
State Cannot Take Adverse Action Against Employee Over Caste Certificate After Years Of Unexplained Delay: Karnataka High Court
|The Court noted that there was no allegation that the constable had fabricated, forged or concocted his caste certificate; the error arose from verification against the State list instead of the Central OBC list applicable to a Central service.
The Karnataka High Court has held that the State cannot take adverse action against an employee over his caste status after allowing him to continue in service for years without explaining the delay.
Applying the Supreme Court’s ruling in Dattu S/o Namdev Thakur v. State of Maharashtra and Others (2012), which disapproved action initiated after nine years, the Court rejected the CISF Commandant’s appeal and upheld relief granted to a constable after nearly 14 years of service.
The Court was hearing an intra-court appeal filed by the CISF Commandant under Section 4 of the Karnataka High Court Act, 1961, against an order quashing the communication questioning the constable’s caste status. The Single Judge had found that the authorities failed to explain the prolonged delay in correcting the verification and could not deprive the employee of the benefit of his long service.
A Division Bench of Justice M. Nagaprasanna and Justice Hema Kulkarni observed: “The learned Single Judge follows the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of DATTU S/O NAMDEV THAKUR v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND OTHERS, which had clearly held that after delay of 9 years, the State could not have taken action against the appellant before the Apex Court.”
Deputy Solicitor General of India Venkatesh M. Kharvi appeared for the CISF Commandant, Advocate Prashant S. Hosamani appeared for the constable, and Additional Government Advocate Sharad V. Magadum represented the State authorities.
Background
The constable obtained a caste certificate recording that he belonged to the Hindu-Reddy community under Category III(A). Relying on that certificate, he participated in the CISF selection process and was appointed as a constable in 2009. His documents were thereafter sent for verification.
In 2018, the jurisdictional Tahsildar confirmed that the certificate was proper and that the employee belonged to Hindu-Reddy Category III(A). However, that verification relied upon the Karnataka State list. Since the appointment was to a Central service, the employee’s eligibility for reservation had to be examined under the Central OBC list, in which the community was not included.
Four years after the Tahsildar’s report, the District Commissioner communicated to the CISF Commandant that the certificate relied upon for the appointment was not valid for claiming reservation in Central Government employment. By then, approximately 13 years had elapsed from the appointment, and the employee had completed nearly 14 years of service when the dispute was considered.
The employee challenged the communication before the Single Judge. The CISF and State authorities argued that his appointment had been obtained under an inapplicable reservation category and that the later re-verification followed a complaint. They nevertheless admitted that there had been laxity in verifying his status.
The Single Judge quashed the communication. Besides granting individual relief, the Single Judge directed the State to establish an electronic dashboard for employers to upload caste documents, prescribe timelines for verification and educate officials about the distinction between State and Central reservation lists.
Court’s Observations
No Allegation Of Forgery Or Fabrication
The Division Bench noted the Single Judge’s finding that the case did not involve a fabricated or forged certificate. The employee had correctly disclosed that he belonged to the Hindu-Reddy community under Category III(A), but claimed reservation on the basis of the State list even though his appointment was to the CISF, a Central service.
The Single Judge had recorded: “In the present case, there is no allegation that the petitioner has either fabricated, forged or concocted the caste certificate.”
The error arose when the Tahsildar confirmed the certificate by referring to the Karnataka list instead of examining whether the community appeared in the Central OBC list. The Division Bench considered this factual setting while deciding whether the Single Judge’s protection of the employee’s service warranted appellate interference.
Authorities Failed To Explain The Prolonged Delay
The Court noted that the employee was appointed in 2009, while the Tahsildar verified the certificate only in 2018. The authorities did not explain why verification took nearly ten years from the date of appointment.
Even after the 2018 report, the District Commissioner waited until 2022 to seek correction. The Single Judge had found no explanation for this additional four-year delay and applied Dattu, in which the Supreme Court protected benefits already obtained after the State delayed caste scrutiny for nine years.
The Single Judge had held: “Thus, the Hon’ble Apex Court in Dattu’s case (supra) having held that if there is any unexplained delay, the benefit of long service cannot be taken away, I am of the considered opinion that the said decision would also apply to the present case and come to the rescue of the petitioner.”
Intra-Court Appeal Required Demonstrable Error Or Perversity
The Court also relied on Bihar Industrial Area Development Authority v. Scope Sales (P) Ltd. (2026) concerning the limits of intra-court appellate jurisdiction. It observed that a Division Bench should not replace a plausible and reasonable view of the Single Judge merely because another view might also be possible.
The Bench stated: “The Apex Court, in the fore-quoted judgment, considering the entire spectrum of the law, directs that the Division Bench hearing the appeals against the orders of the learned Single Judge must not interfere as a matter of course, but only if the Court could find the order to be perverse.”
Since the Single Judge had followed a binding Supreme Court precedent and had relied on the unexplained delay and absence of any allegation of fabrication, the Division Bench found no ground to interfere.
Conclusion
The High Court rejected the CISF Commandant’s appeal and upheld the Single Judge’s order quashing the communication issued against the constable after nearly 14 years of service. It found no demonstrable error or perversity in applying Dattu to the unexplained delay, particularly when the case did not involve an allegation that the employee had forged or fabricated the certificate.
The Court also disposed of all pending applications. The Single Judge’s general directions for time-bound electronic caste verification consequently remained undisturbed.
Cause Title: The Commandant, CISF v. Virupaxagouda and Others (Neutral Citation: 2026:KHC-D:17609-DB)
Appearances
Appellant: Venkatesh M. Kharvi, Deputy Solicitor General of India
Respondents: Prashant S. Hosamani and Vidyashri N. Mulimani, Advocates; Sharad V. Magadum, Advocate