Every Place Where Namaz Is Offered Can't Be Treated As Mosque: SC Directs Removal Of Mosque Inside Allahabad HC Complex
The Supreme Court has directed authorities to remove a mosque from the premises of the Allahabad High Court within three months, telling the petitioners opposing the demolition that the structure stood on a terminated lease property and they can't claim it as a matter of right to continue.
The Court observed during the hearing that every place where namaz is offered cannot be termed as a mosque. The Court noted that if that is permitted, roads will also be converted to mosques. The Counsel for the Allahabad High Court had argued that if namaz is allowed for convenience in the Supreme Court or High Court verandah, it will not become a mosque.
The petitioners, Waqf Masjid High Court and UP Sunni Central Waqf Board, had challenged a November 2017 Allahabad High Court's order, which had given them three months to move the mosque out of the premises.
A Bench of Justice MR Shah and Justice CT Ravikumar, however, allowed the petitioners to make a representation to the UP government for allotment of land nearby for the mosque.
It told the petitioners that the land was a lease property, which was terminated, and they can't claim it as a matter of right to continue.
"We further grant three months time to demolish the construction in question by the petitioners and if the construction is not removed within a period of three months from today, it will be open for authorities including the high court to have them removed or demolished," the Bench said.
Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal, appearing for the management committee of the mosque, said the mosque has been there since the 1950s and it cannot be just asked to move out.
"The government changed in 2017 and everything changed. A PIL is filed 10 days after the new government was formed. We have no problems with shifting to an alternative place as long as they give it to us," he said.
Senior Advocate Rakesh Dwivedi, appearing for the High Court, said that this was a case of complete fraud.
"Twice there were renewal applications and there was no whisper at all that the mosque was constructed and it was used for the public. They sought renewal saying it was needed for residential purposes. The mere fact that they are offering namaz will not make it a mosque. If in the Supreme Court verandah or High Court verandah, if namaz is allowed for convenience, it will not become a mosque," he said.
The Court had earlier asked the Uttar Pradesh government to explore the possibility of granting a piece of land to relocate the mosque.
The High Court had told the Apex Court that it does not have an alternative plot of land to relocate the mosque and the state may consider shifting it to another area. It had also said there was already a shortage of space for parking.
The Apex Court previously directed the parties to arrive at a consensus on where the mosque should be relocated.
With PTI inputs