The Supreme Court has issued notice on a criminal contempt petition filed by the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) against Advocate Pravin Singhal over his alleged remarks against the Chief Justice of India in open court and in an earlier Instagram video.

The Court directed the sole respondent to remain physically present on the next date of hearing. It also permitted him to file a reply, with the SCBA to file any rejoinder thereafter.

The Bench of Justice Dipankar Datta, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V. Mohana ordered, “Having perused the papers before us, which include the consent of the Learned Attorney General under Section 15(1)(b) of the Contempt of Courts Act, we are prima facie satisfied that the motion made by the SCBA for initiation of the contempt proceedings against the Respondents deserves to be taken forward.”

Senior Advocate Pradeep Rai appeared for the Petitioner.

Rai told the Bench that the conduct in court was “deeply unrespectable” and submitted that the proceedings were “not against an individual”. He drew the Bench’s attention to the language used and stated, “he is not our member.”

He submitted that many persons claimed to be Advocates of the Supreme Court, came to the premises, made posts and left. He added that several persons posted such content on the media and that their entire income depended on it.

He further submitted that authorities felt they could not take action since they would have to approach Meta and similar platforms.

Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, who was also present in the matter, stated, “I would fully support the petitioner; the majesty of the court can’t be compromised.”

Justice Datta replied, “We would require your assistance, Mr Solicitor, on the returnable date.”

The SCBA filed the petition under Article 129 of the Constitution of India, read with Sections 2(c) and 15(1)(b) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, after obtaining the written consent of the Attorney General for India.

It sought criminal contempt proceedings against the respondent for his alleged conduct during proceedings in Court No. 1 and for an Instagram video reel published earlier.

According to the petition, the respondent sought urgent mentioning of a matter before the Bench headed by the Chief Justice, claiming that papers submitted to the Chief Justice’s office had received no response. Justice V. Mohana intervened, and the Chief Justice asked him to wait, saying, “We will see, you just wait.” The respondent allegedly refused and said, “No, I won’t wait. You can’t sit in that chair, you don’t deserve. You don’t have the integrity for that.”

The Plea, filed by Advocate-on-Record Aditya Singh, submitted, "It is further submitted that the Respondent had earlier, on or about 13.10.2026, allegedly circulated a video on Instagram wherein he made highly derogatory and scandalous allegations against the Hon’ble Chief Justice of India, repeatedly referring to His Lordship as a “thief”, “fake” and an “agent” of the Prime Minister, besides making other abusive remarks questioning His Lordship’s integrity and independence. The aforesaid acts, viewed cumulatively, disclose a prima facie case of criminal contempt, having the tendency to scandalise and lower the authority of this Hon’ble Court and undermine public confidence in the administration of justice."

It was added that the deliberate and intentional scandalous statements knowingly that it would lower the authority of this Court warrants strict action against the Respondents in accordance with law.

The petition stated that, after being removed from Court No. 1 by security personnel, the respondent continued shouting and using abusive and derogatory language against the Chief Justice within the premises of the Court. His conduct was witnessed by several Advocates, including members of the SCBA Executive Committee.

The SCBA relied on a written complaint from Advocate Meenesh Dubey, who was personally present and stated that the respondent threw papers towards the Bench during the proceedings. It stated that the respondent continuously made reckless statements against the Chief Justice even after his removal from the courtroom, which demonstrated “a persistent disregard for the dignity and authority” of the Court.

The petition further referred to a video reel the respondent allegedly published earlier on Instagram. In the transcript annexed to the petition, translated from Hindi, the respondent allegedly said, “The Chief Justice of the Supreme Court is a fake. He is an agent of Modi. He is a thief, that bastard, wasting time.”

He also allegedly said, “When the Constitution itself will not survive, where will you bring Parliament from? He is a thief, I say so openly. Take down my name.” The petition added that many other Instagram videos of the respondent contained scandalous and reckless allegations against the Chief Justice, and that the SCBA had filed an English translation of the Hindi transcript and sought exemption from filing an official translation.

The SCBA stated that it did not seek to prevent fair, bona fide and temperate criticism of judicial decisions, judicial administration or public institutions, but that the words used by the respondent went beyond fair criticism. It submitted that the proceedings were intended to protect the institution and not to vindicate the personal dignity of any individual Judge, because the judicial institution is larger than any individual occupying judicial office. It added that the reach of social media, on which the video was published, multiplied the harm to public confidence in the justice delivery system.

It referred to its own earlier contempt petition arising from the hurling of a shoe towards the then Chief Justice of India, B.R. Gavai, as reflecting the SCBA’s consistent institutional position that conduct directed against the Court cannot be ignored merely because it is directed at an individual Judge.

"It is respectfully submitted that the deliberate, reckless and malicious statements made by the Respondent/Alleged Contemnor, to incite public disrespect towards the Hon’ble Chief Justice of India and to undermine the authority and dignity of this Hon’ble Court, strike at the very foundation of public confidence in the administration of justice. Such conduct, it is submitted, squarely attracts the provisions of Section 2(c) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, as it tends to scandalise and lower the authority of this Hon’ble Court and interfere with the due administration of justice", the plea averred.

It stated that the petition was within the period of one year prescribed by Section 20 of the Act and that no other contempt petition had been filed on the same cause of action.

The plea prayed, "initiate proceedings for criminal contempt against the Respondent under Article 129 of the Constitution of India read with Sections 2(c), 12 and 15 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, for making and publishing false and scandalous imputations against the Hon’ble Chief Justice of India/ Hon’ble Supreme Court of India; issue notice to Respondent to show cause why they should not be punished for criminal contempt of this Hon’ble Court, and direct their personal presence"

It also prayed that Meta Platforms Inc. (Instagram) be directed to preserve the posts, videos, account records and logs relating to the publications, and that the respondent and platforms including Instagram, Facebook and YouTube be directed to remove the statements complained of and any similar publications.

It further sought to restrain the respondent from making similar imputations against the Chief Justice and the Judges during the pendency of the proceedings.

Accordingly, the Court issued notice on the petition and listed the matter for further hearing on January 20, 2027.

Cause Title: Supreme Court Bar Association v. Pravin Singhal [CONMT.PET.(Crl.) No.3/2026]

Tags: