
Date Of Election Stands Excluded In Computing 45 Days U/S 81(1) RP Act: Madras High Court Refuses To Reject Petition Against Udhayanidhi Stalin's Election
|The Court held that the alleged improper rejection of a nomination, a defective Form-26 affidavit and alleged non-disclosure of assets raise triable issues that can be decided only after evidence.
The Madras High Court has held that, in computing the forty-five days for presenting an election petition under Section 81(1) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951, the date of election of the returned candidate stands excluded under Section 9 of the General Clauses Act, 1897. The Court held that a petition presented on June 18, 2026, against a result declared on May 4, 2026, was filed on the last day of the period and was within time.
Dismissing the returned candidate’s applications to reject the petition and to strike out paragraphs 6 to 23, the Court held that the pleadings disclose material facts and raise triable issues. The petition challenges the election of Udhayanidhi Stalin from the Chepauk constituency in the 2026 Tamil Nadu Legislative Assembly election.
A Single Judge Bench of Justice G. Arul Murugan while citing Tarun Prasad Chatterjee v. Dinanath Sharma (2000), observed, “…the results having been declared on 04.05.2026, that date stands excluded under Section 9 of the General Clauses Act, 1897. The forty-five days, accordingly, commence on 05.05.2026 and expire on 18.06.2026. The election petition, presented on 18.06.2026, was filed on the last day of that period and is well within time. The objection on limitation fails”.
Senior Advocate P. Wilson appeared for the returned candidate, while Advocate J. Vinoth appeared for the election petitioner.
“…Sections 82 and 84 of the RP Act together show that the scheme of the Act contemplates a challenge founded on the improper rejection of the nomination of another candidate, without that candidate being joined. The question of impleading Dilip Kumar therefore does not arise, and the petition has been filed against the necessary party for the relief sought”, the Bench also noted.
P. Milany, an independent candidate from Chepauk, filed an Election Petition seeking a declaration that the election is void under Sections 100(1)(c), 100(1)(d)(i) and 100(1)(d)(iv) of the Act.
The petition pleads that the nomination of Dilip Kumar, set up by Tamilaga Vetri Kazhagam, was rejected on April 7, 2026 on the ground that “Main candidate nomination is accepted. Hence substitute nomination is rejected”. It also alleges that the returned candidate’s Form-26 affidavit was not notarised in the prescribed form and suppressed buildings, liabilities and investments.
The returned candidate sought rejection under Order VII Rule 11 CPC and striking out under Order VI Rule 16 CPC. He contended that the petition was filed on the forty-sixth day and barred, lacked material facts, and was bad for non-joinder of Dilip Kumar.
Applying the Three-Judge Bench ruling in Tarun Prasad Chatterjee, the Court held that the period ran from May 5 to June 18, 2026. It noted that Youaraj Rai v. Chander Bahadur Kark (2007) turned on identifying the date of election, not on Section 9, and that the Supreme Court had set aside the Jharkhand High Court orders in Kishorlal v. Parimal Nathwani (2011).
On non-joinder, the Court held that Sections 82 and 84 show the Act contemplates a challenge founded on improper rejection of another candidate’s nomination without joining that candidate, where no corrupt practice is alleged against him. Whether Clause 6.10.3(iv) of the Handbook for Returning Officers applied was held to be a triable issue.
On the alleged suppression, the Court held that the returned candidate’s explanations cannot be considered at this stage. It held that whether the buildings were included in the declared values, and whether his and his wife’s guarantee for a Rs. 7 crore term loan of Snow Housing Private Limited required disclosure, call for trial.
The Court dismissed both applications, clarifying that its observations do not express any opinion on the merits. The returned candidate must file his reply statement within four weeks, and the petition is listed on December 11, 2026.
Cause Title: Udhayanidhi Stalin v. P. Milany, O.A. Nos. 860 and 861 of 2026 in E.L.P. No. 18 of 2026
Appearances:
Applicant (returned candidate): P. Wilson, Sr. Counsel, for Richardson Wilson.
Respondent (election petitioner): Adv. J. Vinoth, for A.K.M. Venkatesh.