Cauvery Water Release Monitoring Entrusted To CWMA & CWRC: Supreme Court Dismisses Applications By State Of Tamil Nadu & DMK
The Court held that disputed shortfall assessments must be left to the designated expert bodies. The Court separately rejected the DMK’s application, holding that a non-party to the original Tribunal proceedings could not enlarge the scope of the Cauvery award.
The Supreme Court has dismissed two applications filed by Tamil Nadu seeking directions concerning Cauvery water releases by Karnataka, holding that continuing monitoring and enforcement of the release schedule were functions entrusted to the Cauvery Water Management Authority and the Cauvery Water Regulation Committee.
It also dismissed the DMK’s application in the disposed appeal.
The Court was hearing Tamil Nadu’s applications seeking implementation of two CWMA release decisions, release of alleged shortfalls and continued monitoring of flows, along with an application filed by the DMK in the disposed Cauvery water-sharing appeal.
A Bench comprising Justice Vikram Nath and Justice Aparesh Kumar Singh observed: “By instituting the present application, the applicant-State seeks, in effect, to draw this Court into the continuing process of monitoring and enforcing the release schedule, a function entrusted to the CWMA and the CWRC under the Scheme framed pursuant to this Court’s judgment dated 16th February, 2018. By the said judgment, this Court modified the Tribunal’s award dated 5th February, 2007, and specifically directed the Union of India to frame a Scheme to facilitate compliance with and implementation of the judgment. The present application would, therefore, require this Court to assume, in effect, the role of the very authorities constituted to oversee implementation of the water-sharing arrangements. Such a course would be neither warranted nor appropriate, particularly when the designated expert bodies remain seized of the matter.”
Senior Advocate G. Umapathy appeared for Tamil Nadu. Senior Advocates Shyam Divan, Mohan V. Katarki and P.B. Suresh, along with Advocate General Shashi Kiran Shetty, appeared for Karnataka.
Background
The Supreme Court had earlier modified the Cauvery Water Disputes Tribunal’s award governing water sharing among Karnataka, Tamil Nadu, Kerala and Puducherry. Pursuant to its direction, the Union notified the Cauvery Water Management Scheme, which established the CWMA and the CWRC to oversee and regulate implementation of the arrangements.
Tamil Nadu’s first application sought implementation of a CWMA decision requiring Karnataka to ensure a flow of 3,500 cusecs for 15 days. It also sought immediate release of an alleged shortfall and directions requiring the CWMA to monitor reservoir flows and stipulated releases. The earlier stages of this application included the Court’s decision to hear Tamil Nadu’s request for release of its Cauvery share and its direction to Karnataka to ensure compliance with the CWMA’s release directions.
Tamil Nadu contended that a shortfall would remain even if Karnataka complied and alleged wilful non-compliance. Karnataka submitted that releases in a distress year were not inflexible and that deficits could be adjusted during the annual cycle. It acknowledged an initial delay of two days but said that the deficit was later made good and the quantity released exceeded the amount stipulated by the CWMA. The Court recorded that Tamil Nadu had acknowledged the subsequent release in its response.
Tamil Nadu later filed a second application alleging a shortfall in Cauvery water supply. It sought implementation of a later CWMA direction requiring a flow of 6,000 cusecs for 15 days and release of an alleged shortfall. Karnataka disputed the calculations and maintained that it had released water exceeding the amount stipulated.
Court’s Observations
Expert Bodies Were Already Monitoring The Release Schedule
The Court observed that the 2018 Scheme had constituted the CWMA and CWRC to secure compliance with the modified Tribunal award. It held that the first application was misconceived because the expert machinery charged with monitoring and regulating Cauvery releases was already examining the dispute.
The Bench stated: “Having considered the rival submissions, we are of the view that the present application is misconceived, particularly when the expert body entrusted with monitoring and regulating the release of Cauvery waters is already seized of the matter.”
