Distinction Between Proof Of Sexual Intercourse & Proof Of Rape Is Fundamental: Delhi High Court Acquits Rape Accused
The Court while acquitting the man, held that the Trial Court wrongly drew an adverse inference from the accused not cross-examining a prosecutrix who had disowned the allegations, and placed on him the burden of explaining the DNA.

Justice Ravinder Dudeja, Delhi High Court
The Delhi High Court has acquitted a man convicted of rape in 2014, holding that the presence of his DNA on a bed sheet, even if it establishes sexual contact, does not by itself establish that the contact was without the prosecutrix’s consent. The Court said the distinction between proof of sexual intercourse and proof of rape is fundamental, and that the former cannot automatically lead to the conclusion that the latter has been established.
The prosecutrix had turned hostile and denied the allegations, therefore, the Court held that the Trial Court was wrong to draw an adverse inference from the accused not cross-examining her, to require him to explain the DNA, and to treat the superficial abrasions on her neck as conclusive evidence of force. It also held that the Trial Court’s explanation for the absence of any chemical traces, which was central to the allegation of hurt, was speculative.
A Single Bench of Justice Ravinder Dudeja observed, “…Even assuming that the presence of the appellant’s biological material on the bed sheet establishes sexual contact, it does not, by itself, establish that such contact was without the consent of the prosecutrix. The distinction between proof of sexual intercourse and proof of rape is fundamental, and the former cannot automatically lead to the conclusion that the latter has been established. It is also relevant that the presence of the appellant’s DNA on the bed sheet may be consistent with his presence in the house, which is an admitted position and is not disputed by the appellant. In the absence of reliable evidence independently establishing that the sexual act was without the consent of the prosecutrix, the DNA evidence cannot be treated as conclusive proof of rape. The Trial Court, therefore, fell into error in treating the DNA findings as sufficient to establish not merely the occurrence of sexual contact but also its alleged non-consensual nature”.
Advocate Pradeep Kumar Sharma appeared for the appellant, Satinder Singh Bawa, Public Prosecutor appeared for the State, while Advocate Megha Singh appeared for the prosecutrix.
According to the prosecution, the appellant, whom the prosecutrix had known for about two years, came to her house on the pretext of buying a motorcycle, and forcibly had sexual intercourse with her and poured an unknown chemical into her private parts. An FIR was registered at Police Station Bhalswa Dairy under Sections 376 and 323 IPC. Charges were framed under Sections 376 and 324 IPC, and the prosecution examined 15 witnesses.
The Additional Sessions Judge, Special Fast Track Court, Rohini, convicted him on May 9, 2014 and sentenced him on May 10, 2014 to ten years of rigorous imprisonment with a fine of Rs 20,000 under Section 376, and three years with a fine of Rs 5,000 under Section 324, to run concurrently. The appellant appealed under Section 374 of the CrPC.
The prosecutrix, examined as PW-5, said that the appellant had done nothing wrong to her, and was declared hostile. The Court said her earlier statement could not be treated as substantive evidence, that hostility alone does not result in acquittal, and that the court must examine whether the remaining evidence independently proves the offence. It held that the medical evidence showed two superficial abrasions that the examining doctor admitted could be caused by the shrugging of clothes, and that the appellant had no fresh injury.
On the DNA report, the Court held that the appellant’s presence in the house was admitted and that the DNA could not be conclusive proof of rape without independent evidence on consent. The chemical examination found no acid or other chemical, and the explanation that the prosecutrix might have bathed, douched or urinated was unsupported by any medical evidence. It also noted that the prosecution had not examined a tenant living in the house.
The Court held that the circumstances, taken together, did not form a complete chain pointing to guilt, set aside the conviction and sentence, and acquitted the appellant of all charges. The bail bond was cancelled and the surety discharged.
Cause Title: Narayan v. State (Neutral Citation: 2026:DHC:9974)
Appearances:
Appellant: Advocates Pradeep Kumar Sharma, Agam Sharma and Charvi Kwatra.
Respondent: Public Prosecutor Satinder Singh Bawa with SI Monika, PS Bhalswa Dairy, for the State; Advocates Astha and Megha Singh (DHCLSC) for the prosecutrix.

