The Supreme Court issued notice to the Union of India for a limited purpose on a petition by a 20-year-old law student who sought safeguards against the adverse health consequences of consanguineous marriages.

The Bench made it clear that it would not direct the Centre to legislate. It said it would only “sensitize” the Union to consider the desirability of suitable legislation or, alternatively, to ensure wide publicity about the negative impacts of such marriages.

The Bench of Chief Justice Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana ordered, "Issue notice for the limited purpose to impress upon the Union of India (i) to consider the desirability of bringing suitable legislation or (ii) to ensure wide publicity through different mechanisms, including a proper curriculum in schools and colleges to instill scientific temper (about) the negative impacts of consanguineous marriages."


At the outset, the Bench said the matter fell within the domain of the legislature. The Court remarked, “We need to relegate you to the legislative route.”

Counsel for the petitioner clarified that the petitioner was not seeking directions for legislative action. Counsel submitted, “What I am suggesting is not that there should be directions towards legislative action, but just a direction that whatever the statutory framework is, certain safeguards be provided because it is increasing.”

Counsel told the Court that, according to the data, the prevalence of such marriages was “as high as 28%” in the southern states.

The Bench referred to the Court’s earlier rulings involving HIV-positive persons and marriage. It observed that the Court had held marriage to be a matter of personal choice.

“A person wishing to marry an HIV-positive person—it is his personal choice or her personal choice. Courts cannot regulate it by putting a mandate,” the Bench said.

It added that the requirement was only that the decision be informed, and if it was not, “the law itself takes care that the marriage is void.” 

On the petitioner’s broader plea that consanguineous marriage as a custom be revisited through social reform legislation, the Bench said this also “falls exclusively under the constitutional domain of the legislature,” and added, “We wouldn’t want to tread into that much.”

Counsel argued that the issue also raised questions of intergenerational equity. The Bench observed that such marriages mostly took place in rural areas, where families married cousins without knowing the consequences, while people in urban areas were “at least aware to some extent.” Counsel responded that the trend was visible in urban areas as well.

The Bench then indicated the limited scope of the notice. “We are issuing a notice for the limited purpose of, one, impressing upon the Union to bring suitable legislation. We will not direct it; we will only sensitize them,” the Bench said.

Counsel suggested that Anganwadis and Panchayats could be involved in this effort.

Counsel further submitted that spreading such awareness formed part of the fundamental duty to develop a scientific temper. Agreeing, the Bench referred to the duties under Article 51A of the Constitution, “probably clause (h), to develop scientific temperament.”

Counsel informed the Court that the petitioner suffered from immunity-related issues and had a 40% impairment in her vision, but was nonetheless pursuing a law degree. 

Accordingly, the Court issued notice for the limited purpose of impressing upon the Union of India.

Cause Title: X v. Union of India [Diary No. 23903/2026]

Tags: