Mere Fact That Complaint Was Initiated By Individual Consumer Cannot Furnish Reason For Treating Grievance As Individual In Nature: Delhi High Court
The Court set aside a CCPA communication that closed a complaint over CUET (UG) 2025 books as “individual” in nature, and directed a fresh reasoned decision within two months.

Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma, Delhi High Court
The Delhi High Court has held that the mere fact that a complaint was initiated by an individual consumer cannot, by itself, furnish a reason for treating the underlying grievance as individual in nature. The Court said the distinction between an individual grievance and a matter concerning consumers as a class is material to the statutory functions of the Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA).
Setting aside a CCPA communication that closed a complaint over books the petitioner alleged were marketed as “For 2025 Exam” and “Strictly as per the latest examination pattern and syllabus”, the Bench remitted the complaint for fresh consideration. The CCPA must pass a reasoned order within two months and consider the petitioner’s objection to the competence of the officer who dealt with it.
A Bench of Justice Dr. Swarana Kanta Sharma observed that the CCPA “The distinction between an individual consumer grievance and a matter concerning consumers as a class is material in the context of the statutory functions of the CCPA. The mere fact that the complaint was initiated by an individual consumer could not, by itself, furnish a reason for treating the underlying grievance as individual in nature. The CCPA, in this Court’s view, was required to examine the substance of the complaint and record, at least briefly, the basis on which it concluded that the matter did not fall within its statutory purview and that the grievance was of ‘individual nature’. A reasoned decision was particularly necessary since the petitioner had invoked the jurisdiction of the CCPA under the provisions dealing with consumer rights, unfair trade practices and misleading advertisements”.
Petitioner appeared-in-person while Avshreya Pratap Singh Rudy, CGSC appeared for the respondent.
The petitioner alleged that Oswaal Books and Learning Private Limited marketed CUET (UG) 2025 books with those representations before the National Testing Agency released the syllabus and pattern. After buying the books in February 2025, he complained to the CCPA on May 5, 2025 under Sections 17 and 19 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.
He moved the High Court in August 2025 for a decision on his complaint. On September 24, 2025, an Under Secretary of the CCPA communicated that the grievance was “of individual nature”, forwarded it to the National Consumer Helpline, and said no action lay. On March 25, 2026, the High Court left him to approach the NCDRC, which held on May 8, 2026 that no appeal lay under Section 24.
The petitioner argued that the grievance was not individual, since the books were marketed to students across the country, and that the communication was unreasoned and issued by an officer lacking competence. The respondents argued that the grievance was individual, that Section 19 does not mandate investigation in every complaint, and that the communication was issued on behalf of the CCPA.
The Court noted that the communication did not disclose why the grievance was treated as individual, and did not consider the nature of the allegations, the manner of marketing, or that the representations concerned a national-level examination. It said the CCPA may ultimately conclude that no proceedings are warranted, but such a conclusion must follow from consideration of the complaint and the statutory scheme and disclose adequate reasons, “even if brief”. It expressed no opinion on the merits.
The Court set aside the communication and remitted the complaint to the CCPA, directing a fresh reasoned order within two months by the competent authority, with liberty to the petitioner to avail remedies if aggrieved.
Cause Title: Rupesh Kumar Jha v. Central Consumer Protection Authority & Ors. (Neutral Citation: 2026:DHC:10249)
Appearances:
Petitioner: appeared in person
Respondent: Avshreya Pratap Singh Rudy, CGSC, with Usha Jamnal, Nyasa Sharma, Ankit Khatri, Siddhant Nagar and Abhinav Mall, Advocates, Shubham Gill and Ishank Gupta, Advocates
Click here to read/download the Judgment
