The Supreme Court has held that contesting claims on merits without prejudice to a pleaded jurisdictional objection does not amount to waiver or confer jurisdiction by acquiescence. The Court noted that Neycer (India) Ltd. had objected from the inception that claims beyond Rs 2 crore fell outside the reference.

Setting aside a Calcutta High Court Division Bench judgment, the Court held that GMB Ceramics Ltd. could not enlarge the reference, once crystallised at Rs 2 crore, by a later letter. It restored the Single Judge’s order cutting the Umpire’s award of Rs 11,69,62,910 to Rs 2 crore, and treated the Rs 4 crore already paid as full and final satisfaction.

A Bench of Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Satish Chandra Sharma observed, “…Contesting claims on merits without prejudice to a pleaded jurisdictional objection does not amount to waiver or confer jurisdiction by acquiescence”.

“…GMB could not unilaterally enlarge the scope of the reference by 22 Ext. G-71 23 Ext. G-72 a subsequent letter, i.e., Ext. G-72. Moreover, on facts, a mere ‘reservation of rights’ to claim damages in the future did not constitute a reference of an existing dispute to arbitration”, the Bench said.

The parties had entered into a 1986 agreement, amended in 1987, for GMB’s ceramics project. Before arbitration, GMB repeatedly quantified its project cost overrun at Rs 2 crore and, on October 19, 1989, nominated its arbitrator for adjudication of a claim “for over Rs. 2 crores”. Its claims later aggregated to over Rs 17 crore, and in 1999 the Umpire awarded Rs 11,69,62,910 with 15% interest.

On Neycer’s objections under Sections 30 and 33 of the Arbitration Act, 1940, a Single Judge restricted the award to Rs 2 crore on October 14, 2015. A Division Bench restored the entire award on September 24, 2018, prompting Neycer’s appeals.

The Court held that an umpire, being a creature of the reference, commits a jurisdictional error if he enlarges it. It said the scope of a reference is for the Court to determine objectively, and that the Division Bench erred in treating it as a “plausible reading”. A later “reservation of rights” was not a reference of an existing dispute, and Neycer’s invocation letter did not keep the scope open.

The Court also upheld the Single Judge’s setting aside of the Schedule ‘C’ claim of Rs 2.03 crore as speculative, since it rested on a 1990 estimate although GMB’s actual expenditure was on record. It held that Clause 20, requiring Neycer to “endeavour” to commission the plant, could not make it an insurer of five years of GMB’s profits and loan interest. It found no ground to interfere with the Rs 2 crore sustained under the other Schedules, which were severable.

The Court set aside the impugned judgment and restored the Single Judge’s order. It directed that the Rs 4 crore (Rs 2 crore each towards principal and interest) deposited by Neycer and withdrawn by GMB stand in full and final satisfaction of the award as modified, and that no further amount be recoverable by either party. Parties were left to bear their own costs.

Cause Title: Neycer (India) Ltd. v. GMB Ceramics Ltd. (Neutral Citation: 2026 INSC 1251)

Appearances:

Appellant: Amit Sibal, Sr. Adv., Sanjiv Sen, Sr. Adv., Nar Hari Singh- 2109, AOR, Neeraj Chaudhary, Govind Manoharan, Bhavya Sanwal, Advocates.

Respondent: Siddharth Bhatnagar, Sr. Adv., Pulkit Deora, Sonia Dube, Kanchan Yadav, Pracheta Kar, Saumya Sharma, Riya Shankar Sharma, Chinmayi Chatterjee, Advocates M/S. Legal Options- 1554, AOR.

Click here to read/download the Judgment