The Madras High Court has held that a marriage between a Hindu and a person professing a different religion cannot be solemnised or validated merely through registration under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955. Setting aside the Family Court's decision, the Court declared the disputed registration null and void.

The Court was hearing an appeal under Section 96 of the CPC, read with Order XLI of the CPC and Section 19 of the Family Courts Act, 1984, against the dismissal of a suit seeking a declaration that a marriage registered under the Hindu Marriage Act was null and void.

A Division Bench comprising Justice C.V. Karthikeyan and Justice S. Raveekumar observed: “A plain reading of the said provision makes it clear that a marriage under the Act can be solemnized only between two Hindus. Section 8 of the Act provides for the registration of Hindu marriages and framing of the rules, primarily to facilitate proof of marriages solemnized to enable the parties to any such marriage that has taken place to enter such particulars relating to their marriage in such manner, subject to the conditions prescribed in the Hindu Marriage Register kept for that purpose. Therefore, a conjoint reading of Sections 5 and 8 of the Hindu Marriage Act makes it clear that a marriage between a Hindu and a person professing a different religion cannot be solemnized and validated by a mere registration under the said Act.”

Advocates N. Easwaran and R. Veeramani appeared for the appellant.

Background

The appellant alleged that the respondent asked him to come to the registrar's office on the representation that he would sign as a witness to her marriage with another person. He said that he later discovered that a marriage between them had instead been registered. He maintained that he was a Christian, that no ceremony had taken place and that they had never lived together as spouses.

The respondent disputed that account. She contended that the appellant had proposed marriage, that they decided to marry because their families opposed the relationship and that he arranged the registration in the presence of his friends.

The Family Court dismissed the suit. It treated the two baptism dates as contradictory, disbelieved the appellant's claim that he was a Christian before the alleged marriage and found that the alleged compulsion had not been proved.

The respondent did not appear in the appeal despite substituted service and further efforts to serve notice. The High Court nevertheless proceeded to decide the matter on its merits because the validity of the registered marriage remained in issue and the parties had admittedly not lived together for 16 years.

Court's Observations

Baptism Records Established The Appellant's Christian Faith

The Court found that the Family Court had failed to appreciate the baptism records correctly. The appellant had first been baptised in a Roman Catholic church and was baptised again after deciding to follow the Pentecostal faith. His parents' records also supported his case that he was born into a Christian family.

The Bench explained that baptism is not confined to a person converting to Christianity and may also occur when a person born into a Christian family joins another Christian community or church. It observed: “The Trial Court failed to appreciate that baptism is a religious ceremony performed not only in the case of a person converting to Christianity but also in the case of a person born into a Christian family.”

The Court further held that a name commonly associated with a particular faith could not determine a person's religious identity. Government identity documents did not disprove the appellant's claim because none recorded his religion. The Court held that he was a Christian at the time of the alleged marriage.

No Marriage Ceremony Preceded The Registration

The marriage certificate recorded the appellant's caste as “Hindu”, although Hinduism is a religion and not a caste. The Court observed that the Registrar ought to have recorded the specific caste and that an effort to verify the correct particulars would have revealed that the appellant was not a Hindu. The respondent had not pleaded that a ceremony took place at the venue recorded in the certificate or established compliance with the statutory requirements for a Hindu marriage.

The respondent had admitted during cross-examination that no marriage ceremony had taken place and that “yes” had been entered in the relevant column only for registration. The Court held: “Therefore, on the face of it, the particulars mentioned in the certificate are false. Hence, we conclude that the marriage has not been solemnized before registration by following the Hindu customary rites and ceremonies.”

The Court also rejected any possible reliance on Section 7A of the Hindu Marriage Act, which concerns self-respect marriages. That provision could be invoked only where both parties were Hindus. The respondent had neither pleaded a self-respect marriage nor produced evidence that garlands or rings were exchanged before the Registrar.

Registration Could Not Validate An Interfaith Marriage Under Hindu Law

The Court held that Section 5 of the Hindu Marriage Act permits solemnisation only between two Hindus, while Section 8 of the Act facilitates proof and registration of a Hindu marriage that has already been solemnised. Registration could not create or validate a marriage that the Act itself did not recognise.

Applying that statutory framework, the Bench noted that the marriage had not been solemnised or registered under the Special Marriage Act, 1954. It further found that material facts had been suppressed while obtaining registration under the Hindu Marriage Act and stated: “Such registration will not grant legal recognition to the marriage.”

Procedures Governing A Marriage Involving A Christian Were Not Followed

Since the appellant was a Christian, the Court examined the Indian Christian Marriage Act, 1872. Sections 38 to 42 of the Act address notice, certificates, personal appearance, oath and consent, while Sections 50 to 54 of the Act govern the certificate, solemnisation period and registration.

The Court observed: “Section 4 of the Indian Christian Marriage Act, 1872, provides that every marriage between persons, one or both of whom is or are Christian, shall be solemnised in accordance with the provisions of the Act and that any such marriage solemnised otherwise than in accordance with those provisions shall be void.” The alleged marriage had not been solemnised or registered in accordance with that Act.

The Court separately examined the Special Marriage Act. Sections 4 to 14 of the Act govern solemnisation, while Sections 15, 16 and 18 of the Act address registration of marriages celebrated in other forms and its legal effect. The Court stated: “Thus, the Special Marriage Act provides a statutory mechanism for solemnisation of inter-religious marriages and also recognises registration of marriages celebrated in other forms, subject to the conditions and procedures prescribed therein.” Those procedures had also not been followed.

Precedents Supported The Finding

The Court relied on Gullipilli Sowria Raj v. Bandaru Pavani (2009), in which the Supreme Court considered a Hindu-Christian marriage performed under Hindu customs. The reproduced passage stated that “the marriage solemnised in accordance with Hindu customs was a nullity, and its registration under Section 8 of the Act could not and/or did not validate the same.”

It also referred to Jeyakumari v. Stephen, in which a Division Bench had stated: “A marriage between the Hindu and a Christian is possible only under either the Christian Marriage Act or under the Special Marriage Act.” The Court held that both decisions applied.

The Bench disagreed with the appellant's allegation that he had no knowledge of the registration. However, that factual conclusion did not alter the legal position that the registration was void.

Registrars Directed To Verify Particulars And Follow Due Procedure

The Court noted that it had taken 16 years to secure a declaration that the void registration was void. To prevent similar litigation, it directed the Inspector General of Registration to forward the order to all notified marriage registrars in Tamil Nadu, “who shall ensure that only true particulars are entered and the registration is done after following the due procedures under law.”

Conclusion

The High Court set aside the Family Court's judgment and decree, declared the disputed marriage registration null and void and allowed the appeal without costs. It directed the Inspector General of Registration to circulate the order to all notified marriage registrars in Tamil Nadu so that only true particulars were entered and registrations were completed after following due legal procedure.

The Registry was also directed to circulate the order to every Family Court in the State for information and guidance.

Cause Title: A.N.K. v. K.V. (Neutral Citation: 2026:MHC:4630)

Click here to read/download Judgment

Tags: