The Jharkhand High Court has held that where an applicant approaches the court as a natural guardian recognised by law and seeks custody of a minor or ancillary reliefs, the petition cannot be rejected at the threshold merely because no prior declaration under Section 7 of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890 has been obtained. The Court said that Sections 7 and 25 operate in distinct statutory situations, and that an inflexible condition of a prior Section 7 order cannot be imported into Section 25.

Allowing a father’s appeal, the Court set aside the Principal Judge, Family Court, Jamshedpur’s order of March 13, 2024 dismissing his petition as not maintainable. It held that Section 25 is intended to provide a substantive remedy for restoration or regulation of custody, and that it does not require the guardian to be court-appointed.

A Division Bench of Justice Sujit Narayan Prasad and Justice Pradeep Kumar Srivastava observed, “Where the very status of a person as guardian is disputed, or where rival claims requiring adjudication as to guardianship are involved, recourse to Section 7 may become necessary. However, where the applicant approaches the court in the capacity of a natural guardian recognized by law and seeks custody or ancillary reliefs concerning the minor, the petition cannot be rejected at the threshold merely on the ground that no prior declaration under Section 7 has been obtained”.

“The Court is of the considered opinion that Section 25 of the Act, 1890 is intended to provide a substantive remedy for restoration or regulation of custody where a ward has left or has been removed from the custody of a guardian. The provision does not, either expressly or by necessary implication, mandate that such guardian must necessarily be a court appointed guardian”, the Bench said further.

Advocate Indrajit Sinha appeared for the appellant and Advocate Sumeet Gadodia appeared for the respondent.

The parties married in December 2017 and have a son born in 2020. According to the appellant-father, the child lived with him at Chandigarh until August 2022. The respondent-mother returned to Jamshedpur on August 3, 2022 and, on August 6, 2022, lodged an FIR alleging offences under Sections 498A, 506 and 34 IPC and the Dowry Prohibition Act, which the father described as false. The father stated that on August 20, 2022 he handed the child to the mother at the police station on the Investigating Officer’s direction, and that the child has since lived with her.

The father then filed an Original Suit under Section 25 of the Act for custody, and later applied under Section 12 for visitation. The Family Court dismissed the suit at the admission stage, recording that the father had never been appointed a guardian by any court, that the child was with the mother who was herself a natural guardian, and that the petition ought to have been filed under Section 7 read with Section 17. The father appealed under Section 19(1) of the Family Courts Act, 1984.

The High Court compared the two provisions. Section 7, it said, concerns appointing or declaring a guardian, while Section 25 deals with the return of a ward who has left or been removed from a guardian’s custody. It held that under Section 25 there is “no need of a declaration of a guardian either to the mother or the father,” as the child was earlier under the care of one of them.

The Court said that the mother being also a natural guardian does not, by itself, extinguish the appellant’s status as a natural guardian. It added that where the very status of a person as guardian is disputed, or rival claims on guardianship require adjudication, recourse to Section 7 “may become necessary.” It noted the proviso to Section 6(a) of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956 but said the welfare of the minor is paramount.

The Court quashed the March 13, 2024 order and revived the suit for adjudication after giving both parties an opportunity. It directed the Family Court to decide the matter independently and to consider the pending Section 12 application, passing appropriate interim visitation directions if warranted. The Court clarified that its observations are confined to maintainability and that no opinion is expressed on custody or the allegations.

Cause Title: DS v. V (Neutral Citation: 2026:JHHC:31659-DB)

Appearances:

Appellant: Indrajit Sinha, Ajay Kumar Sah and Peeya Bhatia, Advocates.

Respondent: Sumeet Gadodia, K.S. Nanda, Prakhar Harit and Anish Lal, Advocates.

Click here to read/download the Judgment


Tags: