SC Stayed Patna HC's Order Directing Bihar DGP To Produce Sahara Group Chief Subrata Roy Before It
The Supreme Court Friday stayed the direction of the Patna High Court asking the Director General of Police (DGP), Bihar, to produce Sahara Group chief Subrata Roy before it on May 16 in a matter in which it was said that some companies of the Group were not returning money to the investors.
The Apex Court also stayed the separate order passed by the High Court which had on February 11 directed to add Sahara Credit Cooperative Societies Limited and Roy as opposite parties to a bail petition pending before it and later, directed him to personally appear before it.
On April 27, the High Court had directed Roy to personally appear before it noting that Sahara Group and other companies, which have been taking deposits till about one month back, are directed to come up with a plan for the return of investment of the investors.
A Bench of Justice A M Khanwilkar and Justice J B Pardiwala issued notice on the petition filed by Sahara chief challenging the High Court orders.
It is urged that the private complaint filed by one Naresh Kumar Das is against accused persons named therein. The petitioner has not been named as an accused. Further, the impugned order has been passed against the petitioner on an application for anticipatory bail filed by Pramod Kumar Saini, who has been named as accused no.4, the bench noted in its order.
Issue notice, returnable on May 19, 2022, it said, adding, Stay of operation of the impugned judgment and order qua the petitioner herein.
Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal, appearing for the petitioner, informed the bench that earlier in the day, the high court has passed an order directing the Bihar DGP to produce Roy before the court on May 16 at 10.30 AM.
We are informed that pursuant to the impugned order, the high court has issued further orders today, i.e. May 13, 2022, which has the effect of directing the concerned authority in Patna (police) to produce the petitioner before the court. In terms of this order, we stay the operation of the direction given by the high court qua the petitioner till the next date of hearing, the bench said in its order.
All concerned to act on this order forthwith until the further hearing of this matter, it said. Sibal told the Bench that the High Court had passed these orders while hearing an anticipatory bail plea which has nothing to do with the petitioner.
He argued that some investors moved the high court and said Sahara group has not given them the money and the high court then passed the order in February.
Earlier in the day, the High Court noted in its order, which is uploaded on its website, that prayer for exemption of Roy has been earlier rejected twice on May 6 and May 12.
The High Court also observed that despite various chances given to Roy, he has failed to appear before it and the court has no option, but to order the authorities to produce him physically before it on May 16.
The Director-General of Police, Bihar, is directed to produce Subrata Roy Sahara in this court on May 16, 2022, at 10.30 AM (Monday). The Commissioner of Police, Delhi, and the Director-General of Police, Uttar Pradesh will co-operate with the Director-General of Police, Bihar in this matter, the High Court said in its order passed earlier in the day.
In its April 27 order, the High Court noted that while considering the anticipatory bail applications, the court has come across cases of cheating committed by Non-Banking Financial Companies (NBFCs), and considering the same, various orders were passed in these cases earlier.
The High Court had noted that it was informed that the Bihar Protection of Interest of Depositors (in Financial Establishments) Act, 2002 was enacted to control such activities but the public at large has been cheated by NBFCs without any control and the government functionaries under the Act have not been able to give any relief to them.
It had also noted that a large number of complaints before the authorities under the 2002 Act for non-payment of maturity amount by different entities of Sahara Group registered as NBFCs, multi-purpose cooperative society, etc. have been received by the authorities but the Group has somehow evaded payment of maturity amount of the investors.
On being noticed, Sahara Group has come with a plea that about Rupees 25,000 crores belonging to the Sahara Credit Cooperative Society Limited has been lying with SEBI and they are ready to pay the investors' investment if SEBI returns the amount to them as per the order of the Supreme Court dated August 31, 2012, the high court had noted.
Prior to that, on February 11, the high court had noted in its order that some interlocutory applications have been filed by some intervenors that their money is lying with Sahara Credit Cooperative Societies Limited and other companies of the Sahara Group and they have not been returning the amount to the investors.
With PTI inputs