Chief Justice A. Muhamed Mustaque, Sikkim High Court

The Sikkim High Court has upheld the termination of a Protocol-cum-Liaison Officer appointed by the High Court’s own administration, observing that the circumstances of the appointment raise serious concerns of impropriety. Calling it “not a mere blemish on the institutional fabric, but a cancerous growth”, the Bench held that the petitioner entered the institution through the “backdoor” and must leave through the “front door of law”.

The Court held that the selection and appointment violated the notified vacancy, Rule 6 of the High Court of Sikkim (Recruitment, Conditions of Service and Conduct) Rules, 1998, which mandates a competitive examination, and the requirement of State Government sanction for posts created under Article 229 of the Constitution of India. It noted that the case is “not an isolated case” and that the credibility of the institution is at stake.

A Single Bench of Chief Justice A. Muhamed Mustaque observed, “…This is not a mere blemish on the institutional fabric, but a cancerous growth capable of eating away the very soul of this great institution. If not removed with firmness and resolve, its consequences may extend far beyond the immediate beneficiaries and corrode the institution from within”.

“…She must, therefore, march out of this institution through the front door of law, as she entered into this institution through the backdoor, as revealed from the findings recorded herein. She cannot claim the legitimacy of a lawful process to remain in the institution. This case, however, must not be viewed merely as the resolution of an individual dispute. It must, at the very least, serve as the starting point for a process of institutional introspection and renewal. The faith of the people in the integrity of this institution must remain unshaken…”, it noted further.

Advocate Abhinav Kant Jha appeared for the petitioner while Senior Advocate N. Rai appeared for respondent nos. 1 and 2, Zangpo Sherpa, Additional Advocate General appeared for respondent nos. 3 and 4.

“The Chief Justice has no power to dispense with the requirement of a competitive examination, even by invoking the residuary powers under Rule 14 or Rule 19 of the 1998 Rules. The requirement under the 1998 Rules to conduct a competitive examination is mandatory and cannot be waived in the case of appointments to Group ‘C’ posts and above. This demonstrates that the selection solely through a viva-voce clearly lacks the requisite transparency and give rise to serious concerns regarding nepotism.”, the Bench had also noted.

On November 3, 2025, the High Court invited applications for one vacant post of Protocol-cum-Liaison Officer (Group ‘C’, Level-8), with selection by interview on November 19, 2025. The petitioner, Smriti Chettri, was initially rejected for lack of experience documents.

She submitted them on November 18, 2025, after the November 15 cut-off, and was allowed to appear. A clarification notice of December 1, 2025 was issued, in the Court’s words “apparently in response to the public outrage”.

After the interview, the then Chief Justice converted two Lower Division Assistant-cum-Typist posts into Protocol-cum-Liaison Officer posts, and three candidates, including the petitioner, were appointed.

The Full Court decided on April 21, 2026 to terminate her service as an appointment over and above the single notified vacancy, after a show-cause notice. She challenged the termination order of July 16, 2026 under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The respondents argued the appointment was void ab initio, in violation of Rule 6 of the 1998 Rules and without State sanction under Article 229.

The Court held that accepting her documents after the cut-off breached the “level playing field”, and that appointments beyond the notified vacancy are illegal, relying on Rakhi Ray and Others v. High Court of Delhi and Others (2010).

“The plea of innocence advanced by the Learned Counsel for the Petitioner, for sympathetic consideration cannot prevail at the cost of the Rule of Law. The Petitioner's role in the process leading to her appointment cannot be overlooked, particularly when the circumstances disclose that she was a beneficiary of undue favouritism. Sympathy cannot legitimize illegality, nor can any right flow from a wrong. Those who make calculated choices must accept its consequences. The appointment in question is not merely tainted by procedural irregularities, the circumstances surrounding them raise serious concerns of impropriety that cannot be brushed aside as isolated aberrations…”, the Bench said.

Accordingly, it dismissed the writ petition and gave the petitioner liberty to invoke her lien in her previous State Government employment, her probation not having been declared.

Cause Title: Smriti Chettri v. High Court of Sikkim & Ors. (WP(C) No. 47 of 2026)

Appearances:

Petitioner: Abhinav Kant Jha, Preeti Basnett and Angkita Giri, Advocates.

Respondents: N. Rai, Senior Advocate, Kazi Sangay Thupden, Prerana Rai, Srijana Bagdas, Sogyal Topden Norbu and Pritika Pradhan, Advocates, for Respondent Nos. 1 and 2; Zangpo Sherpa, Additional Advocate General, with Thinlay Dorjee Bhutia, Government Advocate, for Respondent Nos. 3 and 4.

Click here to read/download the Judgment



Tags: