Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma, Delhi High Court

The Delhi High Court has held that a petitioner’s residence in Delhi does not, by itself, confer territorial jurisdiction upon it to order the de-indexing of a decision passed by another High Court when no material, essential or integral part of the cause of action arose within Delhi.

The High Court accordingly dismissed a doctor’s petition seeking de-indexing of a Gauhati High Court bail order.

The Court was hearing a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution by a doctor who had been discharged from a criminal case in Assam. The petitioner sought directions requiring Google and Indian Kanoon to restrict name-based searches connected with a bail order passed by the Gauhati High Court while retaining access through other identifiers.

A Bench of Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma observed: “Thus, in view of the foregoing discussion, this Court is of the opinion that no material, essential or integral part of the cause of action has arisen within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court. The mere facts that the petitioner resides in Delhi or that the bail order in question is accessible on the internet from Delhi cannot confer territorial jurisdiction upon this Court, when the order sought to be de-indexed has been passed by the High Court of Gauhati, and the entire criminal proceedings, from the registration of the FIR till the discharge of the petitioner, have taken place within the State of Assam. Even otherwise, this Court is of the view that the High Court of Gauhati is the forum conveniens for adjudication of the grievance raised by the petitioner.”

Advocate Rudra Deosthali appeared for the petitioner. Central Government Standing Counsel Amrita Prakash represented the Union of India, while Advocate Apar Gupta appeared for Indian Kanoon.

Background

The petitioner was arrested following the registration of a criminal case in Assam and was subsequently granted bail by the Gauhati High Court. A charge-sheet was later filed only for the offence under Section 498A of the Indian Penal Code, 1860, but the jurisdictional Magistrate found the charge groundless and discharged the petitioner. According to the petitioner, the discharge order attained finality.

The petitioner stated that a name-based Google search continued to display the Gauhati High Court’s bail order through a link hosted by Indian Kanoon. Claiming continuing prejudice to reputation and informational privacy, the petitioner sought global de-indexing of the order from name-based searches and corresponding restrictions on Indian Kanoon. The petitioner also sought liberty to approach the courts concerned for masking personal identifiers.

The petitioner argued that the Delhi High Court possessed jurisdiction because the petitioner resided in Delhi and could access the order there. Reliance was placed on an earlier Delhi High Court decision concerning de-indexing of online reports about a settled matrimonial dispute.

The respondents raised a preliminary objection to territorial jurisdiction. They submitted that the bail order had been passed by the Gauhati High Court and that the FIR, arrest, charge-sheet and discharge had all occurred in Assam.

Court’s Observations

Residence Was Not An Integral Part Of The Cause Of Action

The Court observed that Article 226(2) of the Constitution permits a High Court to exercise jurisdiction when the cause of action arises wholly or partly within its territory. The pleaded fact must, however, constitute a material, essential or integral part of the cause of action and have a nexus with the relief sought.

Applying that test, the Court stated: “As regards the residence of the petitioner in Delhi, in view of the settled position of law discussed above, the same is not a material or integral part of the cause of action, and cannot by itself confer territorial jurisdiction on this Court.”

The facts essential to the de-indexing claim were the criminal case, the Gauhati High Court’s bail order, the subsequent charge-sheet and the discharge order. Each arose in Assam, where the relevant judicial records were also situated.

Internet Accessibility Could Not Create Nationwide Jurisdiction

The Court noted that an uploaded judicial order is accessible throughout India and beyond. Treating its accessibility at every location as part of the cause of action would render the territorial limitation in Article 226(2) ineffective and encourage forum shopping.

It observed: “If the mere accessibility of a digitised judicial record at a particular place were to be treated as an integral part of the cause of action, every High Court in the country would possess the jurisdiction to entertain a petition seeking de-indexing of a judicial record of any other Court, irrespective of where the proceedings were conducted or where the record was created.”

Earlier De-Indexing Decision Was Distinguishable

The Court distinguished the precedent cited by the petitioner. That case involved online news reports published by national media organisations for a nationwide readership, certain respondents situated in Delhi and formal notices seeking deletion and de-indexing.

By contrast, the Court noted: “In the present case, there is no news report or other publication of which the petitioner complains.” The only impugned content was a Gauhati High Court order reproduced on Indian Kanoon as part of that Court’s judicial record.

The present grievance therefore concerned another High Court’s judicial record rather than independent news reportage.

Gauhati High Court Was The Forum Conveniens

The Court held that even if a slender part of the cause of action were assumed to have arisen in Delhi, the discretionary doctrine of forum conveniens favoured the Gauhati High Court.

It explained: “Any direction which would regulate the manner in which a judicial record of that Court is accessed or searched would, in the considered opinion of this Court, be most appropriately examined by that Court itself.”

Entertaining the petition in Delhi could result in the same judicial record being considered by two High Courts and create the possibility of overlapping or conflicting directions. The petitioner’s own prayer seeking liberty to approach the court concerned for masking also recognised the connection with the Gauhati High Court.

Conclusion

The Delhi High Court dismissed the petition and pending applications for lack of territorial jurisdiction. It left the petitioner free to pursue remedies available in accordance with law, including by approaching the Gauhati High Court.

The Court clarified that it had expressed no opinion on the merits of the de-indexing request. It also directed that the judgment be uploaded immediately.

Cause Title: A.T. v. Union of India and Others (Neutral Citation: 2026:DHC:10254)

Appearances

Petitioner: Rudra Deosthali, Gautam Swarup and Sakshi Pandey, Advocates

Respondents: Amrita Prakash, Central Government Standing Counsell Apar Gupta, Pragya Jain, Naman Kumar, Sahil Mander and Rahul, Advocates

Click here to read/download Judgment

Tags: