Punjab & Haryana HC Upholds Decision To Permit Couple Who Crossed Age Limit To Undergo ART Treatment Based On Undertaking
The Punjab & Haryana High Court was considering a Letters Patent Appeal challenging an order granting permission to a couple to undergo the In Vitro Fertilisation (IVF) procedure.
Justice Suvir Sehgal, Justice Rajesh Gaur, Punjab & Haryana High Court
While observing that a blanket age-based restriction imposed without a rational and proportional justification may unduly infringe upon a woman's decisional autonomy, bodily integrity and dignity, the Punjab and Haryana High Court has upheld a decision granting permission to a couple where the woman is aged above 50 to undergo the In Vitro Fertilisation (IVF) procedure.
Division Bench held that the Union of India was estopped from challenging the decision of the Single Bench since the same was based on the submission of the Counsel for the Union of India.
The High Court was considering a Letters Patent Appeal, filed under Clause X of the Letters Patent against the impugned order passed by the Single Bench whereby the writ petition filed by the contesting respondents, seeking a direction to the appellants to permit the first respondent to avail herself of Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART) services, including In Vitro Fertilization (IVF), was allowed by the Single Bench.
The Bench comprising Justice Suvir Sehgal and Justice Rajesh Gaur held, “A conjoint reading of the aforesaid provisions makes it abundantly clear that the legislature has consciously prescribed age restrictions separately for an individual man and an individual woman. The statutory scheme does not contemplate as prescribed any cumulative and combined age restriction in respect of commissioning couple. Thus, the age criteria under the Act is individual specific and cannot be construed as imposing any additional age restriction based on the combined age of the couple, particularly when no such restriction finds express statutory recognition.”
“Such a blanket age-based restriction, if imposed without a rational and proportional justification, may unduly infringe upon a woman's decisional autonomy, bodily integrity and dignity, which constitute integral facets of Article 21 of the Constitution”, it added.
Senior Panel Counsel Vipul Aggarwal represented the Union of India.
Factual Background
The respondents, a married couple, were desirous of conceiving a child through IVF, particularly in view of the fact that, during their previous pregnancy, which was also facilitated through IVF, the wife suffered the loss of one foetus. However, the couple was informed that they were ineligible to undergo the IVF procedure on account of the statutory age restrictions prescribed under Section 21(g)(i) of the Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Act, 2021 (ART Act). Section 21(g)(i) stipulates that an ART clinic may provide ART services to a woman who is above the age of 21 years and below the age of 50 years. The couple was informed that they could no longer avail themselves of these services under the said Act as the wife had crossed the prescribed upper age limit.
The respondents approached the High Court after such rejection with a petition which was allowed. Aggrieved thereby, the appellants approached the Division Bench by way of the Letters Patent Appeal.
Reasoning
The Bench, at the outset, explained that the ART Act, 2021 defines a commissioning couple as an infertile married couple, who approach an ART clinic or ART bank for availing authorised services but the Act does not prescribe any combined age limit for a commissioning couple.
Reference was made to Section 21(g) of the Act, which stipulates that ART services should be provided to a woman only if she is above the age of 21 years or below the age of 50 years and to a man only if he is above the age of 21 years and below the age of 55 years. The Bench clarified that the statutory scheme does not contemplate, as prescribed, any cumulative and combined age restriction in respect of commissioning couples. The Bench was of the view that any interpretation seeking to impose a combined age limit upon a commissioning couple would amount to importing a condition into the statute which the legislature has consciously not prescribed.
The Bench further held that the prescription of an upper age limit under the ART Act, 2021, without adequate consideration of an individual woman’s health, medical fitness and informed consent, raises substantial constitutional concerns.
Thus, finding no reason to interfere with the direction issued by the Single Bench permitting the contesting respondent to proceed with the treatment, the Bench dismissed the appeal.
Cause Title: Union of India and Another v. A (Neutral Citation: 2026:PHHC:201438-DB)