The Supreme Court has held that an employee cannot be held responsible merely by reason of his relationship with persons alleged to have engaged in misconduct. Allowing the appeal of a Central Industrial Security Force (CRPF) constable, the Court found no evidence connecting the alleged threats by his relatives, or the circulation of a video of his wife, to him. It set aside his removal from service as shockingly disproportionate.

The Court explained that disciplinary liability must be founded upon misconduct attributable to the employee and established in the inquiry. It also held that previous misconduct for which an employee has already been punished cannot, by itself, be treated as a fresh instance of misconduct. Past minor penalties may be considered while determining the penalty for a subsequent misconduct which has independently been established, but cannot be used to supply the deficiency in proof of the present charges.

A Division Bench of Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice N. Kotiswar Singh observed, “The mere fact that the video concerned the Appellant’s wife, or that certain persons claiming to be his relatives contacted the departmental authorities, would not, in the absence of evidence connecting their conduct to the Appellant, be sufficient to sustain the charge against him. Disciplinary liability must be founded upon misconduct attributable to the employee and established in the inquiry. The Appellant cannot be held responsible merely by reason of his relationship with the persons alleged to have engaged in such conduct. We are, therefore, unable to sustain the finding that the Appellant was responsible for the circulation of the video or the alleged threats made by his relatives”.

Senior Advocate Rakesh Kumar Khanna appeared for the appellant and Brijender Chahar, A.S.G. appeared for the respondent.

“…The previous misconduct for which an employee has already been subjected to disciplinary action cannot, by itself, be treated as a fresh instance of misconduct for the purpose of imposing another penalty. The past service record may, where relevant and in accordance with the applicable rules, be considered while determining the penalty for a subsequent misconduct which has independently been established. It cannot, however, be used to supply the deficiency in proof of the charges in the present proceedings. In the present case, the reference to previous minor penalties does not establish any independent misconduct forming part of the present proceedings, nor can it be used to strengthen charges which have otherwise not been proved”, it noted further.

The appellant joined the CISF as a Constable (General Duty) in 2012. In late 2017, his wife suffered a miscarriage and underwent major surgery. He was granted leave until December 3, 2017 and rejoined on that date, then sought twelve more days of leave.

On December 6, 2017, he tendered a resignation through the grievance portal, citing acute mental stress. It was closed, and he was granted twelve days of leave the same day.

On January 18, 2018, the day he joined a new unit, he was served with a charge memorandum on three charges. The first alleged non-appearance before the Commandant and a conditional resignation to pressurise the administration. The second alleged intimidation of officials through relatives and circulation of a video of his wife. The third relied on five earlier minor penalties.

The inquiry officer held all three charges proved and the disciplinary authority ordered removal on May 1, 2018. The appeal and revision were dismissed. The Delhi High Court dismissed his writ petition on February 14, 2024, holding that he was a “habitual offender” and that “a blot is a blot”. It declined review on July 12, 2024.

The Court applied the limits of judicial review in disciplinary matters but noted that interference is warranted where the penalty shocks the conscience. On the first charge, it found no specific written direction or contemporaneous material showing the direction was communicated, and held that the circumstances of the resignation required due examination. On the second, it noted that the video was received from a different number and was recorded at the hospital while the appellant was at the Unit, and found no evidence connecting the conduct to him. On the third, it held that earlier penalties cannot strengthen charges that are otherwise unproved.

The Court also noted procedural irregularities, including Hindi translations supplied only after the prosecution evidence closed and the denial of a defence assistant despite Rule 36(8)(a) of the CISF Rules, 2001. It held that these reinforced the conclusion that the appellant lacked an effective opportunity to defend himself.

The Court set aside the High Court’s orders and quashed the removal. Declining to remit the matter, it directed reinstatement forthwith with consequential benefits and 50% of back wages from the date of removal.

Cause Title: Sumit Kumar v. Union of India & Ors. (Neutral Citation: 2026 INSC 1221)

Appearances:

Appellant: Rakesh Kumar Khanna, Sr. Adv., Amita Singh Kalkal, AOR, Aditi Gupta, Aditya P Khanna, Arushi Jindal, Devinder N. Grover, Vijay Lakshmi Grover, Govind Kashyap, Anchal Aggarwal, Advocates.

Respondents: Brijender Chahar, A.S.G., Pooja Chahar, Anmol Chandan, Nasadiya Singh, Rajan Kumar Chourasia, Adv. Mr. Amrish Kumar- 2986, AOR Dr. Arun Kumar Yadav, Arvind Kumar Sharma-AOR, Adv.

Click here to read/download the Judgment


Tags: