Justice Anant Ramanath Hegde, Karnataka High Court 

The Karnataka High Court has held that an insufficiently stamped instrument is admissible in evidence in criminal proceedings under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (NI Act), as such proceedings do not fall under the chapters of the Code of Criminal Procedure excluded by Section 34(c) of the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957.

The Court observed that even where a Magistrate chooses to impound an insufficiently stamped instrument, the stamp duty or penalty can be recovered under Section 46 of the Act, but payment of stamp duty cannot be a condition precedent to admitting the document in evidence.

The Court dismissed a criminal petition filed by an accused in a cheque bounce case. He had challenged the orders of the Trial Court and the Sessions Court rejecting his application to reject a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) produced by the complainant as inadequately stamped.

The Bench of Justice Anant Ramanath Hegde observed, “If the case in which the document is tendered in evidence, is not falling under the chapter specifically named in the said clause, then in a criminal proceeding the document is admissible in evidence notwithstanding the fact that it is insufficiently stamped. There is no discretion left to the Magistrate or the Judge trying a criminal case not falling under certain chapters mentioned in Clause(c) to deny the admissibility of an instrument which is not sufficiently stamped.”

Senior Advocate Jayakumar S. Patil appeared for the Petitioner, while Advocate Irshad Ahmed K. appeared for the Respondent.

Brief Facts

The respondent, M/s Grind Stone Crusher LLP, filed a private complaint under Section 138 of the NI Act against the petitioner, the proprietor of a stone crusher unit.

The accused filed an application under Section 58(2) of the Karnataka Stamp Act to reject the document, contending that it was not adequately stamped. The Trial Court rejected the application, holding that the document could be considered for a collateral purpose, and noting that no objection had been raised when it was marked.

The Sessions Court upheld the order, albeit on different grounds. It held that under the proviso to Section 34 read with Section 58(1) of the Act, the admission of an instrument in evidence is barred only in proceedings under Chapters XII and XXXVI of the CrPC. Since Section 138 NI Act proceedings are governed by Chapter XXI, it held that an objection on inadequate stamping cannot be raised. Aggrieved, the accused approached the High Court.

Contentions of the Parties

The petitioner contended that Sections 33 and 34 of the Act, read together, lead to the inevitable conclusion that an insufficiently stamped document is inadmissible in evidence. He argued that the defect goes to the root of the matter and is not cured merely because no objection was raised at the time of marking. He submitted that under clause (a) of the proviso to Section 33(2), the Magistrate has no absolute discretion not to examine the sufficiency of stamp duty and must assign reasons. 

The respondent contended that Sections 33 and 34 do not apply to instruments tendered in criminal proceedings other than those under Chapters XII and XXXVI of the CrPC.

Observations/Findings of the Court

The Court observed that Section 33 deals with the examination and impounding of insufficiently stamped instruments, and “does not deal with the admissibility or inadmissibility of the insufficiently stamped document.” Admissibility is dealt with by Section 34.

Comparing the two provisions, the Court noted that clause (a) of the proviso to Section 33(2) confers a discretion on the Magistrate not to examine or impound an insufficiently stamped instrument in a criminal proceeding outside certain categories. However, “Clause (c) of the Section 34 of the Act, 1957 does not confer any discretion on the Magistrate or the Judge, on the question of admissibility of an insufficiently stamped instrument which is sought to be tendered in evidence.”

On whether the two provisions are inconsistent, the Court held, “Both provisions operate in different fields and serve different purposes.”

It held that even if a document is impounded under Section 33(1), it does not become inadmissible merely because the stamp duty and penalty under Section 34 are not paid. In such a case, the Magistrate may bring the matter to the notice of the competent authority to recover the stamp duty and penalty, “But such exercise does not make the document inadmissible under Section 34 of the Act, 1957.”

The Court also held that, as the CrPC, 1898 was repealed by the CrPC, 1973, which in turn has been replaced by the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, the corresponding chapters of the BNSS have to be read into Sections 33 and 34(c) of the Act.

Noting that the Magistrate had not chosen to impound the document, and applying the ratio in Ravikala H., the Court found no error in the Sessions Judge’s order. It held, “Though the reasons assigned by the Magistrate may not be correct, the order admitting the document in evidence and refusing to impound the document has to be upheld for the reasons assigned in this order.”

Accordingly, the Court dismissed the criminal petition.

Cause Title: Erigala Ram Pula Reddy v. M/s Grind Stone Crusher LLP [Criminal Petition No. 554 of 2026]

Appearances:

Petitioner: Senior Advocate Jayakumar S. Patil and Advocate Anjaneya A.B.

Respondent: Advocate Irshad Ahmed K.

Click here to read/download the Order

Tags: