The Supreme Court declined to grant urgent listing of an application seeking the recall of its recent split verdict regarding the constitutional validity of the Chief Election Commissioner and other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023.

The application was moved on the ground that Justice Satish Chandra Sharma, one of the two judges on the Bench, had a conflict of interest, as his son was appearing as counsel for the Election Commission of India.

In September 2026, the Supreme Court had delivered a split verdict in the matter concerning the challenge to the Chief Election Commissioner and other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023.

While Justice Dipankar Datta held that the challenge could be decided by applying settled constitutional principles without referring the matter to a larger bench, Justice Satish Chandra Sharma favoured referring the substantial constitutional questions to a five-judge bench.

The Bench comprising Chief Justice Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana refused to list the application before the same bench urgently.


Advocate Prashant Bhushan mentioned the application before the Bench and submitted that it was an application for recall on the ground of conflict of interest. He said that the application be listed before the same Bench comprising Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Satish Chandra Sharma, as Justice Sharma was due to retire by the end of the following week.

Bhushan said, "This is an application for recall in the Election Commissioner's appointment matter, on the ground that there was a conflict of interest. That has to be listed before the same bench of Justice Datta and Justice Sharma, and he is retiring at the end of next week...But if the order is recalled, then there will not be a reference, because that reference order is itself sought to be recalled on the ground that one of the two judges had a conflict of interest."

The Bench said, "You can raise this plea before the five-judge bench, as the five-judge bench is not bound by the reference, right? So it can frame a question about the validity of the reference itself. There, you can make out your case of bias. Whenever you want, you choose—you know Tuesday is a holiday, Wednesday we can note it."

Bhushan reiterated that it would be appropriate to list the application before the same Bench that had heard the matter, since the recall of that very order was sought. He submitted that had Justice Sharma not dissented, the matter would not have been referred to a Constitution Bench.

CJI Kant said, "The bench itself has ultimately, in the concluding paragraph—I have seen the judgment, right?...independently Justice Datta has opined that the matter requires consideration by a Constitution Bench. Please read the judgment again. I have read it, and that is why I constituted the bench. My role was only to constitute the bench."

Bhushan clarified that he was not questioning the role of the presiding judge, but was only submitting that a recall application should ordinarily be placed before the same Bench. The Bench stated that the recall application would be listed before the same Bench, and that counsel could raise the issue when the matter came up, whereupon a judicial order would be passed.

When Bhushan pointed out that one of the judges would have retired by then, the Bench observed that recall applications were listed even after a judge’s retirement, and that the presiding judge would in any case remain on the Bench.

While delivering the concerned judgment, despite their difference of opinion, both judges issued a concurring procedural order directing the case papers to be placed before the Chief Justice of India to consider constituting a Constitution Bench directly, avoiding the procedural delay of a three-judge bench, while also highlighting the urgent institutional need to address long-pending references.

While delivering his opinion on the matter, Justice Dipankar Datta had opined that it has become "fashionable nowadays" to blame the Collegium for every infelicitous choice. Justice Datta highlighted that the Collegium's role is merely recommendatory and that the executive holds final decisive control—frequently overriding recommendations, delaying reiterated names, and forcing the judiciary into a Hobson's choice to keep the institution running.

The Bench had also requested the Chief Justice of India to consider constituting a permanent 5-Judge Bench to decide pure constitutional issues.