Contempt Cannot Be Initiated Against Judicial Officer On Hearsay Version Of Alleged Open Court Remark Or Media Reports: Kerala High Court
Dismissing a lawyer’s petition over remarks allegedly made against her by a former District Judge, it also observed that judicial officers should not make oral observations in court “especially in this new era of social media”.

Justice P.V Kunhikrishnan, Kerala High Court
The Kerala High Court has held that it cannot initiate contempt proceedings against a judicial officer on the basis of a petitioner’s hearsay version of a statement allegedly made in open court, which was “not in the official records, but only in the air”. The Court said it could not order contempt proceedings against a judicial officer on media reports either, and that notice would not be issued to a sitting judicial officer unless there is a factual foundation and material showing contempt.
Dismissing the writ petition of Advocate T.B. Mini, the Court held that even if the alleged remarks were made, they could not be treated as contempt. It also observed that judicial officers should not make oral observations in court, especially in the age of social media, and that the media should not treat such courtroom dialogue as news.
A Single Judge Bench of Justice P.V. Kunhikrishnan observed, “…This Court cannot order the initiation of contempt proceedings against a judicial officer based on the media reports…there is no other material showing that such a statement was made by the 3rd respondent in the open Court. This Court cannot initiate contempt proceedings against the judicial officer based on the petitioner's hearsay version of an alleged statement made by the judicial officer in an open court, which is not in the official records, but only in the air. Based on such hearsay versions, this Court cannot initiate any proceedings against a judicial officer…”.
Advocate K. Nandini appeared for the petitioner, while P.A. Mohammed Shah, Additional Advocate General appeared for the Advocate GeneralHarikumar G, Standing Counsel, for the Registrar General.
The petitioner, who represented the victim in a Sessions trial, alleged that on January 12, 2026 the then Principal District and Sessions Judge, Ernakulam, Honey M. Varghese, said in open court during a contempt reference petition that she slept in court whenever she came and treated it as a resting place. She said the remark was widely reported and led to attacks on her on social media. She was not present in court that day, and relied on her junior’s account.
Her application seeking the Advocate General’s sanction to initiate contempt under Section 16 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 was dismissed on April 22, 2026. The Advocate General held that the statement, even if made, did not amount to criminal contempt and was at best “excessive or extravagant language,” citing Berely v. Xavier 1986 KHC 278.
In the writ petition, she sought to have her information placed before the Chief Justice for suo motu action, expunction of the remarks, and takedown directions to the Union.
The Court noted that there was no evidence the remark was made except the petitioner’s version. It declined to rely on the photocopy of the junior’s affidavit annexed to the sanction petition, since no affidavit was filed before it, and it declined to rely on the judge’s denial in a confidential file, as the petitioner had no access to it. It also declined to comment on media reports, since no media house was a party. It noted that the petitioner had “no case” that the remark was recorded in any judicial proceeding.
Referring to Joseph Kuzhanjalil v. Joseph Pulikunnel 1999 KHC 557, the Court said the Advocate General’s view is entitled to weight and due consideration, and held that his finding was correct. It said that even if the remarks were made, they could not be treated as contempt. It also observed that judges speak through their judgments, and that it saw no complaint against the petitioner’s capacity as a lawyer.
The Court dismissed the writ petition. It also rejected an I.A. for impleading news and YouTube channels, saying it need not conduct “a roving inquiry,” and another I.A. for calling for the records of the contempt reference petition.
Cause Title: T.B. Mini v. The Registrar General, High Court of Kerala & Ors. (Neutral Citation: 2026:KER:87660)
Appearances:
Petitioner: K. Nandini, Advocate.
Respondent: P.A. Mohammed Shah, Additional Advocate General; Harikumar G, Standing Counsel, for the 1st Respondent; M. Jayakrishnan, CGC.

