The Supreme Court today dismissed the appeal filed by the Uttar Pradesh Government against the Allahabad High Court order that stayed the conviction of Samajwadi Party leader Mohammad Azam Khan in a case over two birth certificates issued for his son.

The Court allowed the appeals of Azam Khan’s wife, Dr. Tanzeen Fatima, and son, Mohammad Abdullah Azam Khan, against the High Court’s refusal to stay their conviction in the same case.

All three were convicted by a Rampur court in October 2023 for conspiring to obtain two birth certificates showing different dates and places of birth for Abdullah Azam Khan. In May 2024, the High Court suspended the sentence of all three, but stayed the conviction of Azam Khan alone.

The Bench of Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Sheel Nagu ordered, "We have dismissed the appeal of the state government. We have allowed the appeals of Abdullah Azam Khan and Tazeem Fatima..."

The Court remarked, "The name of the lady is differently spelled by the High Court in the proceedings. And in the memo here, you have spelled it differently. The memo here is... Because we have noted that it is Tanzim Fatima. Tanzim Fatima in the proceedings before the High Court. And here it is Tazin Fatima."

Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal appeared for Azam Khan and Tazeen Fatima

The case arose from an FIR registered on January 3, 2019, at Ganj Police Station in Rampur, on a complaint by Akash Saxena, then Regional Convener of the BJP’s Small Scale Industry Cell in West Uttar Pradesh. The FIR named Samajwadi Party leader Mohammad Azam Khan, his wife Dr. Tanzeen Fatima and their son Mohammad Abdullah Azam Khan.

The FIR alleged that Azam Khan and Tanzeen Fatima conspired to get two birth certificates issued for their son. The first, dated June 28, 2012, was issued by the Nagar Palika Parishad, Rampur, and recorded his date of birth as January 1, 1993, and his place of birth as Rampur. The second, dated January 21, 2015, was issued by the Municipal Corporation, Lucknow, and recorded his date of birth as September 30, 1990, with Queen Mary’s Hospital, Lucknow as the place of birth. According to the prosecution, Abdullah Azam used the first certificate for his passport and the second in Government documents.

Abdullah Azam used the second birth certificate when he filed his nomination for the 2017 Uttar Pradesh Assembly election from the Suar constituency, and he won the seat. In December 2019, the Allahabad High Court set aside his election, as he was below the minimum age of 25 years on the date of nomination. The Supreme Court upheld that decision on November 7, 2022. While dismissing a review petition on February 7, 2023, it clarified that any criminal cases on the same subject would be decided on their own merits.

On October 18, 2023, the Special Judge Rampur convicted all three under Sections 120-B, 420, 467, 468 and 471 of the IPC. The court sentenced them to a maximum of seven years of simple imprisonment, with all sentences to run concurrently. On December 23, 2023, the Additional Sessions Judge/Special Judge (MP/MLA), Rampur dismissed their appeals.

The three then filed criminal revisions before the Allahabad High Court. They sought suspension of their sentence and a stay of their conviction while the revisions were pending.

On May 24, 2024, the High Court had suspended the sentence of all three and directed their release on bail. The High Court stayed the conviction of Azam Khan alone, holding that his case was distinguishable. It rejected the prayer for a stay of conviction for Tanzeen Fatima and Abdullah Azam.

The High Court noted that the prosecution’s claim that the Lucknow certificate of January 2015 was issued on the basis of a hospital certificate dated April 21, 2015 was “not possible at all, as the same is of later date.” It also noted that when it asked who had been cheated and what evidence of forgery there was against Azam Khan, the State and the complainant could not point to any material evidence, “except stating that since he was aware about the birth certificate dated 21.01.2015, therefore presumption shall be drawn against him.”

The High Court further observed that the officials who issued both birth certificates were neither examined during the investigation nor produced at trial. It added that the complainant was not a person deceived by the accused. It also considered that the offences were not heinous, that the accused had not misused their liberty while on bail during the trial, and that Azam Khan and Tanzeen Fatima were aged about 74 and 72 years respectively.

Accordingly, SLPs were filed before the Supreme Court by the State of U.P., Azam Khan and Tazeen Fatima.

Cause Title: State of U.P. v. Mohd. Azam Khan & Ors. [SLP(Crl) No. 11030-11032/2025] and other connected matters.