Minority Institution’s Power To Appoint Without Prior Approval Does Not Dispense With Statutory Eligibility Requirements For Grant-In-Aid: Delhi High Court
Setting aside rejection of grant-in-aid for all 100 appointments by Delhi Tamil Education Association, the Court held that such collective rejection “cannot be sustained” and directed appointment-wise scrutiny.
Justice Sanjeev Narula, Delhi High Court
The Delhi High Court has held that the authority of an aided linguistic minority institution to make appointments without prior departmental approval must be distinguished from the eligibility of those appointments for grant-in-aid, and does not dispense with compliance with the statutory requirements governing recruitment and eligibility.
Partly allowing two connected petitions, the Court set aside the Directorate of Education’s order rejecting grant-in-aid for all 100 appointments made by the Delhi Tamil Education Association, holding that such collective rejection could not be sustained, and directed appointment-wise scrutiny through reasoned orders.
A Bench of Justice Sanjeev Narula observed, “The management’s authority to make appointments without prior departmental approval must be distinguished from the eligibility of those appointments for grantin-aid. The former does not dispense with compliance with the statutory requirements governing recruitment and eligibility. At the same time, the department cannot, under the guise of examining eligibility for State aid, assume control over the management’s choice of candidates or impose restrictions inconsistent with its rights under Article 30(1) of the Constitution…”.
Advocate Kartikeye Dang appeared for the association, Senior Advocate Diya Kapur appeared for the employees, while Avnish Ahlawat, Standing Counsel appeared for the government.
The Association administers seven aided minority schools receiving 95% grant-in-aid towards salaries. After earlier judgments upheld its right to fill vacancies without prior approval, it recruited 100 teaching and non-teaching staff. The Directorate rejected grant-in-aid for all appointments on November 4, 2025, citing deficiencies. The Association challenged this, while the employees sought unpaid salaries.
The Court held that the right under Article 30(1) of the Constitution of India includes appointing staff, but not “the right to maladminister”, and the State may prescribe eligibility and conditions for proper use of aid. The second proviso to Rule 98(2) of the Delhi School Education Rules, 1973 dispenses with approval, it said, but not with prescribed qualifications or a sanctioned vacancy.
On Assistant Teachers, it held that the 1989 Recruitment Rules applied and B.Ed. without JBT/BTC does not satisfy the essential training requirement. It rejected the objection to direct recruitment of Principals, holding that minority management’s right to choose the Head is protected, and held the Directorate could not impose its own marking scheme where none is prescribed.
The Court held that the Directorate’s failure to nominate representatives could not invalidate selection, but that compliance with Rule 96(3)(b) must be verified school-wise. It found the Rule 98(4) deemed-approval claim could not be decided without examining communications for each appointment.
On remuneration, it held that the State’s liability to fund appointments is distinct from the institution’s liability to pay for services rendered, and that clauses postponing salary until receipt of aid cannot extinguish the latter.
The Directorate must designate an officer not below Additional Director, complete the exercise within twelve weeks, and pass a separate reasoned order for each employee. Where aid is admissible, it must release its 95% share within four weeks of each determination.
Cause Title: Delhi Tamil Education Association (Regd.) v. Government of NCT of Delhi & Anr. (Neutral Citation: 2026:DHC:10169)
Appearances:
Appellant: Kartikeye Dang, Advocate.
Respondents: Avnish Ahlawat, Standing Counsel, with N.K. Singh, Aliza Alam, Mohnish Sehrawat and Ananya Saxena, Kartik Sharma, Manhan Chalwa and Pearl Sharma, Advocates