The Delhi High Court has held that the status of a convict as a police officer and the resulting breach of public trust, though undoubtedly an aggravating circumstance, cannot by itself furnish the basis for capital punishment, as it declined to enhance to death the life sentences of a man convicted of two murders.

Dismissing three cross-appeals, the Court upheld the conviction of Ajay Kumar Tomar under Sections 302 and 397 of the IPC and the Arms Act, and rejected pleas by the State and the son of one of the deceased for the extreme penalty, holding that the case, “however grave”, is not a “rarest of rare” case.


A Division Bench of Justice Navin Chawla and Justice Ravinder Dudeja observed, “The commission of two murders, though a grave aggravating circumstance, cannot mechanically lead to the conclusion that the death penalty must follow. Also, the appellant's status as a police officer and the breach of trust of the public, which believes the police officials to be their protectors, while undoubtedly an aggravating and connected matters circumstance, cannot by itself furnish the basis for capital punishment. While awarding the sentence, the Court is required to determine whether the cumulative effect of all the circumstances is so overwhelming that life imprisonment would serve no legitimate purpose. On the material placed before us, such a conclusion cannot safely be drawn”.

Advocate Sudarshan Rajan appeared for the appellant, while Aman Usman, APP appeared for the State and Advocate Pawan Reley appeared for respondent no. 2.

According to the prosecution, on September 24, 2011, Amarjeet Singh Chaddha was shot thrice in his car near Railway Hospital, SPM Marg, after his gold chains were snatched by a man in police uniform. While being chased by a head constable who had taken a lift on a civilian’s motorcycle, the man allegedly fired again, striking Harender Singh @ Sunny in the neck.

The Trial Court at Tis Hazari convicted him in December 2021 under Sections 302 and 397 IPC and Sections 25 and 27 of the Arms Act, and by order of May 13, 2022 imposed life imprisonment for each murder, observing that the case was not a “rarest of the rare” one. Tomar challenged the conviction, while the State and the son of Amarjeet Singh Chaddha sought enhancement of the sentence.

On guilt, the Bench held that omissions in the eyewitness’s testimony did not travel to the core of the prosecution case, and that his testimony was corroborated by medical, ballistic, fingerprint and recovery evidence. It also treated the victim’s statement at the spot as a dying declaration. As to Sunny’s death, it observed that an intention to kill “can be formed even at the spur of the moment”.

On sentence, the Court termed the offence “heinous” and treated the abuse of a police officer’s position of trust as a significant aggravating circumstance. However, it held that aggravating circumstances “cannot by themselves justify the imposition of the death penalty”. Applying Bachan Singh and Machhi Singh, it found no “exceptional brutality, extraordinary depravity” or circumstances placing the appellant beyond reform.

The Bench concluded that a finding that life imprisonment would serve no legitimate purpose “cannot safely be drawn”. All three appeals were dismissed, the sentence was maintained, and a copy was directed to be sent to the Trial Court and the Jail Superintendent.

Cause Title: Harvinder Singh @ Vimpy Chaddha v. The State of NCT of Delhi & Anr. (Neutral Citation: 2026:DHC:10122-DB)

Appearances:

Appellant: Sudarshan Rajan, Hitain Bajaj and Sunny Sharma, Advocates

Respondent: Aman Usman, APP, with Manvendra Yadav, Advocate, Pawan Reley, Akshay Lodhi, Simran Singh, Gaurav Kumar, Tanish Rawat & Prakhar Agrawal, Advs. for R-2.

Click here to read/download the Judgment