“Everyone Has A Right To File Even 100 Complaints”: Apex Court Junks PIL Seeking Database Of Repeat Sexual Offence Complainants

The Supreme Court today dismissed a PIL seeking directions for setting up a database at police headquarters to address instances of people filing "repeated" complaints of sexual offences, saying that every individual has the right to lodge a complaint.
Observing that a person can file 100 complaints as the law provides for consequences in case of false cases, a bench comprising Chief Justice Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana rejected the PIL filed by one Shonee Kapoor against the Centre, the Delhi government and the city police commissioner.
“Everyone has a right to file a complaint, even a hundred complaints. If it is a false complaint, consequences will follow," Justice Bagchi said.
The bench expressed reservations about the database, sought in the plea, saying that maintaining such records could pose a serious risk of disclosure of the identities of victims of sexual offences.
During the hearing, it questioned the need for additional identity profiling when the existing legal framework already provides safeguards for the identification of victims and verification of complaints.
Justice Bagchi said that the law provides multiple layers of privacy protection for victims and warned that maintaining a database of complainants with the police could expose their identities.
The counsel for the petitioner said that the plea sought directions for setting up a structured database at police headquarters in every district to address instances of individuals allegedly filing repeated complaints.
When the bench sought clarification on whether the proposed database was intended to cover victims or accused, the lawyer said that it concerned complainants and not the accused.
The lawyer said that some individuals misuse the process by filing repeated complaints.
Questioning the necessity of such a database, Justice Bagchi said investigations into sexual offences involve several established procedures, including medical examination and DNA profiling, wherever applicable.
Justice Bagchi said the law requires the statements of victims to be recorded before a magistrate, providing an additional layer of verification.
"What better identification data can the investigating agency maintain?" the judge asked and dismissed the plea.
With PTI Inputs

