Madras High Court
Without Proof Of Intoxication, Knowledge Cannot Be Attributed: Madras High Court Alters Conviction From S.304 IPC To S. 304A IPC
Madras High Court

Without Proof Of Intoxication, Knowledge Cannot Be Attributed: Madras High Court Alters Conviction From S.304 IPC To S. 304A IPC

Agatha Shukla
|
16 Nov 2026 11:10 AM IST

The Court held that no reliable evidence of blood alcohol above the legal limit existed, since no breath analyser or blood test was done; faults the doctor and the investigating officer.

The Madras High Court, Madurai Bench has held that, in the absence of proof that a lorry driver was under the influence of alcohol, the knowledge required for culpable homicide not amounting to murder under Section 304 Part II of the IPC cannot be attributed to him. The Court observed that rashness and negligence, however gross, do not by themselves establish such knowledge, and that once the prosecution failed to prove intoxication, the aggravating circumstance on which the conviction rested was absent. It altered his conviction to one under Section 304A for causing death by negligence.

The Court acquitted the appellant under Section 185 of the Motor Vehicles Act because neither a breath analyser test nor a blood test was conducted. It criticised the doctor who examined him and the investigating officer for this lapse. It awarded the maximum two years of rigorous imprisonment under Section 304A for each of the two deaths and, using Section 31 of the CrPC, directed that the sentences run consecutively.

A Single Bench of Justice D. Lingeswaran observed, “…There is no doubt that the lorry was driven at high speed and that the appellant was rash and negligent. However, in the absence of proof that he was under the influence of alcohol, the knowledge required for an offence under Section 304 Part II of the IPC cannot be attributed to him…The prosecution having failed to prove that the appellant was under the influence of alcohol at the time of the accident, one aggravating circumstance on which the conviction under Section 304 Part II of the IPC rested is absent. That section requires proof that the accused acted with the knowledge that his act was likely to cause death, though without intention to cause it. Rashness and negligence, however gross, do not by themselves establish such knowledge”.

Advocate S. Ravi appeared for the appellant and G. Ganesh Kumar, Government Advocate appeared for the respondent.

“…The observation of PW-1 that the appellant appeared to be drunk may show that the appellant had consumed alcohol, but a lay impression cannot substitute for the proof the statute requires. There is therefore no reliable evidence that the appellant had alcohol in his blood beyond the permitted limit. The conviction under Section 185 of the Motor Vehicles Act cannot be sustained”, the Bench further noted.

The prosecution case was that on March 6, 2016, at about 2 pm, the appellant, Muthiah, drove a lorry under the influence of alcohol on the Theni–Madurai High Road near the Government Hospital, Andipatti. He allegedly drove into a crowd, hit two persons, then a Tata Magic van, an auto-rickshaw and two electric poles, and did not stop until he was intercepted at a checkpost. Two persons died, and three persons in the van and one pedestrian were injured.

The Additional District and Sessions Judge (Fast Track), Theni, convicted him on October 12, 2018 under Sections 279, 304 Part II (two counts) and 337 (four counts) of the IPC and Section 185 of the Motor Vehicles Act. It imposed seven years of rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs 5,000 for each count under Section 304 Part II, and a fine of Rs 1,000 for each count under Section 337. It imposed no sentence under Section 279 or Section 185 and acquitted him under Section 427. The appellant filed an appeal under Section 374(2) of the CrPC.

The appellant argued that no breath analyser or blood test was conducted, that the trial court relied only on the drunkenness certificate (Exhibit P-12), and that he was not identified as the driver. The State relied on eyewitness evidence and the inspection report.

The Court accepted the eyewitness evidence and rejected the plea of mistaken identity. It found the endorsement on the certificate was made by the police, not the doctor, and that the doctor’s evidence was contradictory. It held that a lay impression of drunkenness could not substitute for the proof the statute requires. It distinguished Alistair Anthony Pareira v. State of Maharashtra, where the accused was drunk and knew the route, and relied on Prabhakaran v. State of Kerala. It held that the appellant, a stranger to the area, may have sped away from panic, which is as consistent with fear as with knowledge.

The Court partly allowed the appeal and altered the conviction to Section 304A (two counts) with two years of rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs 5,000 on each count, to run consecutively. It upheld the convictions under Sections 337 and 279 and the fine under Section 337, acquitted him under Section 185 of the Motor Vehicles Act, and directed him to surrender immediately, with set-off for the period already undergone.

Cause Title: Muthiah v. The Inspector of Police, Andipatti Police Station, Theni District (CRL A(MD) No. 108 of 2019)

Click here to read/download the Judgment



Similar Posts