The Court noted that the release schedule operated on an annual cycle from June to May. Karnataka had stated that the initial shortfall had been made good after adequate rainfall, and Tamil Nadu had acknowledged the later release. The Court consequently observed: “In these circumstances, the apprehension expressed by the applicant-State of Tamil Nadu that its annual allocation of water may not be met appears premature.”
Both States Participated In Periodic CWRC Reviews
The Court found it difficult to accept that Tamil Nadu’s concerns would be disregarded because both Tamil Nadu and Karnataka were represented in the CWMA and CWRC. Those bodies had been constituted to implement the Supreme Court’s final judgment.
The Bench recorded: “It is also pertinent to note that, as fairly admitted by both parties, the CWRC has been convening meetings every fifteen days to review the prevailing situation, hear the parties concerned, and issue appropriate directions in light of the circumstances obtaining at the relevant time.”
Accordingly, the Court declined to assume the role assigned to the two expert bodies and dismissed Tamil Nadu’s first application.
Disputed Shortfall Calculations Fell Within Expert Domain
While considering Tamil Nadu’s second application, the Court noted Karnataka’s submission that it had complied with the later CWMA direction and released water exceeding the stipulated quantity. The alleged shortfall and its quantification required an assessment of distress and flows across the entire Cauvery basin.
The Court held that those questions fell within the domain of the CWRC and CWMA. Having already determined the inter-State allocation and the governing principles, it declined to issue a separate direction based on disputed calculations, holding: “The matter shall, accordingly, be left to be considered by the CWRC and the CWMA in accordance with law.”
Tamil Nadu’s Grievances Had Been Considered
The Court rejected Tamil Nadu’s contention that its concerns about shortfalls were not being adequately addressed. After examining the meeting minutes, it observed: “A perusal thereof reveals that both authorities considered the submissions made by all the States, including the parties herein, and specifically addressed the grievances raised by the applicant-State of Tamil Nadu.”
The Bench also noted that, at a subsequent meeting, the CWMA had considered basin flows and concluded that no backlog remained. It recorded: “CWMA, upon noting the submissions of Member (Water Resources), has categorically held that it can be concluded that there is no backlog shortfall.” The CWMA had thereafter directed Karnataka to maintain the daily average flows stipulated by the Court, subject to monitoring by the CWRC and CWMA.
DMK Could Not Enlarge Original Adjudication
The Court held that the concerns raised by the DMK were adequately represented by Tamil Nadu. The party had not participated in the original proceedings before the Cauvery Water Disputes Tribunal.
The Bench held that the scope of the Tribunal’s award, as affirmed and modified by the Supreme Court, “ought not to be enlarged by entertaining and adjudicating upon claims or objections raised by an applicant who was not a party to the original proceedings before the Tribunal.”
It consequently declined to entertain the DMK’s application.
Conclusion
The Supreme Court dismissed both applications filed by Tamil Nadu and the application filed by the DMK. The application for impleadment was also dismissed, and all pending applications were disposed of. The disputed shortfall and future implementation of the Cauvery release schedule were left to the CWRC and CWMA in accordance with law.
Cause Title: State of Tamil Nadu v. State of Karnataka and Others (Neutral Citation: 2026 INSC 1257)
Appearances
Applicants: G. Umapathy, Senior Advocate; B. Karunakaran and Anuradha Arputham, AORs; Akhil Krishnan A., P. Wilson, Richardson Wilson, Apoorv Malhotra, Lokesh Krishna, Aditya Ojha, Aravind A., Saran Raghunandhan, Sapna Pillai, Ankit Sharma and Mridul Gupta, Advocates
Respondents: Shyam Divan, Mohan V. Katarki and P.B. Suresh, Senior Advocates; Shashi Kiran Shetty, Advocate General; Nishanth Patil, AOR; Karoshi, Mayank Jain, Sudipto Sircar and Kushvinder Vohra, Advocates