The Supreme Court has held that physical exercise and fitness equipment such as cross elliptical trainers, treadmills, rowers, exercise bikes, and strength equipment can be classified as sports goods. It held that such equipment is entitled to the exemption under the notification issued under the U.P. Value Added Tax Act, 2008, and that the Revenue could not levy tax on it at 12.5% by treating it as unclassified goods.

The Court dismissed the appeals filed by the State of Uttar Pradesh against a judgment of the High Court, which had set aside the tax demand raised against the dealers.

The Bench of Justice S.V.N. Bhatti and Justice Shree Chandrashekhar observed, “We have to juxtapose the exemption in the notification dated 09.04.2008 with Commodity Code No. 60, which deals with sports goods, games and toys. A simple juxtaposition of both the entries would make it clear that the equipment being dealt with by the dealers can be classified as sports goods. The impugned order is correct and has applied the correct provision of law and the exemption entry.”

Advocate-on-Record Bhakti Vardhan Singh appeared for the Appellants, while Advocate Charanya Lakshmikumaran appeared for the Respondents.

The writ petitioners are private limited companies primarily engaged in the sale of physical exercise and fitness equipment, and are registered dealers under the U.P. Value Added Tax Act, 2008. The Revenue called upon them to pay tax at 12.5% on the equipment for the period from April to July 2008. The dealers challenged the assessment orders before the High Court by way of writs of certiorari.

The dealers claimed that the equipment falls under Commodity Code Entry No. 60, framed under Section 70 of the Act, which covers “Sports Goods, Games and Toys”. They further claimed that it falls within the exemption notification, which covers “Sports Goods excluding Apparels, and sports Footwear”. They argued that levying tax on exempted goods is impermissible, and that levying tax at 12.5% by treating the equipment as unclassified goods is illegal.

The Revenue’s case was that the notification employs broad expressions, and that a subsequent notification would make clear that the Revenue did not treat the dealers’ equipment as sports goods.

The High Court held that there was no good or valid reason to exclude the equipment from the meaning of sports goods, and set aside the impugned notice.

The State argued that the High Court ought to have given meaning to the expression “sports goods” in the exemption notification. On that understanding, it said, the dealers’ equipment could not be treated as sports goods, and the assessments were therefore validly issued.

The dealers contended that the commodity entry is general but includes their equipment. They argued that once the Revenue had exercised its power under Section 70 and prepared the commodity code, denying the benefit of the exemption was illegal, and that the High Court’s reasoning, though brief, was tenable.

The Court compared Entry No. 60 of the commodity codes, which includes sports goods, games and toys, with Entry No. 51 in Schedule-I as amended through the exemption notification. It concluded that the exemption clearly deals with sports goods and that the equipment dealt with by the dealers can be classified as sports goods.

Finding no reason to interfere with the High Court’s judgment, the Court dismissed the civil appeals.

Cause Title: State of U.P. & Ors. v. Grand Slam Fitness (P) Ltd. [Civil Appeal No. 291/2011]

Appearances:

Appellants: AOR Bhakti Vardhan Singh

Respondents: Sr. Adv. Pragyan Pradip Sharma, AOR P. V. Yogeswaran, AOR Charanya Lakshmikumaran, Adv. Piyuesh Tiwari, Adv. Ananya Mahajan, Adv. V Lakshmikumaran, Adv. Neha Choudhary, Adv. Medha Sinha, Adv. Nitum Jain, Adv. Swastik Mishra, Adv. Yashovardhan Singh, Adv. Adithya Nair, Adv. L Badri Narayanan, Adv. Ananya Gupta

Click here to read/download the Order

Tags: