The Supreme Court has held that the moratorium under Section 14 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC) operates only in the context of the corporate debtor, not its promoters or directors.

The Court set aside an order of the Securities Appellate Tribunal (SAT), Mumbai, which had barred BSE Ltd. from recovering the outstanding Annual Listing Fee (ALF) dues of a corporate debtor from its erstwhile promoter.

The Court remanded the matter to the SAT for fresh consideration on merits, observing that the Tribunal had disposed of the appeal in a cursory manner without going into the questions that arose in it.

The Bench of Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva observed, “The aforestated construction of Section 14 of the IBC by the SAT militates against the very language used therein. The moratorium that operates under that provision would only be in the context of the corporate debtor and not its promoters or directors.”

Senior Advocate Amit Sibal appeared for the Appellant, while Senior Advocates Ashish Mohan and Chander Uday Singh appeared for the Respondents.

Brief Facts

The Surveillance Cell of the National Securities Depository Limited froze the demat account of Spice Energy Pvt. Ltd. (SEPL) over the outstanding ALF dues of M/s Cals Refineries Limited, of which SEPL was an erstwhile promoter. The Review Committee of BSE rejected SEPL’s request to de-freeze the account.

SEPL appealed to the SAT, which allowed the appeal with costs of Rs 1,00,000. The SAT quashed the Review Committee’s order and directed BSE to refund the entire amount realised from SEPL towards the outstanding ALF dues, along with interest, and to de-freeze its demat account immediately.

The SAT took the view that Cals Refineries Limited was undergoing the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) on the admission of a petition under Section 9 of the IBC, so the matter could be disposed of on the short point of the moratorium under Section 14.

Applying Section 238 of the IBC, which gives the Code overriding effect, the SAT held that the corporate debtor’s outstanding ALF dues could not be recovered from its erstwhile promoter. It rejected BSE’s argument that the moratorium applies only to the corporate debtor and not its promoters, on the ground that such an interpretation would defeat the purpose of the IBC.

BSE then approached the Supreme Court, which stayed the SAT’s order.

Observations/Findings of the Court

The Court held that the SAT had merely relied on Section 14 and thereby applied Section 238 of the IBC, and that it had disposed of the matter without considering and applying its mind to the other issues raised in SEPL’s appeal.

The Court noted that the interpretation and application of the Circulars issued by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) under the SEBI (Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2015 also arose for consideration in the context of the liability sought to be pinned on SEPL.

It observed, “Though the validity of the Circulars and the Regulations was never subjected to challenge by SEPL, the construction thereof and their application was very much within the ken of the enquiry by the SAT in the appeal.”

The Court added that SEPL’s status vis-a-vis the corporate debtor had also not been considered, despite a specific ground having been raised in the appeal.

Accordingly, the Court set aside the SAT’s order and remanded the matter for fresh consideration on merits and in accordance with law.

The Court noted that under an earlier interim order, the demat account of SEPL had been allowed to be de-frozen upon deposit of Rs 58,04,505 with BSE, without prejudice and under protest, and that SEPL had paid this amount. It directed that the payment shall abide by the result of the appeal before the SAT. All issues, including SEPL’s entitlement to claim a refund with interest if it succeeds, were left open.

Cause Title: BSE Ltd. v. Spice Energy Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. [Civil Appeal No. 7038 of 2025]

Appearances:

Appellant: Sr. Adv. Amit Sibal, AOR P.N. Puri, Adv. Abhishek Puri, Adv. Sahil Grewal, Adv. Surbhi Gupta, Adv. Reeta Dewan Puri, Adv. Shreya Rajkamal

Respondents: Sr. Adv. Ashish Mohan, Sr. Adv. Chander Uday Singh, AOR Rishi Sehgal, AOR Mohit Paul, AOR M/s Expletus Legal, Adv. Ayush Agrawal, Adv. Vikrant Singh Bloria, Adv. Rangoli Seth, Adv. Sushant Tomar, Adv. Divyanshu Negi, Adv. Harsh Mittal, Adv. Abhishek Baid, Adv. Mohit Kumar Bafna, Adv. Anup Jain, Adv. Ashok Kumar Jain

Click here to read/download the Order