Appellate Court Can’t Interfere With Judgment Merely On Ground Of Suspicion: Supreme Court
The appeal before the Apex Court was filed against the judgment dismissing the claim for compensation and allowing the appeal filed by Jaipur Vidyut Vitran Nigam Limited (JVVNL).
Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra, Justice Shree Chandrashekhar, Supreme Court
While restoring an order granting compensation to a woman who suffered permanent disability on account of electrocution, the Supreme Court has held that the Appellate Court is not entitled to interfere with a judgment merely on the ground of suspicion without weighing the truthfulness of the witnesses.
The appeal before the Apex Court was filed by the appellant against the judgment dismissing the claim for compensation and allowing the appeal filed by the Jaipur Vidyut Vitran Nigam Limited (JVVNL).
The Division Bench of Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice Shree Chandrashekhar held, “The appellate Court can interfere with the judgment of the Court of first instance if it suffers from material irregularity, or is based on inadmissible evidence or a misreading of the evidence. But the appellate Court is not entitled to interfere with a judgment merely on the ground of suspicion without weighing truthfulness of the witnesses. If a witness is found truthful then the Court is required to separate chaff from grain and render a judgment by applying correct principles in law. This is no ground to spurn a judgment delivered by a Court of competent jurisdiction that there was a delay in lodging the claim or a complaint, or that there is some inconsistency in the evidence produced by the plaintiff. The appellate Court should not embark upon a fault-finding expedition and interfere in the matter on mere showing of some mistake in the judgment under challenge.”
AOR Abhishek Yadav represented the Appellant, while Advocate Dr. Rupesh Singh represented the Respondent.
Factual Background
The suit was instituted on behalf of the appellant claiming that she sustained injuries by electrocution on July 15, 2011 due to negligence of the respondents. The appellant was a minor at that time, and she stated that the transmission lines passing from village Phunthpura to village Harivansh ka Pura-Pathaur ka Pura had loosened over the last few days and the electric wires came close to the ground. While passing through village Harivansh ka Pura-Pathaur ka Pura, she tried to ward off the electric wires falling on her way, but it was a live wire and a major part of her body was badly burnt due to electric shocks. She was taken to Health Centres for treatment, but her condition did not improve. Her right hand was amputated, and she was rendered permanently handicapped.
According to the appellant, a Daily Diary Report was made at Basedi police station, but no action thereon was taken by the police. In the written statement, the respondents put up a defence that the appellant could not have survived, since any person coming in contact with an 11 KV electric line would die on the spot due to electric shock. The Civil Case was decreed, and the respondents were directed to pay Rs 8,70,000 as compensation to the appellant with interest. In the respondent’s appeal, the High Court interfered with the judgment, holding that the appellant’s story was unbelievable.
Reasoning
The Bench, at the outset, explained, “A civil suit should be decided on the basis of evidence produced by the parties and not by merely raising a doubt on the claim made by the plaintiff. The question whether the appellant suffered injuries by coming into contact with live electric wire was decided by the trial Court on the basis of evidence laid by the parties. The principle which governs the proceedings in the appellate Court is that the findings of fact recorded by the trial Judge should normally prevail when it comes to appreciation of evidence by the appellate Court, unless the trial Judge has missed out some vital defects in the testimony of a witness. In a full-fledged trial, the respondents had an opportunity to elicit truth and such material facts from the appellant’s witnesses which could have shattered the credibility of her witnesses.”
On a perusal of the facts of the case, the Bench noted that there was no real effort on the part of the respondents to challenge the incident except putting a suggestion to the appellant that she suffered injuries while coming into contact with the Jumper wire. The Bench further found that the respondents’ witness admitted in the Court that it was the responsibility of the respondents to maintain the transmission lines. It was also noticed that the evidence produced on behalf of the appellant to support her claim remained unshaken and intact. Her witnesses stood by her claim for compensation and supported her case on all material aspects.
According to the Bench, the High Court overlooked a fundamental rule that it is not every inconsistency or omission in the testimony of a witness which assumes materiality in a civil trial. “The High Court disbelieved the whole case on the ground that the incident appears to be suspicious. It was a grave error in law that the High Court has committed while observing that “there is something which is unbelievable”. Section 4 of the Indian Evidence Act says that the Court may either record a fact as proved if such presumption is provided by the Act, or may call for proof of it until and unless it is disapproved. There is no provision in law which authorizes the Court to disbelieve the incident without recording a finding that the witnesses were unreliable or were found lying in the Court. The High Court was required to keep in mind that whether the appellant suffered permanent disability on account of electrocution is also a question of fact ”, it stated.
Considering that the Trial Court believed the witnesses produced by the appellant and held that the appellant was entitled to compensation for the injuries suffered by her on account of negligence of the respondents, the Bench held that the High Court had no jurisdiction to interfere in the matter by nurturing a suspicion over the appellant’s case that the occurrence did not happen.
Decision
Thus, setting aside the impugned order, the Bench restored the judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court.
Cause Title: Rekha v. Jaipur Vidyut Vitran Nigam Limited & Ors. (Neutral Citation: 2026 INSC 1216)
Appearance
Appellant: AOR Abhishek Yadav, Advocates Ashutosh Kumar, Vinod Chauhan, Saurabh Yadav
Respondent: Advocates Rupesh Singh, Siddharth Yadav, Yogesh Bhati, Divyanshu Yadav, AOR Satya Veer Singh, Advocate Smriti Singh