
Anganwadi Centre Is Recognised Educational Institution For 1,000-Feet Liquor-Shop Restriction: Calcutta High Court
|The Court dismissed the liquor-shop operator’s appeal but permitted him to approach the authority if he maintained that the proposed site was situated beyond 1,000 feet from the Anganwadi Centre.
The Calcutta High Court has held that an Anganwadi Centre is recognised under the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009, and falls within the category of a school for the purpose of applying Rule 8 of the West Bengal Excise (New Sites and Grant of Licence) Rules, 2003.
The High Court consequently upheld the rejection of a liquor-shop operator’s request to shift his shop to a site within 1,000 feet of an Anganwadi Centre.
The Court was hearing an intra-court appeal against a Single Judge’s order dismissing the operator’s writ petition. The petition challenged the excise authority’s refusal to permit the shop’s relocation, arguing that the proposed premises were within 1,000 feet of an Anganwadi Centre, which the authority treated as a recognised educational institution under Rule 8 of the 2003 Rules.
A Division Bench of Justice Shampa Sarkar and Justice Partha Sarathi Chatterjee observed: “The Anganwadi Centre imparts elementary education and is established under the integrated child development scheme (ICDS) under the Ministry of Women and Child Development and Social Welfare. Section 2(1) of the National Food Security Act, 2013 defines an Anganwadi Centre to mean a child care and development centre set up under the ICDS Scheme of the Central Government to render services under the said Act.”
Advocate Tapash Kumar Bhattacharya appeared for the appellant, while Additional Government Pleader Susmita Saha Dutta appeared for the State.
Background
The appellant operated a foreign-liquor shop from rented premises. Intending to run the business from his own land, he applied to the competent authority for permission to shift the shop. The authority rejected the request because the proposed site was found to be within 1,000 feet of an Anganwadi Centre.
The operator challenged that decision in a writ petition. He contended that an Anganwadi Centre was not a recognised educational institution within the meaning of Rule 8(1) of the 2003 Rules because it was not governed by the statutory framework of the School Education Department. He also asserted that the proposed site was, in fact, situated more than 1,000 feet from the centre.
The State maintained that an Anganwadi Centre was a recognised educational institution under Rule 8. It relied on a notification issued by the West Bengal Excise Department clarifying that Anganwadi Centres could not be excluded from the meaning of an educational institution under the provision.
The Single Judge rejected the operator’s contention. Relying on the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009, and the West Bengal Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Rules, 2012, the Single Judge held that Anganwadi Centres had been recognised alongside schools and pre-schools and imparted education to children between three and six years of age.
Court’s Observations
Anganwadi Centres Provide Care And Elementary Education
The Division Bench found no infirmity or perversity in the Single Judge’s conclusion. It noted that Section 2(1) of the National Food Security Act, 2013, defined an Anganwadi Centre as a child-care and development centre established under the Central Government’s Integrated Child Development Services Scheme to provide services under the Act.
The Court further observed that States had established Anganwadi Centres to provide care and elementary education to children between three and six years of age. It stated: “Under the said provision, states have also set up Anganwadi Centres which provide care and elementary education for children between the ages of 3 to 6 years.”
The Bench also referred to Section 11 of the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009. The provision enables the appropriate Government to make arrangements for free pre-school education to prepare children above three years of age for elementary education and provide early childhood care and education until they complete six years.
State RTE Rules Recognise Education Through Anganwadi Centres
The Court noted that the West Bengal School Education Department had framed the 2012 Rules and recognised pre-school and elementary education through Anganwadi Centres. Rule 5 requires local authorities to maintain records concerning children from birth until they reach 14 years of age and use those records to monitor admission, attendance and completion of elementary education.
The Bench particularly relied on Rule 5(5)(iv), which requires the register to contain the name of the school, pre-school, Anganwadi Centre or Alternative Innovative Education Centre where a child receives elementary education up to the age of six years.
It observed: “Under Rule 5(5)(iv), the name of the pre-school or the Anganwadi Centre or the Alternative Innovative Education Centre which the child availed of for elementary education up to the age of 6 years was also an important information.”
The Court held that this statutory framework recognised the educational role performed by Anganwadi Centres, even though they functioned under the Department of Women and Child Development and Social Welfare rather than the School Education Department.
Anganwadi Centre Falls Within ‘School’ For Excise Restriction
Rejecting the operator’s argument, the Court held that Anganwadi Centres were educational institutions recognised by law and therefore fell within the category of a school for implementing Rule 8 of the 2003 Rules.
The Bench stated: “The fact that they are educational institutions, recognized by law is not in doubt. Under such circumstances they also fall under the category of a school for the purpose of implementation of Rule 8 of the 2003 Rules of 2003.”
The Court accordingly upheld the Single Judge’s order and rejected the challenge to the authority’s treatment of the Anganwadi Centre as a recognised educational institution.
Conclusion
The Division Bench dismissed the appeal and affirmed that Anganwadi Centres are recognised educational institutions falling within the category of a school for applying Rule 8 of the West Bengal Excise (New Sites and Grant of Licence) Rules, 2003. It made no order as to costs in the appeal.
The Court permitted the appellant to approach the competent authority if he claimed that the proposed liquor-shop site was beyond 1,000 feet from the Anganwadi Centre. It directed the authority to consider such a request in accordance with law after giving him due notice.
The Court separately condoned the delay in filing the appeal, subject to the appellant paying ₹5,000 to the West Bengal State Legal Services Authority for transmission to the Juvenile Justice Committee’s funds within three weeks.
Cause Title: Aloke Kuma Dey v. State of West Bengal and Others
Appearances
Appellant: Tapash Kumar Bhattacharya, Sandip Ghosh and Partha Sarkar, Advocates
State: Susmita Saha Dutta, Additional Government Pleader; Madhurima Saha, Advocate