
Justice Vikas Mahajan, Delhi High Court
Verbatim Copying Of Headnotes: Delhi High Court Grants Interim Injunction To Taxmann Against Commercial Law Publishers
|The Court found that the defendants copied plaintiff’s distinctive manner of distilling and presenting the legal proposition and the operative aspect of the judgment.
The Delhi High Court has found, prima facie, that the defendants in a copyright suit by Taxmann Allied Services did not merely refer to or independently derive a legal proposition from an underlying judgment, but verbatim copied the plaintiff’s copyright-protected headnotes. The Court granted an ex parte ad interim injunction restraining Commercial Law Publishers (India) Pvt. Ltd. and others from dealing with eight impugned publications, or any other publication containing the plaintiff’s headnotes or a substantial reproduction of them.
The Court held that the copying extended to the plaintiff’s distinctive manner of identifying, distilling and presenting the relevant legal proposition and the operative aspect of the judgment. It was satisfied that the plaintiff had made out a prima facie case, that irreparable loss would follow without an injunction, and that the balance of convenience favoured the plaintiff. It also exempted the plaintiff from pre-institution mediation under Section 12-A of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015.
A Single Bench of Justice Vikas Mahajan observed, “…this Court find merit in the submission of Mr. Deepak that the defendants have not merely referred to, or independently derived a legal proposition from the underlying judgment, but have verbatim copied the plaintiff’s copyright-protected original headnote, including the plaintiff’s distinctive manner of identifying, distilling and presenting the relevant legal proposition and the operative aspect of the judgment”.
“…I am of the view that the plaintiff has made out a prima facie case for the grant of an ex parte ad interim injunction, till the next date of hearing. I am satisfied that the plaintiff shall suffer an irreparable loss in case no injunction is granted. The balance of convenience also lies in favour of the plaintiff, and against the defendants”, the Bench said further.
Senior Advocate J. Sai Deepak appeared for the plaintiff while none appeared for the defendants.
The plaintiff filed the suit for a permanent injunction restraining the defendants from publishing or substantially reproducing its headnotes. It said that its research platform, “Taxmann Research”, carries case-laws accompanied by original headnotes drafted by an in-house team of over 200 professionals, and that its end-user licence agreement bars reproduction of its content without written permission. Defendant No. 1 is a publisher of law books. Defendants 4 to 6 are authors of the impugned books.
According to the plaintiff, its editorial team found, during routine market monitoring, that eight publications of the first defendant reproduced its headnotes verbatim, including in cases where Taxmann was named as the source below the headnote. It identified, among others, 55 headnotes in one book, 85 in another and 280 in a third. A legal notice dated May 22, 2026 and a reminder dated June 12, 2026 drew no reply.
It was argued that preparing a headnote requires reading the judgment, identifying the legal point and re-expressing it in a distinctive style, so that the headnote is an original literary work under Sections 2(o) and 13(1)(a) of the Copyright Act, 1957.
The Court examined the plaint, the documents containing marked extracts of the eight books and the corresponding headnotes from the plaintiff’s website, and the impugned publications and printouts produced during the hearing. It found merit in the submission that the defendants had verbatim copied the headnotes.
Under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 of the CPC, the Court restrained the defendants, their directors, partners, proprietors, officers, agents, distributors and retailers from printing, publishing, reproducing, distributing, selling, advertising or dealing in the eight books listed in the order, or any other publication containing the plaintiff’s headnotes or any substantial reproduction. It issued notice, allowed four weeks to reply, and required compliance with Order XXXIX Rule 3 within two weeks. The plaintiff did not press its application for a Local Commissioner. The matter is listed before the Joint Registrar on January 13, 2027 and before the Court on March 2, 2027.
Cause Title: Taxmann Allied Services Pvt. Ltd. v. Commercial Law Publishers (India) Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. (CS(COMM) 1133/2026)
Appearances:
Plaintiff: Senior Advocate J. Sai Deepak with Advocates Saurabh Kansal, Pallavi S. Kansal, Raghav Vij, Suraj Kumar Jha and Pratham Malik.
Defendants: none recorded for the Defendants.