Remand Under Order XLI Rule 23A CPC Is A Retrial, Not De Novo Trial; Earlier Evidence Remains Intact: Madras High Court
The Court added that after remand, additional evidence must remain focused on the issues identified by the Appellate Court, while previously examined witnesses retain their original ranks.
Justice N. Anand Venkatesh, Madras High Court
The Madras High Court has held that a remand under Order XLI Rule 23A of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC), results in a retrial and not a de novo trial.
The High Court further clarified that the evidence recorded before remand does not get wiped out; any evidence subsequently recorded is additional evidence that must be considered with the original record.
The Court was hearing a civil revision petition under Article 227 of the Constitution challenging an order of the Principal Subordinate Court that had refused to correct the rank assigned to a previously examined witness and the numbering of documents following the remand of a partition suit.
A Bench of Justice N. Anand Venkatesh observed: “A careful reading of the judgments of the Delhi High Court, the Calcutta High Court and the Kerala High Court makes it clear that the term ‘re-trial’ does not mean re-institution of the suit. There is a marked difference between a re-trial and a de novo trial. In a de novo trial, the entire evidence gets wiped off and the suit is decided afresh on merits.”
The Court further observed: “In view of the same, in no case where the Appellate Court remands the matter to the Trial Court in exercise of jurisdiction under Order XLI Rule 23A, the evidence already recorded gets wiped out. It will remain intact and after remand, the evidence that is recorded will only be considered as additional evidence, which will be taken into consideration along with the original evidence recorded at the time of appreciation of the evidence.”
Advocate Sharath Chandran appeared for the petitioners. Advocate P. Dinesh Kumar, representing Advocate D. Ravichander, appeared for the respondent.
Background
The respondent’s partition suit seeking a one-fifth share was dismissed by the Trial Court. The Principal District Court allowed her appeal and remanded the suit after finding that all properties and necessary parties had not been included. It permitted their inclusion and directed the Trial Court to expedite the proceedings.
After remand, a witness who had previously been examined as the second plaintiff witness was examined as the first plaintiff witness. Sixteen documents were also marked through him as Ex.A.1 to Ex.A.16.
The petitioners, who were defendants in the suit, sought correction of the witness’s rank and the exhibit numbering. The Trial Court dismissed their application on the ground that the Appellate Court had directed a retrial and that the evidence consequently had to be taken afresh.
Before the High Court, the petitioners argued that a retrial could not be equated with a de novo trial. They submitted that the earlier evidence remained on record and that further evidence and documents could only be treated as additional material. The respondent contended that the use of “retrial” in Rule 23A contemplated a de novo trial because the earlier decree had been set aside and the suit remanded for fresh disposal.
Court’s Observations
Rule 23A Had To Be Understood Independently
Tracing the legislative history of appellate remands, the Court noted that Rule 23A was inserted through the 1976 amendment to widen the power to remand cases decided otherwise than on a preliminary point when the decree was reversed and a retrial was considered necessary.
Explaining its interpretive approach, the Court stated: “In order to understand this term, it is not necessary for this Court to place reliance upon the last limb of Order XLI Rule 23 after the semi colon portion.”
The Court held that Rule 23A addressed a situation distinct from Rule 23 and had to be interpreted independently.
De Novo Trial Was Confined To Exceptional Cases
The Court considered the decisions of the Delhi, Calcutta and Kerala High Courts and the Supreme Court’s decision in Satyajit Banerjee v. State of West Bengal (2005). Those authorities distinguished a retrial, which revives the pending proceeding and retains the earlier record, from a de novo trial, where the proceedings begin afresh.
Recording the additional limitation drawn from Satyajit Banerjee, the Court observed: “The Hon’ble Apex Court held that a de novo trial can be ordered only by the Constitutional Courts in cases where the trial was found to be a farce, which was described as a mock trial and that in so far as the re-trial is concerned, the entire trial cannot be erased or wiped off from the records and it has to be considered along with the additional evidence recorded by the Trial Court after remand.”
The Court consequently held that the scheme of Rule 23A did not empower an Appellate Court to order a de novo trial. It could order only a retrial in cases falling within the provision.
Additional Evidence Had To Address The Remand Grounds
The Trial Court was required to read the appellate judgment, identify the matters that had prompted the remand and confine further evidence and documents to those areas. The Court relied on Sanatan Mohapatra v. Hakim Mohammad Kazim Mohammad (1977) to hold that fresh evidence should not be taken on every issue merely because the suit had been remanded.
As a procedural safeguard, the Court stated: “The rank of the witnesses already examined must be maintained even when they are recalled for further evidence.”
Existing documents did not require fresh marking. Additional documents could receive new exhibit numbers, while a new witness rank could be assigned only when a party examined an additional witness.
Present Remand Did Not Authorise A Fresh Evidentiary Record
The Court found that the earlier appellate judgment had remanded the suit only to permit the plaintiff to implead all necessary parties and include all relevant properties. The Trial Court was therefore required to focus further evidence on those identified matters and appreciate it together with the evidence recorded before remand.
Clarifying when a new witness rank could be used, the Court directed: “New rank to the witnesses shall be assigned only in case where additional witnesses are examined by either of the parties.”
The Trial Court had therefore erred in treating the earlier evidentiary record as displaced and assigning a fresh rank to a witness who had already been examined before remand.
Conclusion
The High Court allowed the civil revision petition and set aside the Trial Court’s order. It directed that witnesses examined before remand retain their original ranks when recalled and that existing documents need not be marked again. New exhibit numbers could be assigned only to additional documents, while new ranks could be assigned only to additional witnesses.
The Trial Court was directed to assess the evidence recorded before remand together with the additional evidence, keep the purpose of the remand in view and deliver its final judgment within four months of receiving the High Court’s order. The Court made no order as to costs and closed the connected miscellaneous petition.
Cause Title: Andalammal and Others v. Djealatchoumy (Neutral Citation: 2026:MHC:4565)
Appearances
Petitioners: Sharath Chandran, Advocate
Respondent: P. Dinesh Kumar, Advocate, for D. Ravichander, Advocate