While upholding the sale of a certain portion of company-owned land, the Supreme Court has held that an unrelated thirdparty, cannot be made liable for proving the holding of the meeting and passing of a resolution in the said meeting. The Apex Court also reaffirmed that a third-party purchaser can only act bona fide when one of the two directors, being a 50% shareholder produces a resolution of the Board of Directors.

The appeal before the Apex Court was filed by the company M/s Elaine Info Solutions Pvt. Ltd., challenging the judgment of the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal upholding the order of the NCLT declaring the Board Resolution of the Board Meeting and the registration of documents for certain land as null and void.

The Division Bench of Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva held, “The only two shareholders of the Company are the mother and the son. Appellant, being an unrelated third party would have no knowledge of the meeting, therefore, the finding of the NCLT that Appellant has failed to prove that mother had notice or participated in any alleged meeting is erroneous for the reason that it was for the shareholders and the directors of the Company to prove the said meeting. Appellant being an unrelated thirdparty, cannot be made liable for proving the holding of the meeting and passing of a resolution in the said meeting. A third-party purchaser can only act bona fidely when one of the two directors, being a 50% shareholder produces a resolution of the Board of Directors.”

Senior Advocate S. Niranjan Reddy represented the Appellant while Senior Advocate Devashish Bharuka represented the Respondent.

Factual Background

The proceedings emanated from a Petition filed by the mother under Section 241 of the Companies Act, whereby she had challenged the sale of the subject land owned by the Company, contending that though she was the Director of the Company, the son was taking care of the day-to-day affairs of the Company. It was contended by the mother that the Company had purchased 18 Acres 18 Guntas of land vide sale deed, and she was surprised to learn that the son, in collusion with the Appellant, had transferred a part of the said land by way of a sale deed. It was contended that the shares of the Company were owned by her and her son in the ratio of 50% each, and both of them were Directors of the Company.

The son, in his counter-affidavit filed before the NCLT contended that one Naga Satish, Director of the Appellant, was a family friend and both Naga Satish and his mother were in the business of moneylending. It was further his case that Naga Satish had paid to the Company to purchase lands on different dates and the total money paid by Naga Satish and his mother was Rs. 1,65,00,000. It was further submitted in the counter-affidavit by the son, that Naga Satish had filed a case against the son on the basis of an agreement to sell for purchase of agricultural land admeasuring 29 Acres 30.08 Guntas, owned by the son. The agreement reflected a balance consideration of Rs. 7,91,00,000 towards the purchase of the said land.

The NCLT held that as there were only two shareholders and two directors, i.e., the mother and the son, the question of conducting any valid Board Meeting in the Company did not arise without participation of either the mother or the son. It further held that, as no Board Meeting had been conducted, the son did not have the authority to transact the sale of the property and, thus, the Court held that the sale deed was void ab initio and non est in the eyes of law. The NCLAT disposed of all the appeals, holding that the Appellant had failed to adduce any evidence relating to the presence of the mother at the Board Meeting.

Reasoning

The Bench noted that the Appellant is a third party to the affairs of the Company and the Board Resolution was alleged to have been passed in a meeting held on the same date. Though the sale deed referred to a resolution of the Board Meeting dated August 1, 2015, the Bench held that the Appellant could not be attributed with any knowledge of the same, as the holding of the meeting and passing of the said resolution would be within the personal knowledge of the Directors/shareholders of the Company.

Considering that the only two shareholders of the Company were the mother and the son, the Bench noted that the Appellant, being an unrelated third party, would have no knowledge of the meeting; therefore, the finding of the NCLT that the Appellant had failed to prove that the mother had notice or participated in any alleged meeting was erroneous. As per the Bench, it was for the shareholders and the directors of the Company to prove the said meeting. “Appellant being an unrelated thirdparty, cannot be made liable for proving the holding of the meeting and passing of a resolution in the said meeting. A third-party purchaser can only act bona fidely when one of the two directors, being a 50% shareholder produces a resolution of the Board of Directors”, it added.

Holding that the Doctrine of Indoor Management would come to apply in the case, the Bench noted that Both NCLT and NCLAT had primarily acted by holding that the resolution of the Board of Directors had not been passed and the sale deed executed based thereon was invalid. “Appellant, being an unrelated third-party would have no knowledge of the indoor affairs of the Company”, it stated.

The Bench further observed that the mother, being the signatory to the books of accounts, would have been aware of the entries reflecting the sale of the account subject and the appropriation and utilization of the sale consideration for the affairs of the Company. As per the Bench, she couldnot be permitted to deny the said transaction or claim the ignorance to such a transaction. The Bench further held that a challenge to the Board Resolution dated August 1, 2015 and the sale deed dated September 4, 2015 had been made to counter the claim of Naga Satish in the suit for specific performance filed by him.

According to the Bench, the NCLT had erred in declaring the Board Resolution of the Board Meeting and the Sale Deed as null and void and had further erred in directing the Sub-Registrar to cancel the registered document and directing restoration of the title of the property in the name of M/s J & A Avenues India Private Limited.

Decision

The Bench set aside the Order of the NCLT and the order of the NCLAT. The petition filed by the mother (Vishnumolaka Govardhanmma) under Section 241 of the Companies Act, was also dismissed.

Cause Title: Elaine Info Solutions Pvt. Ltd. v. M/S. J & A Avenues India Private Limited and Ors (Neutral Citation: 2026 INSC 1228)

Appearance

Appellant: Senior Advocates S. Niranjan Reddy, Sridhar Potaraju, AOR Swapnil Gupta, Advocates Ujjal Banerjee, Shivambika Sinha, Nimita Kaul, Tarun Mishra, Sridhar Potaraju, Byrapaneni Suyodhan, AOR Tatini Basu, Advocates Obulapuram Keerthi, Kumar Shashank, Chamundeswari Pemmasaini

Respondent: Senior Advocate Devashish Bharuka, Advocates Advika Devanshi, Dr. Priyanka, AOR Kumar Mihir, AOR Deeptakirti Verma, Advocate Vipin Nair, AOR Ujjal Banerjee, Advocates Byrapaneni Suyodhan, AOR Tatini Basu, Advocates Obulapuram Keerthi, Kumar Shashank

Click here to read/download Judgment




Tags: