release the detenus forthwith unless they were required to remain detained in connection with another case. All connected applications were also disposed of.

Cause Title: Atmakuri Srinu @ Nagaraju v. State of Telangana and Others

Appearances

Petitioners: V. Raghunath, Senior Counsel; Verose Sanjana and Ajith Reddy, Advocates

State: Swaroop Oorilla, Special Government Pleader

Click here to read/download Judgment