Supreme Court Seeks Lokpal’s Response On Plea Against Delhi High Court Ruling On Pre-Notice Hearing For Public Servants
The Supreme Court today sought a response from the Lokpal of India on a plea challenging a Delhi High Court verdict which held that the anti-corruption ombudsman was not required to provide a public servant an opportunity of hearing before issuing a show-cause notice with regard to an investigation.
The Delhi High Court, on April 15, had dismissed a petition filed by public servant Chinmoyjit Sen, who had challenged a Lokpal order dated February 25 and a subsequent show-cause notice issued on February 27 in connection with a complaint.
Observing that the right to be heard arises before any final action is taken under Section 20(3) of the Lokpal and Lokayuktas Act, 2013, the High Court had held that the Lokpal was not required to provide a public servant an opportunity of hearing before issuing a show-cause notice.
Section 20(3) of the Act requires a Lokpal bench of at least three members to review preliminary inquiry reports under Section 20(2), hear the public servant, decide if a prima facie case exists and choose one or more actions.
The Lokpal probes allegations of corruption under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 against specified public servants, politicians and certain institutions.
A bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana took note of the submissions of Sen's lawyer and issued the notice to the ombudsman.
The bench, however, refused to stay the proceedings before the Lokpal against Sen and said that the matter would be taken up after a week.
The proceedings originated from a preliminary inquiry conducted by the CBI on the directions of the Lokpal.
The CBI submitted its preliminary inquiry report on January 27, following which the Lokpal examined the allegations and found certain of them against Sen to be prima facie substantiated.
The Lokpal subsequently issued a show-cause notice to the petitioner, calling upon him to respond to the two allegations and providing an opportunity of hearing under Section 20(3) of the Act.
Challenging the order and notice, Sen told the High Court that the Lokpal had passed the February 25 order without giving him an opportunity of hearing.
It was further said that the Lokpal had already formed an opinion on the allegations, rendering the subsequent show-cause notice and hearing an empty formality.
"We make it clear that the opportunity of hearing to the public servant is contemplated before any final action is taken under Section 20(3). Had the legislature intended that a hearing be granted even prior to issuance of a show-cause notice, it would have so provided. Therefore, the mere issuance of a show cause notice, after due consideration of the material on record, cannot be said to be without application of mind or in violation of principles of natural justice," the High Court had said.
It had further said the impugned order dated February 25 is only a prima facie opinion and final order for proceeding with one or more of the actions under Section 20(3) of the Act is to be passed only after hearing the petitioner.
"The mere issuance of a show-cause notice, after due consideration of the material on record, cannot be said to be without application of mind or in violation of principles of natural justice," the High Court had said.
The High Court said that Sen could raise all his grievances before the Lokpal.
With PTI Inputs