While upholding an order determining mesne profits payable by the tenant and closing a litigation which had engaged the parties for more than three decades, the Supreme Court has observed that the omission to consider a material piece of evidence having a direct bearing on the determination of mesne profits gives rise to a substantial question of law requiring correction.

The Apex Court was considering the Appeals arising out of a long-standing landlord-tenant dispute challenging the correctness of the rate of mesne profits and interest payable by the respondent-tenant for the continued occupation of the premises after the tenancy stood terminated.

The Bench comprising Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice N.V. Anjaria held, “We have carefully examined the reasoning adopted by the High Court. The High Court noticed that, while reversing the determination made by the Trial Court and limiting the grant of mesne profits only at the admitted rate of rent, the First Appellate Court had failed to advert to a material admission made by the respondent no. 1's own witness (DW-1 P.V. Ramani, officer of respondent no. 1) in his examination-in-chief regarding the prevailing rental value of comparable properties in the locality at the relevant point of time. The respondent no. 1’s witness had stated that at the time the tenancy stood terminated, the prevailing rate of rent in the locality ranged between Rs. 5/- and Rs. 8/- per square foot per month. Such omission was not insignificant. The omission to consider a material piece of evidence having a direct bearing on the determination of mesne profits was rightly regarded by the High Court as giving rise to a substantial question of law requiring correction.”

AOR Abhay Kumar represented the Appellant while Senior Advocate Prashanto Chandra Sen represented the Respondent.

Factual Background

The appeal was instituted by the legal representatives of the family members who had instituted a suit in 1990 seeking recovery of possession of the property after termination of the respondent tenant’s tenancy. Besides recovery of possession, the plaintiffs claimed damages for use and occupation at the rate of Rs. 1,47,500/- per month (equivalent to Rs. 4,916.67 per day) till delivery of vacant possession, together with interest. The Trial Court passed a preliminary decree under Order XX Rule 12 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, directing that a separate inquiry be conducted for determination of the pendente lite and future mesne profits payable to the plaintiffs. The appellants, along with the other legal representatives of the original plaintiffs, initiated proceedings before the Trial Court seeking determination of mesne profits payable by the first respondent.

The Trial Court determined mesne profits at the rate of Rs. 22 per square foot per month in respect of the carpet area of the ground floor and Rs. 11 per square foot per month in respect of the carpet area of the mezzanine floor, together with interest at the rate of 15% per annum. When the matter reached the First Appellate Court, the judgment passed by the Trial Court was set aside and limited mesne profits to the admitted rate of rent. The appellants then approached the High Court which led to the modification of the judgment of the First Appellate Court and determination of mesne profits at the rate of Rs. 7 per square foot per month in respect of the ground floor and Rs. 5 per square foot per month in respect of the mezzanine floor for the respective periods under consideration. The High Court further directed payment of simple interest at the rate of 7.5% per annum from the respective months in which the mesne profits became payable till realization. Aggrieved thereby, the appellants approached the Apex Court.

Reasoning

Referring to the judgment in Martin and Harris Private Limited and Another vs. Rajendra Mehta and Others (2022), the Bench stated, “It is well settled that mesne profits are compensatory in nature and are intended to recompense the true owner for the loss occasioned by the continued wrongful occupation of his property. Their assessment is not governed by any rigid or inflexible formula. The Court is required to arrive at a fair and reasonable estimate having regard to the nature and location of the property, the prevailing rental value, the evidence adduced by the parties and the attendant circumstances of each case. Equally, such determination is essentially one founded upon appreciation of evidence and, unless shown to be manifestly arbitrary, unsupported by the record or based upon an erroneous application of law, does not ordinarily warrant appellate interference.”

Considering that the High Court evaluated the material as well as the respondent’s witness evidence and thereafter determined the mesne profits at Rs. 7 per square foot per month in respect of the ground floor and Rs. 5 per square foot per month in respect of the mezzanine floor, the Bench stated, “We find that the determination represents a balanced assessment founded upon the evidence available on record.”

According to the Bench, the rate determined fell within the evidentiary range disclosed by the respondent's own witness and could not be characterised as arbitrary, speculative or based on no evidence to warrant interference by the Apex Court. The Bench further held that the High Court corrected the omission committed by the First Appellate Court in overlooking material evidence and thereafter proceeded to determine the mesne profits on a reasonable appreciation of the record. Observing that ‘interest’ forms an integral component of mesne profits and is intended to compensate the owner for being deprived of the beneficial enjoyment of the property during the period of wrongful occupation, the Bench refused to interfere with the direction relating to interest passed by the High Court.

On a perusal of the facts, the Bench noted that the litigation traced its origin to the termination of the tenancy with effect from December 31, 1989 and the decree for possession attained finality more than two decades ago in 2001. Considering that the appeals remained pending for nearly fifteen years and holding that the impugned judgment represented a fair and reasonable determination of the mesne profits payable by the respondent on the basis of the evidence available on record, the Bench dismissed the appeals.

Cause Title: Bharat Bhushan Jain (Dead) Through Lrs. And Others v. M/S Goodyear India Ltd. And Another (Neutral Citation: 2026 INSC 1240)

Appearance

Appellant: AOR Abhay Kumar, Advocates Shagun Ruhil, Shreenivash, Karan Chopra, Sakshi Sharma

Respondent: Senior Advocate Prashanto Chandra Sen, Advocates Nihit Nagpal, Livya P. Lalu, AOR M/s S. S. Rana & Co., AOR Bindra Rana, AOR Vikrant Rana, AOR Abha R. Sharma

Click here to read/download Judgment