The Delhi High Court has held that, under paragraph 22(i) of the Vivad se Vishwas II (Contractual Disputes) Scheme, the procuring entity is the competent authority to accept a settlement and cannot abdicate that obligation by referring the decision to the public authority on whose behalf the procurement was made. Where the claim is Rs. 500 crore or less, the Court held, the procuring entity is bound to accept it.

The Court held that where a public authority, which may not be an instrumentality of the Central Government, procures through a Central Public Sector Enterprise, the Scheme in effect applies to it. It found that Noida could not disown the Scheme, and that the pendency of a Section 34 challenge to the award is no embargo. It set aside IRCON International Limited’s rejection of the contractor’s claim and directed it to execute the settlement.

A Single Bench of Justice Amit Mahajan observed, “…A plain reading of the paragraph 22 (i) of the Scheme as quoted supra, reveals that the procuring entity shall be the competent authority to accept the settlement under the Scheme. The language employed in the paragraph is mandatory and the same does not contemplate the procuring authority sharing its decision-making power with the public authority. The mandatory language thus employed in paragraph 22(i) leaves no room for doubt that the procuring entity would be the competent authority to accept settlement, and it cannot abdicate the obligation entrusted to it under paragraph 22(i) by referring the ultimate decision to Respondent No. 2…”.

“…In the opinion of this Court, once a procurement is done by any public authority (which may not be an instrumentality of the Central Government) through a Central Public Sector Enterprise as enumerated in paragraph 4 of the Scheme, then the scheme in effect is made applicable to such public authority”, it noted further.

Senior Advocate Kirtiman Singh appeared for the petitioner, while Advocate Abhay Kr. Tayal appeared for respondent No. 2.

IRCON had floated a tender on behalf of Noida for road works on the Noida-Greater Noida expressway, and the contract was awarded to the petitioner in 2001. After disputes arose, a Sole Arbitrator awarded the petitioner Rs. 9,44,09,629 with 12% interest on June 6, 2016. The respondents’ Section 34 challenge was returned for lack of jurisdiction.

In execution proceedings, the High Court directed a deposit of Rs. 15,37,55,780, which was made, and closed the proceedings on October 24, 2024, with liberty to revive them.

Meanwhile, the petitioner uploaded a claim of Rs. 8,21,15,653.75 under the Scheme on October 27, 2023. On August 23, 2024, IRCON rejected it, stating that Noida is a state entity whose funds are required under paragraph 22 and that it could not proceed without Noida’s permission. The petitioner approached the High Court by a writ petition. Noida argued that the Scheme is central in nature and inapplicable to it, and that a Section 34 challenge is pending.

The Court held that IRCON, as a Central Public Sector Enterprise, is a procuring entity and that the petitioner met the eligibility conditions. It found that paragraph 22(i) is mandatory and does not contemplate the procuring entity sharing its decision-making power with the public authority, and that under paragraph 18, claims of Rs. 500 crore or less must be accepted.

It noted that paragraph 22 does not restrict the expression “public authority” to Central bodies. Having voluntarily routed the procurement through a Central agency, Noida could not “approbate and reprobate” by disowning the Scheme, since that would render paragraph 22 otiose. It added that paragraph 10(b) allows settlement even where the award is under challenge.

The Court set aside the rejection and directed IRCON to execute the settlement in terms of the Scheme dated May 29, 2023. It held that Noida shall provide the budget for the settlement under paragraph 22(ii).

Cause Title: Maytas Subhash v. IRCON International Limited & Anr. (Neutral Citation: 2026:DHC:10103)

Appearances:

Petitioner: Kirtiman Singh, Sr. Adv., Siddhant Jaiswal and Ritwik, Advocates.

Respondent: Abhay Kr. Tayal, Advocate.

Click here to read/download the Judgment