The Delhi High Court has held that, where a complainant does not sign the mediation form, the Insurance Ombudsman is required to adjudicate the complaint and take it to its “logical conclusion”, and that an award which does not do so is liable to be set aside.

Allowing a writ petition by the widow of a home loan borrower, the Bench quashed the Ombudsman’s award dated September 26, 2023, holding that the Ombudsman, whose orders involve civil consequences, must observe the principles of natural justice. The Court also set aside HDFC Ergo General Insurance Company’s repudiation of her claim, holding that cardiac arrest falls within “Myocardial Infarction” under the policy, and directed payment of Rs 27,97,445 with interest at 9% per annum.

A Bench of Justise Jasmeet Singh observed, “Once the petitioner was aggrieved by the repudiation of a claim and had approached the respondent No. 3, it was incumbent upon the respondent No. 3 to take the complaint of the petitioner to its logical conclusion. If the mediation form was not signed by the petitioner, it was required for the respondent No. 3 to adjudicate the complaint. Since the same has not been done and for the reasons stated above, the Award is liable to be set aside”.

“…in adjudicating a complaint against the repudiation of an insurance claim, passes orders which involve civil consequences and therefore is bound to adhere to the principles of natural justice”, the Bench further said.

Advocate Shantnu Aggarwal appeared for the petitioner, while Advocate Suman Bagga appeared for HDFC Ergo General Insurance Company Limited and Advocate Abhishek Nanda for the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India.

The petitioner’s late husband and his brother took a Rs 50 lakh home loan in July 2018, along with a five-year “Home Credit Assure” policy covering nine major medical illnesses, including “Myocardial Infarction”. He died of cardiac arrest on April 20, 2021. HDFC Ergo repudiated her claim on July 3, 2021, saying that death due to cardiac arrest, respiratory failure and bilateral pneumonitis was not covered.

In July 2023, the Court disposed of an earlier writ petition by directing her to approach the Insurance Ombudsman. The Ombudsman dismissed her complaint on September 26, 2023, recording that she had refused to sign a mediation form. She says she was given only a blank settlement form and pressed to sign it.

On maintainability, the Court held that HDFC Ergo, though a private entity, is amenable to Article 226, since insurers perform functions of a public nature. It noted that the case turned on a pure question of construction and a natural-justice challenge, and that she had exhausted the alternate forum. It held that the Ombudsman’s orders involve civil consequences and must observe natural justice, and noted that under Rule 17(1) of the Insurance Ombudsman Rules, 2017, an Ombudsman “shall pass an award” where mediation does not settle the complaint.

On the policy, the Court noted the insurer’s own case that both conditions arise from disrupted blood supply and are described as a “heart attack”, and held that cardiac arrest falls within “Myocardial Infarction”. It placed the burden of proving an exclusion on the insurer, applied contra proferentem, and said a narrow reading would “substantially defeat” the purpose of the cover. It declined to require expert medical opinion.

The Court directed HDFC Ergo to pay Rs 27,97,445, being 50% of the insured sum for the husband’s share as one of two insured persons, with 9% interest from July 3, 2021 until payment. It also directed payment of Rs 5,08,176 towards the loan-interest component, with the later interest component paid until actual payment.

Cause Title: Sushma Tyagi v. HDFC Ergo General Insurance Company Limited & Ors. (Neutral Citation: 2026:DHC:10223)

Appearances:

Petitioner: Shantnu Aggarwal, Advocate.

Respondents: Suman Bagga, Advocate, Abhishek Nanda, Hrishika Rawat and Yashika Singh, Advocates

Click here to read/download the Judgment